Amsoil vs. Delvac 1

   / Amsoil vs. Delvac 1 #41  
GrantMO – Well I am assuming (which is bad from the start to assume) you mean 3000 or 5000 miles and not hours. Here is how I would answer your questions. (1) If you are going only 5,000 miles on synthetic and 3,000 miles on regular oil you are wasting money in both applications. The only answer I will give you is that no car manufacture states that you must go 3,000 then change oil and filter! This is the biggest myth out there! If you are using gas engine the miles will be around 7,000 miles and if diesel it will be around 5,000 miles. These values are all using regular oil. If you use synthetic you can safely double in diesel and triple in gas engines. Again that is if your automobile is running in the proper state. (2) yes it would make sense to change to synthetic HYD fluid because if will have less chatter, better in cold temps and will [in general] lower HYD temps around 20 degrees. This result is longer life for rear end. (3) yes and no. Some companies like Amsoil and Fleetguard require that you use their filters to benefit the most and you can go longer in between filter changes. Using other company oil filters you must change at the regular oil filter interval and others filters filter less. (4) No, Changing over to synthetic will not hurt anything. If you get gasket leaks it is because there was slug in the engine from using poor oils in the tractors history. You would eventually get leaks anyways. All the synthetic oil is doing is cleaning out the slug; the slug might be acting like a gasket, hence leaks might happen. If you have been real good in oil changing and using a good regular oil you will be okay. I have seen many people change to synthetic oil well over 100K miles and no leaks. Tractors I have seen over 100 hours and over 700 hours and no problems.

Kubota can’t deny warranty service because of using different oils or different drains. I would say prove it to me that the oil was the #1 causes of any problems? They can’t. My dealers are not the best but I don’t put up with the dealers BS thinking he can do whatever he wants. If you start “stirring up the pot” they will listen. I love it when some service manager that basically knows nothing outside of what he is told or literature his boss tells him or her to read tells me what I can and can’t do to my tractor or other item. I tell them to show me in print and not in some sales brochure that I have to follow their recommendations 100% or step for step. They can’t and they try to make you feel bad or put worries in your head. Give me a break! I love that dealer crap. Enough said on that /w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif.



Putty – If you have problem with dirt you have any air filter problem and not an oil problem. If you are using an excellent oil filter you need not worry. Do you have a high silicone rate when testing oil? If you have never tested oil I don’t think you know for sure that you have a dirt problem. Yes manufactures are dealing with this problem. They have for sometime. The additive package will have good soot control to keep the dirt in the oil and thus the dirt or silicone will go to the filter and get filtered.


Richard – If you know any people you can get it cheaper, for example, Amsoil 100% Synthetic 15w-40 Heavy Duty Diesel and Marine for around $3.30 per quart (dealer price). Friends don’t let friend pay retail /w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif. I also think the filter price 3 to 5 times is a bit high or very high I think. For example, my Powerstroke, Amsoil oil filters are around $13 and Ford filters are around $10 at Wally world. Yes the detergents and additives might have a problem but I highly doubt it. I have used LE, Amsoil, and Mobil in my Ford before staying with Amsoil and never had a problem. So I agree with you and not the others. Yes Amsoil has the best oil filters out there. The Amsoil filters are made by Baldwin (hint hint). I run extended drains or extended runs again on my Powerstroke and don’t have a problem. I go around 12K on oil and filter. I change oil filter with 6,000 miles. I have done oil analysis to prove oil is okay and to see if it is better than other (yes it was). You don’t need any special oil filtration system to run extended drains. If you want to go around 20 to lets say 100K on oil (1) oil change you need a special oil filtration system called a By-pass filter.

If you did a cost analysis of only cost than you would be ahead, only in up front cost, but you are forgetting the benefits, like better a starting in cold climates, more MPG, less wear, extended drains, etc.

Also why are you running Seriesd 3000 in tractor? Amsoil is $8.10 A QUART FOR PURE SYNTHETIC and $4-5 for a synthetic blend is retail price.

Man, It feels like I am writing a book!!!! /w3tcompact/icons/wink.gif


Thanks
Mike
Like I told my last ex-wife, I only drive as fast as I can see...and besides, It's all in the reflexes
-Jack Burton, Big Trouble in Little China
 
   / Amsoil vs. Delvac 1 #42  
Burnickas,
I was going by the extended life for the filters for the bypass system. For the fleetguard oil filters I pay $5.60 a piece and they are $18 on the webiste for just the regular filter so about 3x the price plus shipping. That's why I gave the website so people could see what they are using so you could compare apples to apples. For just the regular filter you are right it isn't that big of a difference. I just gave the $4.10 to $8 as the range that you pay for the oil not necessarily what was the right oil or not for the tractor or truck.
As far as paying retail that would be the only way to go for me and I suppose alot of other guys. Not everyone has a friend who sells it or if they are selling it they need to make a profit. I guess it's kind of like regular oil if you have a friend that sells it you can get it for half of the retail price too but that isn't likely, although it is more likely with Amsoil to find an independent dealer. The preferred customer is another way to go but basically that only saves you about 10% and they charge you to be a preferred customer.
Yes you are completely right about the 3000 mile interval. I just do it because it's what I'm comfortable with. On the Dodge that I used to have even with conventional oil the recommended oil change was 7,000 miles.

