5030 "skidder" pics - the "tree-bota" in action

   / 5030 "skidder" pics - the "tree-bota" in action
  • Thread Starter
#31  
Re: 5030 \"skidder\" pics - the \"tree-bota\" in action

This is an overhead shot of the "operator's station". It shows how handy all the controls are. I never did show the loader joystick with the rocker switch for the front grapple; it replaced the stock loader handle. You can see the rear grapple joystick to the right of the seat.
 

Attachments

  • 779879-IMG_0288.JPG
    779879-IMG_0288.JPG
    75.6 KB · Views: 695
   / 5030 "skidder" pics - the "tree-bota" in action #32  
Re: 5030 \"skidder\" pics - the \"tree-bota\" in action

How about the hookup to the hydraulics? Inquiring minds want to know. Cost? And even a picture of the front HSV would be handy. Thanks
 
   / 5030 "skidder" pics - the "tree-bota" in action
  • Thread Starter
#33  
Re: 5030 \"skidder\" pics - the \"tree-bota\" in action

Highbeam - I am going to provide much additional information to this thread as soon as possible, including more pics, descriptions and especially the costs involved with going with HSV's (hydraulic solenoid valves) and the electrical controls that activate them (joysticks, push-buttons, rocker switches etc) that would replace the venerable "remote" lever.

I just got off the phone with my tractor guy who installed my hydraulics to double-check the cost factors with him, having been unable to put my hands on my invoice from the installation job. The short answer on cost is that the triple Vickers HSV was probably about 500 bucks, and the joystick that controls it might have been 100-150 bucks. With installation, hoses, fittings, brackets et al, the costs involved are in the same ballpark as conventional remotes.

Here is a link to a very interesting thread in which it becomes obvious that speaking of "buttons", this subject of HSV's vs. remotes seems to have a way of pushing them. Remotes and top-and-tilt There seems to be a school of thought that people don't want to be bothered with this, and just want to do the simplest thing, i.e. remotes. For the possible benefit of those reading this who would like to know about an alternative to conventional remotes which I believe has many irrefutable advantages, I will continue to provide as much hard information as I can.

This reminds me very much about another hot-button issue, conventional (aka "dino") oil vs. synthetics. Just as there is a wealth of data supporting the fact that dino oils have been doing a very good job of protecting engines for billions of miles, there is also a solid body of scientific evidence proving some of the indisputable advantages of synthetics.

Similarly, while remotes have been the "industry standard" for controlling hydraulic functions for many, many years, there are some indisputable advantages to using solenoids.

There also seems to be a school of thought that since remotes have been the standard way of doing things for many years, and have given reliable service all that time, that they are a better choice for tractor buyers, "novice" or otherwise. I would offer that technology is advancing all the time, often out-pacing attitudes. Western Union was slow to get into the field of telephony because they didn't think people needed to communicate in "real time" - that the telegraph had met there needs very nicely, and would continue to do so. Detroit fought seat belts and air bags for years, and now they are welcomed by most consumers. Mules gave way to tractors, propeller-driven airplanes to jets, snail mail to email, buttons to zippers.

On my tractor, remotes gave way to solenoids. They cost about the same as remotes, and are an improvement over them in many ways. What we all do to our machines is a very personal thing, and my intent is not to recruit "converts". I just think they're a great way to go, and offer them as a very attractive alternative.

More to come, John D.
 
   / 5030 "skidder" pics - the "tree-bota" in action #34  
Re: 5030 \"skidder\" pics - the \"tree-bota\" in action

John, I am anxiously awaiting a good HSV write up. I like your remote hydraulic system and want to know more about them. Cost and especially how to plumb into the OEM hydraulics. In return, I promise not to argue about HSV vs. OEM remotes. /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif
 
   / 5030 "skidder" pics - the "tree-bota" in action
  • Thread Starter
#35  
Re: 5030 \"skidder\" pics - the \"tree-bota\" in action

Highbeam et al -

Sorry for the delay, you truly have the patience of Job, both with the slow pace of my replies, and with my love for the written word. This thread will soon be coming out in hardcover, reserve a copy today! /forums/images/graemlins/laugh.gif

I would have replied sooner, but I keep getting interrupted by pesky customers - they keep yammering about their trees, and don't seem to realize that I have more important things to do, like talk about my tractor. /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif

I'll post more pics very, very soon - tomorrow probably. Closeups of the front solenoid, rear solenoids, "plumbing" and anything else that might help. The front solenoid pic will be very unremarkable, as it just looks like many of the other pics posted by others who have used solenoids for the front.

