Having read your description eleventy times I still have no idea what you are describing. I am not usually that dense but I seem to have no frame of reference for what you are describing. Are you putting the square perpendicular to the length, or the diameter? What do you mean you measure to the top of the pipe, aren't you cutting the top of the pipe, so shouldn't you be measuring in from the top? I have no idea what you mean by "You should have approximately one third of the pipe original length in the middle of one third cut out at each side." I have done this in the past a couple times and it has been a pretty much guess-work process with me grinding some out and then just cutting out more as required until it fit, so I would love to understand what it is you are doing. From what I remember though, the high sides of the vertical bar reach the center of the horizontal bar, not one third, so I am not sure what is different. Do you have a picture perhaps, so I could set my frame of reference and then try to read your description again? Thanks.