Dog pics

[goeduck]

As long as a shock collar is only used in "shock" mode in emergency situations and as long as the dog acts as expected when being shocked (does not bolt into traffic or whatever), I would say it is better than the alternative (dog getting run over, etc).

We use fences on livestock all the time and we have fewer breaking fences down and getting hit by vehicles, in someone's yard, etc. I am not seeing the issue.

 

[sixdogs]

As long as a shock collar is only used in "shock" mode in emergency situations and as long as the dog acts as expected when being shocked (does not bolt into traffic or whatever), I would say it is better than the alternative (dog getting run over, etc).

We use fences on livestock all the time and we have fewer breaking fences down and getting hit by vehicles, in someone's yard, etc. I am not seeing the issue.

Agreed. These collars have an adjustable "vibrate" function and that's all I have ever used. Shock never enters the picture with a well-behaved dog. The vibrate is for things you speak of such as an emergency situation where the life of the dog is at risk.

I had a dog run over--in front of me-- when I was 12 years old and it was preventable. A collar would have saved it. Never again. A good dog owner is 3/4 of the battle but dogs sometimes do things dogs do.

Vibrate is no big deal but dogs don't like it and just putting the collar on changes their behavior.

 

[Sigarms]

Agreed. These collars have an adjustable "vibrate" function and that's all I have ever used. Shock never enters the picture with a well-behaved dog. The vibrate is for things you speak of such as an emergency situation where the life of the dog is at risk.

I had a dog run over--in front of me-- when I was 12 years old and it was preventable. A collar would have saved it. Never again. A good dog owner is 3/4 of the battle but dogs sometimes do things dogs do.

Vibrate is no big deal but dogs don't like it and just putting the collar on changes their behavior.

I honestly can't remember a dog that would obey directly with a vibration first and only. Generally, you vibrate first, with a quick shock after the vibrate, and depending on the dog, some will pick up faster than others to correlate the vibration with the shock as a negative reinforcement

Thing I like about the dogtra brand is the settings are between 0 to 150 on the "shock setting", so you can find the discomfort level pretty quick at what setting.

Likewise, all dogs being different, some pick up quicker than others from my own experiences if they are wearing the ecollar LOL

That blue tick hound had the ecollar for about 2 years, now he never needs it as he never sneaks off the property anymore.

One dog is about the dumbest dog we've ever had, and he'll probably be wearing it for life LOL

Our biggest issue is the fact that none of our dogs really get a lot of lead work because they are on the property with us.

 

[Sigarms]

Here is the reality with an ecollar.

See the dog licking his chops in the pic below? (brown coat).

Dog was going to be destroyed by the pound. For whatever reason, he's "odd" when it comes to bigger dogs than himself (other than those in our home). He was my neighbors dog, and I'll give the dog the benefit of the doubt and assume he was actually smarter than my neighbor (who has since moved, which I'm grateful for due to numerous reasons). Side note, dog was kept outside off lead 24/7. Within a couple of weeks he's never had an accident in the house, and he's crated at night.

I have another neighbor on the other side of me that lets his dog roam free. Those two dogs do not get along. Without an ecollar, I would not be able to control the situation on my end (with the brown coat dog).

Technically, I could shoot my neighbor's dog because that dog can spend more time on my property than my neighbors at times, but he's (neighbors dog) is really a good dog, it's just that these two do not get along because our neighbors dog doesn't "live" with us, and only visits coming onto our property which the "brown dog" is trying to defend as he now sees our land as "his turf"

With some dogs, no matter how much training, for whatever reason due to their past, they have odd issues that could become big issues down the road. This is where a ecollar shines.

I don't have the money or great "story" to have ceasar millan (sp?) to fly to us and come and make a TV show, nor with both my wife and I working 80 plus hours a week to try and spend time to understand exactly what is going on with this dogs brain to spend every hour trying to train him.

2 notes

1 - When we sell the house will spend big bucks to redo the kitchen LOL

2 - The cat's balls of steel keep getting bigger when he'd down in the kitchen and the dogs are eating.

That brown dog will be wearing a ecollar the rest of his life with us.

If you ever have a dog that you're giving hope on, I'd ALWAYS suggest to try an ecollar for behavior modification.

 

[Jstpssng]

Do they revert as soon as you take the collar off?
I got my first dog at 7 weeks old. My current dog was just a year old when I got him, was grossly underweight and had spent the first part of his life on a chain, his first winter in an unheated garage. Yet of the two he is better behaved, calmer, and won't willingly let me out of his sight. OTOH she was a lot smarter, virtually fearless, grew up in the woods with me and was always at home there. I always knew that she could have done a lot more if I'd known how to train her, and spent the time doing it.

 

[Sigarms]

Do they revert as soon as you take the collar off?

From my experience, the bigger question is what are they reverting back to so quick per their bad bahavior when the collar is off?

The reality is, with that brown dog, I could probably have the collar off him 70% of the time when the neighbor's dog doesn't come onto our property. With my luck, the one time I don't put the collar on him, the neighbor's dog shows up next to our house.

The brown dogs worst behavior is when a "larger" strange dog is "on his turf" (on our property).

At the end of the day, you spend a couple of hundred bucks on a quality collar to try to rid one bad behavior.

Most of the time with us, it's dogs running off. That small little black dog we found as a pup on the road by the house. We have 40 acres and the first thing he did when we let him out of the house was run to the neighbors yard (because the neighbor would throw food scraps out behind his place). Seriously, open the door, and he runs 100 yards under a fence to the neighbors house because of food. Put a small ecollar on him, and he did get zapped a couple of times, but he's not dumb. It stopped the bad behavior of him running to the neighbors yard once we opened the door.

Hope that makes some sense.

 

[Jstpssng]

My biggest reason would be for a dog running off. As I said before, I take a dog into the woods with me. They need to stay close, even if there's something interesting like a deer, bear, or moose attracting their attention. I used to carry a .22 pistol for a dog call; used only in extreme cases it would bring her running.

 

[ArlyA]

Our mutts are trained for leads, but in the woods we never use them. No shock collars ever used but they are trained. They never run off for more than a few minutes. How could that work?

 

[Jstpssng]

^^^
My current dog is like that also. As I said before, the only time that he wears a collar is when he goes to the vet or out in public.
My last dog was the exact opposite... a very alpha female. She would leave the truck wearing a collar but by the end of the day it would be gone.

You could never walk a dog on lead in the places where we go.

 

[Steppenwolfe]

Attachments

• 
  20200313_111332_resized.jpg

  745.8 KB · Views: 237

Attachments

• 
  20200602_162122_resized.jpg

  1.7 MB · Views: 1,072

No worries about these two running off...