I'm also going to post an in-depth explanation of exactly what a solenoid is, how it controls hydraulic flow, how it is activated by various controllers like joysticks and rocker switches, and how the controllers work. An HSV setup is no more complicated to use than a video game, and just as much fun. It's all really very simple, no need to be intimidated by it.

Mentioning how unremarkable the front solenoid is prompts me to say something that I have been thinking about quite a bit, and that is to express some curiousity about why electric solenoids are so commonly used and widely accepted for attachments on the front of a tractor, but are not given the same warm welcome when proposed for the back. A large part of the answer is of course that remotes are usually on the back (though some are mid-mount), and therefore don't lend themselves very well to controlling a hydraulic attachment on the front. But what's good for the front is good for the back. For top and tilt, a grapple, hydraulic scarifiers on a box blade, chute rotator, blade angler, you name it. Picture a three-function joystick controlling top, tilt and hydraulic scarifiers on a box blade, all three functions controlled with one hand never leaving the joystick as you move along. Or controlling a rear grapple like mine with 3 functions. SO much more convenient than moving three separate closely-spaced remote levers, for about the same cost. Electric solenoids are common, standard even, on many of the larger machines, and I think they are going to find themselves on more and more CUTs.

But here I go again, straying from the nitty-gritty.

In the next post(s) I'll address costs (again, quite comparable to remotes), where to get the various components (lots of places), "plumbing", and how to find someone who is well-versed in installing HSV's on tractors, as well as post more pictures.
 
   / 5030 "skidder" pics - the "tree-bota" in action
  • Thread Starter
#36  
Re: 5030 \"skidder\" pics - the \"tree-bota\" in action

I'm going to post 5 more pics, including this one that shows a closeup the rear solenoids, a triple "gang" of Vickers with 1/2" ports. The other four pics will show the front solenoid mounted on the r/h loader frame, the front hoses that go to and from the front grapple, the rear hoses that go to and from the rear solenoids, and how the hoses are routed under the right side of the tractor.

For those unfamiliar with hydraulic solenoids, or solenoids in general, I'm going to include a description of what they are and how they work. It's really pretty simple. Most of this is from a post I made in another thread partly in response to this question: " I like the sound of having the functionality of the solenoids but still do not completely understand it?" Bear in mind that you don't have to completely understand it, and if you wanted HSV's on your tractor all you would have to do is print out this thread and bring it, and your preferably remote-less tractor, to the right person. They are out there.

A hydraulic solenoid valve (I'm going to call it an HSV from now on) has two joined halves. Half of it is an electric solenoid, the other half is the valve body that the hydraulic fluid flows through and in and out of the ports. The ports (1/2" usually, for the flow rates of most CUTs) conduct the fluid in the valve body into the hydraulic hoses that you screw into them using the same type of hose and fittings as you would use with remotes.

The general definition of a solenoid is an electrical component that moves a lever, or moves something, when current is applied to it, 12 volts in this case. (A typical automotive application is a starter solenoid, that moves a gear that engages with and spins the ring gear on the flywheel when you turn the key). A joystick, as I have been referring to it, is just a handle that sends the electric current to the appropriate solenoid through sets of contacts that get closed or opened when you move the joystick in different directions. If you wanted a box blade to come up, you'd push the handle forward. 12 volts would go to the solenoid that's connected to the valve body that the hose going to that cylinder is attached to, and the box blade comes up. When the solenoid receives the 12 volts, a lever opens or closes a valve in the valve body, allowing or not allowing the pressurized (around 2,500 psi) hydraulic fluid to flow throught the port and through the hose. So pushing the joystick forward accomplishes the same as pushing a "remote" lever forward.

The only limit to how many HSV's you can have is how many do you need and where to locate them. It's wide open. You can have single ones, like the one that operates my front grapple, that is controlled by the rocker switch on my loader handle. My front grapple has only one hydraulic function - open/close. [Any attachment with only one hydraulic function requires just ONE HSV or remote to operate it. Either one would perform BOTH the open and close, or left and right, or up and down, whatever. You don't need one valve to do one direction of the function, and another valve to do the other]. My rear grapple itself has two hydraulic functions - grapple arms open/closed, and lift arms/lower arms. I have a triple bank of Vickers HSV's mounted behind the seat on the ROPS. The four hoses to handle these two functions go into two of the valve bodies on them. The third HSV will control the hydraulic top-link cylinder that I am going to add. The joystick to the right of my seat, where the remote levers would have been, controls (sends current) to one, two, or all three of the HSV's depending on how the joystick is moved in its two axes (clockwise from 9:00 - left, left-forward, forward, forward-right, right, right-rear, rear, rear-left), or whether or not the rocker switch on the top of the joystick is activated. When the joystick is moved left, right, forward or back, one solenoid is energized, moving one cylinder. In the other positions, two are energized at the same time, moving two cylinders simultaneously. The rocker switch on the top of the joystick will energize the third HSV that will operate the top link cylinder, to give the rear grapple greater range of motion.

