Another "What Size" thread by a clueless newbie....

   / Another "What Size" thread by a clueless newbie.... #1  

Shawn B

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2013
Messages
32
Location
Shreveport, LA
Tractor
Kioti DK45
I think I am losing my mind. Trying to figure out how much tractor do I require? :confused2:

I searched for and read every thread on TBN under the terms "size" and "power" (titles only) that were remotely similar to my situation. I've talked to all the good-ol-boys that live around me and get varying different advice on how much tractor is appropriate for my uses. Every thing from "30-35 hp is plenty" from a 60'ish year old country friend to "you gotta have at least 50 hp" from another serious country-boy buddy of mine.

I've been scouring the Craigslist in my area and looking at TractorHouse dot com. Been to the Kubota and Mahindra dealers.

Pertinent personal information:

* 49-years old. In good shape. Never ran into a machine I could not learn how to operate or drive. Standard, automatic, car, truck, ATV, motorcycle, zero-turn mower, no issues, quick learner. Not sure what kind of tranny I need on this tractor. A stick-shift with clutch does not intimidate me at all.

* Never driven a tractor. Ever. Put my hands on one and sat in the seat at the Mahindra dealer the other day. IIRC 4035.

* Moved from working nightclubs in Houston for three decades, to owning a 44-acre cattle ranch near Shreveport, LA. Major paradigm shift.

*The nearest tractor dealer (Kubota) is 29 miles away. The farthest is Kioti at 59 miles away.

* I want a major name-brand tractor. JD, Kubota, Mahindra, Case, New Holland, Kioti, Massey, etc...Not sold on a particular brand, but want a well established and reputable dealer, support and network. No off-brands.

* I'm very good (**** retentive) with routine maintenance, not a mechanic by any means. Beyond a grease-gun, filter and fluid changes, I will be lost.

* I keep vehicles for a very long time and maintain them impeccably. 1993 Nissan and 2004 Chevy Tahoe. Both could go cross-country and back right now with no issues whatsoever. I plan on buying a tractor and having it basically until I die.


Farm Details and Property.

* 44-acres. Mostly flat or long, slow, slight grades. No real hills of any sort.

* 18-acres of hay-pasture. I hire my hay-cutting and baling. Pretty happy with that arrangement, seems that mowing/baling equipment is crazy-expensive. $32 bucks a bale is the going rate in my neck of the woods. Just under 2K (60 X $32) worth of hay bales from one (1) cutting. Quite frankly I'd prefer to keep hiring this work out. There is only so much one (1) guy can do, and my chore/project list is literally never-ending as is.

* Two (2) 10-acre cow pastures. Bush-hogging or mowing necessary.

* A dozen heifers and calves. I'd like to eventually have 20'ish heifers spitting out calves.

* My round bales are 1,200-1,250 pounds. I need to move them across mostly flat and relatively smooth hay pasture to my cow pastures. Maybe 500-600 yards or so. Probably two (2) bales every week to ten days. I have hay rings to go around the bales. This is "mission critical" for my tractor.

* I'd also like to be able to load those 1250-pound hay bales onto a trailer if I decide to sell hay. I only did one (1) cutting on my hay-field this year. Netted sixty (60) of those bales. I need about thirty (30) bales or less to get my cows through the winter. I could have done two (2) more hay-cuttings but I have no use for additional hay and cannot sell any extra if I cannot load it for a potential buyer.

* I have a Kubota ZG227 (54-inch deck) commercial-grade zero turn mower to use around the houses/shed/barn/driveway (6 or so acres of "lawn"). I have also mowed my cow pastures with it, and could mow my hay field with it if I really wanted to. It is a beastly mower. However, both a heavy duty bush-hog and finishing mower (5-6 footers) are necessary for my tractor.

* My quarter mile long driveway could use a bit of attention. I'd like to smooth it out.

* I am still clearing some portions of my land. My big back pond is basically in the woods. It has not been cleared around since 1989. 20+ year old trees and scrub gotta go. A massive job that may require a bulldozer (?).

* My entire fence line around my hay-field needs to completely cleared (remove 80-year old fencing) and re-fenced with brand new 5-strand barb-wire fencing. Those existing fence lines are 40-60 feet wide (no kidding) with trees/scrub invading my land. I use 7" posts as the main posts and "H" things, I use t-posts every ten feet. We're talking several hundred yards by several hundred yards of fence lines.