18-35034-TRACTO~1.GIF
 
   / Amsoil vs. Delvac 1 #43  
-Richard –

I would have to think long-and-hard if paying retail for Amsoil. I asked around at work and found some dealers. They work in the Space & Sea Division so I figured they knew there stuff. They get me the stuff at dealer cost. They said they don’t need to make a profit because I am friends with them and they also have no overhead to pay for. The % off is around 20 to 25% he told me.
It saves me more in time and money (more MPG) then anything. The cost is cheaper when going around 12K miles on Amsoil then draining all 16 qts of dino oil & filter every 3,000 miles. I put on over 2,200 miles per month on the Powerstroke. I can’t see draining oil every 1.3 months! The EPA would think I have a toxic dump in my garaged! /w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif. Plus the tractor was a little quieter with it.


Thanks
Mike
Like I told my last ex-wife, I only drive as fast as I can see...and besides, It's all in the reflexes
-Jack Burton, Big Trouble in Little China
 
   / Amsoil vs. Delvac 1 #44  
Richard, I suspect you should get your facts straight on a public forum. Your Amsoil prices are a flat out (NOT TRUE) !!!gary
 
   / Amsoil vs. Delvac 1 #45  
Gary,
That's pretty uncalled for!!!! I got those prices straight off of the Amsoil WEBSITE! WWW.AMSOIL.COM Anybody can check it out!

18-35034-TRACTO~1.GIF
 
   / Amsoil vs. Delvac 1 #46  
   / Amsoil vs. Delvac 1 #47  
Gary ---Even if Richard and I don't see eye-to-eye on some oil issues I have to agree with him on the price issue. He is dead-on with the <font color=orange> retail </font color=orange>prices.

I hope Richard does not get mad but I am going to make his answers <font color=blue> "hot links" </font color=blue> to their proper web pages so they are easy to see! Just point and click....


SAE 10W-40

SERIES 2000 - SAE 0W-30 Synthetic Motor Oil

Super Duty Full-Flow Engine Oil Filter

By-Pass Oil Filter Replacement Elements



Thanks
Mike
Like I told my last ex-wife, I only drive as fast as I can see...and besides, It's all in the reflexes
-Jack Burton, Big Trouble in Little China



<P ID="edit"><FONT SIZE=-1>Edited by burnickas on 02/26/01 09:13 PM (server time).</FONT></P>
 
   / Amsoil vs. Delvac 1 #48  
Burnickas,
No way would I be mad! Thanks for doing that, I appreciate it and the kind words of assurement. No way do I think that synthetic is bad, just pricey. Like I've said a hundred times I think it's great oil and probably is better than regular oil as well as the filters, I just don't think it's worth the extra cost. That's my only knock on it. Thanks again Mike.

18-35034-TRACTO~1.GIF
 
   / Amsoil vs. Delvac 1 #49  
Richard, Mike and Putty,
Thanks for the info. BTW the top three links all take you to the Amsoil opening page and you can go in from there. Mike, you're right that I could go longer on oil changes in my cars. I change at 3000 miles because I always seem to be driving in conditions that may warrant sooner rather than later changes, ie dusty conditions, stop and go, temp extremes. I just feel more comfortable with the 3000 number for me. More a peace of mind thing I suppose. /w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif
18-32934-tractorsig2.JPG
 
   / Amsoil vs. Delvac 1 #50  
Guys:
Let me chime in with my philosophy on oil. I'm no engineer, but I was in the navy many years ago, a diesel mechanic. We were taught in class a Engineman school that one of the main enemies of diesel engines is oil contamination. In any compression ignition engine, fuel in not completely burned, especially when the engine is at low temperatures. The unburned fuel winds up in the crankcase and is circulated througout the engine. Diesel is not a good lubricator for engines (although high pressure injector pumps use it), and increased wear results when the oil is not changed often enough. You cannot filter this dilution out. In the navy we used a DeLavalle (sp?) centrifugal separator spinning at 17,000 rpm, in addition to very large filters to clean the oil. It's my opinion that more important than the brand of oil, synthetic or petroleum, or filter, the frequency of oil changes is the key to long engine life.
Bob
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

UNUSED FUTURE 4 GAUGE 25' JUMPER CABLES (A51243)
UNUSED FUTURE 4...
(2) ROCK GUARDS FOR 2022 FORD BRONCO (A51244)
(2) ROCK GUARDS...
Land Honor Skid Steer Pallet Forks (A50515)
Land Honor Skid...
2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
John Deere Lawn / Garden Suitcase Weights (A50515)
John Deere Lawn /...
NPK H2XA Skidloader Breaker (A50774)
NPK H2XA...
 
Top