You can put HSV's wherever you want them, in any configuration. A single, double, triple, quad, any combination. Then just send current to them using any type of joystick or other control you want, selected for ergonomics, size, shape, number of buttons, whatever or however you want to control whatever implement. My front loader uses a single HSV. A triple was perfect for the rear grapple, so the joystick I selected has 3 functions too.

When I was researching my tractor purchase, I thought a lot about how I was actually going to control the attachments, grapples in this case. I decided that I did not want to have to throw individual levers to control one function at a time. It would have been a royal pain to close, then lower, then maybe close some more, or open a little, or lift some, all while reaching for different handles. I already knew about HSV's, they're on a lot of machines. Many front grapples on the tractors here on TBN for instance. Some have diverter valve setups which I did not want because of the extra button pushing and loss of the function that's being diverted away from. Once I realized that I didn't want remotes, I just started calling and asking around until I found someone who knew what I was talking about, and assured me that this was right up his alley. Anyone reading this can find someone too, it's just a matter of how far you will have to travel. I had to go about 25 miles. As they say, your mileage may vary.
 

Attachments

  • 786363-IMG_1056.jpg
    786363-IMG_1056.jpg
    86.7 KB · Views: 472
   / 5030 "skidder" pics - the "tree-bota" in action
  • Thread Starter
#37  
Re: 5030 \"skidder\" pics - the \"tree-bota\" in action

This shows how the solenoid that controls the front grapple is mounted on the lower right-hand side of the loader support. It's tucked neatly out of the way and it doesn't interfere with anything. To look at it, you'd think it grew there.

Notice the wire coming in from the left of the picture, throught the cowling on the instrument panel. That wire comes from the rocker switch on the loader handle and carries the signal that causes hydraulic fluid to flow one way or the other through the valve body to open or close the front grapple.
 

Attachments

  • 786382-IMG_1089a.jpg
    786382-IMG_1089a.jpg
    94.8 KB · Views: 440
   / 5030 "skidder" pics - the "tree-bota" in action
  • Thread Starter
#38  
Re: 5030 \"skidder\" pics - the \"tree-bota\" in action

This pic shows how the hoses are routed to the front grapple. They largely share the same route as the hoses for the loader , then go to a bracket mounted between the loader arms. They end in two Bobcat-style quick disconnects that the grapple hoses plug into.
 

Attachments

  • 786389-IMG_1094b.jpg
    786389-IMG_1094b.jpg
    93.3 KB · Views: 405
   / 5030 "skidder" pics - the "tree-bota" in action
  • Thread Starter
#39  
Re: 5030 \"skidder\" pics - the \"tree-bota\" in action

This shows how the supply and return hoses come up to the rear solenoids. One hose, probably the supply, comes from the front of the front solenoid. The other hose goes to the 10 o'clock position of the hydraulic junction block shown in the next picture. They are neatly tucked out of the way, and have never interfered with anything. Again, it seems like they "grew" there.
 

Attachments

  • 786400-IMG_1083a.jpg
    786400-IMG_1083a.jpg
    81.2 KB · Views: 377
   / 5030 "skidder" pics - the "tree-bota" in action #40  
Re: 5030 \"skidder\" pics - the \"tree-bota\" in action

Thanks for the pictures Ct that helps out....
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2004 Sterling Tack Truck (A52384)
2004 Sterling Tack...
7033 (A51691)
7033 (A51691)
1982 GOOSENECK 24FT TRAILER (A52472)
1982 GOOSENECK...
4"x8' Treated Post, 36 Piece Bundle (A52384)
4"x8' Treated...
2008 Chevrolet Suburban SUV (A51694)
2008 Chevrolet...
2005 Caterpillar 430D 4x4 Extendahoe Backhoe Loader (A51691)
2005 Caterpillar...
 
Top