New Holland or John Deere? Which one to buy?

   / New Holland or John Deere? Which one to buy? #21  
New Holland Ag - Library Login

see if you can check this link out, it compares to john deere tractors, the TT-A series is a much roomy tractor on the deck compared to a deere. it comes standard with one rear hydraulic remote, i dont know if deere does, ease of service on the new holland is much better and easy to service and maintence the tractor. good luck
 
   / New Holland or John Deere? Which one to buy? #22  
New Holland Ag - Library Login

see if you can check this link out, it compares to john deere tractors, the TT-A series is a much roomy tractor on the deck compared to a deere. it comes standard with one rear hydraulic remote, i dont know if deere does, ease of service on the new holland is much better and easy to service and maintence the tractor. good luck

This seems to be a link only for dealers. do you have a way to make this accessible to nondealers, or could you post the info.

Andy
 
   / New Holland or John Deere? Which one to buy? #23  
let me see what i can do, do you have an email i coudl send an attachment to or something
 
   / New Holland or John Deere? Which one to buy?
  • Thread Starter
#24  
I need the login and password to access the site
 
   / New Holland or John Deere? Which one to buy? #25  
Aranon, I'm also disappointed that you didn't get a true comparison on this thread. I too thought those were popular models and looked forward to reading some "real world" analysis. Sorry it didn't work out..... :confused:
 
   / New Holland or John Deere? Which one to buy? #26  
In my opinion, I would go with the Deere. I have operated several different brands of older tractors for several years. I purchased a 5105 2WD a couple years ago and have been very pleased with it. The 2.9L motor used in the tractor you are looking at is used in several different models and seems to be a very reliable engine. If I were starting over today I would be looking at the same Deere model you are looking at. I would recommend going with the 16.9-28 rear tires, adding a second rear SCV and the extendable draft links. My 5105 is not a turbo engine, but it seems a lot of the newer Deere models are. I do not have anything negative to say about the NH. My local dealer also has been great even though I bought my tractor used. I have since bought a loader from them and their service has been excellent. I think you are in the right area by looking in the 50HP range. These size tractors seem to be very versatile. Good luck in your search.
 
   / New Holland or John Deere? Which one to buy? #27  
if you have an email address i have 3 different attachmetns i can send you
 
   / New Holland or John Deere? Which one to buy?
  • Thread Starter
#29  
I made my decision and bought the Green one. Several things weighed my decision. One was by a freak accident of fate I had to take a detour and drive several miles through the country to get to another highway. On the journey, I saw not one, not two but nine different tractors working or driving down the road that I had to pass. Guess how many of them were green? Eight. One was MF. Was it a hint? Made me think.

The other and main decision was that the John Deere's transmission was better in that I can shift while moving just using the clutch. The New Holland's tranny made you have to stop, change gears and then start off again. On the John Deere you can go forward and then reverse without stopping which will be good when using the bucket/loader. And I like the way the joystick was laid out on the JD. The NH looked like they stuck it up there as an afterthought.

I got the 5055E, with the 563 loader, the bucket, the MX6 med duty shredder, the fork lift package with 48" forks, the quick attach PTO implement changer over package, and a Knife blade for the bucket and a set of remotes on the back for $28,980.00. Oh, and five John Deer Tee Shirts and a cuzy. I told them the T-shirt thing was a deal breaker. Oh, and the stands for the loader.

All in all, I think I got a pretty good deal. It was the best one I could make. Almost the same price as the NH. Plus think of all the JD stuff I can buy at the tractor house. Key chains, Hats, knifes, baby booties, crib pillows, belt buckles, neckerchiefs, toys, little farms, little tiny tractors and backhoes for the grand kids, etc. You can't say that for the other color.

Thanks for all the input, although I really was looking for more. I really thought several people would have owned both of these, but maybe those are the ones who don't log onto sites like this.

I pick it up tomorrow after lunch. I get to play with it over the holidays. At least I got my Christmas present.

Thanks again,

Aranon
 
   / New Holland or John Deere? Which one to buy?
  • Thread Starter
#30  
Oh, I forgot. I got John Deere little tractor lighted Christmas Tree lights to put on the Christmas Tree. I think there are a dozen little tractors. Try to find New Holland lights.
Aranon
 
 
Top