JYD,
I thought I would chime in with my experience as I was in the same boat as you about a year ago. I've got 90 acres, had just finished a select-cut harvest, and wanted to put in food plots. I did a lot of screen-time research and ended up with a JD 4320 Cab, Horst Welding Root Grapple (
http://horstwelding.com/hla_items.php?id=112), LandPride 3596 rake, LandPride DH1572 Disc Harrow (with notched blades), Woods BrushBull 720 hog, Woods RB84 rear blade, a FIMCO LG-3025 ATV sprayer, and a 5’ wide (used) ATV tow-behind lime/fertilizer spreader.
Based on my experience turning woods into food plots, I would suggest you make the grapple the highest priority. Since I received the grapple, except for the last few weeks in anticipation of snow removal, I have had the bucket back on the loader a grand total of 15 minutes. I cannot imagine not having the grapple for cleaning up the brush created by a timber harvest. Also, if you can swing it, get the cab. I never thought I would spring for it, but since I did, I have never regretted it (except for a 5 day period after I broke a window doing something stupid with a basketball hoop … but that’s another story.)
I paid an excavator to stump the plots and move the big stumps to the edges. I then went in with my disc harrow and landscape rake. The disc broke things up, and the rake moved much of the loose sticks off to the side. My plots are only a few acres, so I was able to rake the debris off the plot reasonably well. You will never get it all, but who cares? This was much easier than picking everything up, one by one – though I did do some of that with help from my boys, before I got smarter and used the rake. The AC in the cab made everything seem easier.
After the clearing, I sprayed roundup to kill everything, and put down many tons of lime and fertilizer as per the soil test recommendations. After a couple of weeks, I made several passes with the disc to really break things up, then simply spread the seed with a hand-held spreader. For small plots, the hand-held spreader gave me great control.
The end result was great. Seed germination was great, and the deer & turkey really hit the plot as it matured. I was originally thinking I would attempt to plow it next year … but I think I might just let the roots alone. I’m afraid a plow will just rip up and expose roots that I will then need to clear. Besides, it came up great, and the deer certainly do not mind the few roots sticking up here and there.
Sorry about the long-winded response. There are probably better ways that the way I did it, but it seemed to work for me. I hope this helps.
Bob