* I have had, and will have, immense burn piles to deal with. I'm talking burn piles that are 2,000 square feet and 20 feet high. Some logs in there that are 36" in diameter. The FEL and tractor will be helping me to tend those burn piles.

* I need a corral. (60-80) 7-inch treated posts going in the ground to a depth of 36-inches. A 9-inch augur for the tractor is a must. Approximately one foot of good topsoil over red clay. You hit the red clay with a manual post-hole digger and the going gets very, very tough, very quickly.

* I need at least a couple dozen or more 14-yard dump trucks worth of various dirt-types dropped on my land. Got some low spots that need filling and smoothing. Need to do some filling on a levee by my middle pond where beavers caused some damage. I'll be using the FEL to move quite a bit of dirt around, I won't have to move the dirt very far, I can have it dumped very close to the work-sites.

* I am hoping to be able to move the tractor with an 18-foot dual axle trailer (7000 pound capable) and my Tahoe. Not sure if that is realistic. I could borrow an F250 to get the tractor home if necessary.

* I'd like to look at a pre-owned, well maintained, low hour tractor. 12-15K. Plenty of 30-40 hp clean, low hour, private owner tractors in this range. I'd borrow the money from my bank at 6% over a 48 month note, looking at 375'ish ballpark on the 15K monthly note.

* On the other hand, Mahindra (for one) will put me in a brand new 4035 w/loader, 5-year warranty, for 23K'ish. Low monthly note of 325'ish for 60/72 months. Very do-able in my budget. I imagine other dealers might offer similar long-term, low interest, financing.

* The amount of the monthly note cannot exceed 400/mo. I am very comfortable at that level with my finances.

* I'm in northern LA and will need to start feeding hay to my cows in the next 30-45 days.




That is every thing I can think of.

Obviously horsepower costs money. I do not want to overkill nor underestimate how much tractor I require. I want to buy one (1) time and use it forever.



What say you TBN experts? What general vicinity would you be looking at for tractor horsepower and weight? Can a 30-35 horse do my necessary work? Do I require 40-50 horsepower?

Any help, expertise, or insight is very much appreciated.
 
   / Another "What Size" thread by a clueless newbie.... #2  
1200-1250# rd bale is a load for anything under 50 hp and I'd choose 70 hp.
 
   / Another "What Size" thread by a clueless newbie.... #3  
i hate todo this but i dissagree with your seasoned farm freinds.with everything your wanting todo you need a 7060 kubota ROPs 4x4 fel with a hydro shuttle.this size tractor will move stack an load the round bales your using.you can use posthole digger with a 9in an 12in auger.an 8ft pull type shredder.we run a 400ac farm with 2 tractors 1 is the 2013 7040 thats now a 7060 if all the 7040s are gone.the other is a jx80 case.both tractors are 4x4 with fels.now i ran a 2010 mx5100 hst 4x4 rops 52hp.but it was to lite tobe lifting 5 by 6 bales an pulling a hay hauler loaded with 5 by 6s.
 
   / Another "What Size" thread by a clueless newbie.... #4  
1200-1250# rd bale is a load for anything under 50 hp and I'd choose 70 hp.

I guess I have to disagree. I sure wouldn't have any trouble lifting a 1250lb bail with my 40hp tractor that has a loader rated to 2700lbs at full height.

Shawn basically needs a utility tractor for a variety of tasks minus haying or major land clearing on a 44 acre property. Nothing wrong with 50-70hp but he certainly won't be able to transport one on a 7000lb trailer. I don't see any reason why a solid 40hp machine wouldn't do every one of the tasks he has outlined. 40hp would be trailerable but tight. 35hp is a little light mostly because you won't find many with strong loaders but once you get up to 40hp the loaders of many tractors can handle a 1250lb bale. Save money on the tractor and invest in good used implements would be my strategy to maximize bang for the buck.

I think he'll find the best bang for the buck with slightly used slightly off brands like Mahindra, Kioti, LS. Kubota and JD are pretty pricey even used. NH would be somewhere in between I'd imagine. I have a Kioti DK40se that I would not hesitate to recommend for the types of tasks listed. I'd go for HST with all the general utility stuff because of all the maneuvering with the fencing projects.
 
   / Another "What Size" thread by a clueless newbie.... #5  
After the bale handling size a backhoe may be nice for a lot of the other jobs planned.:thumbsup:

The basic physical size of the tractor may be more important than a really high HP but both seem to go hand in hand.:)
 
   / Another "What Size" thread by a clueless newbie.... #6  
50 HP 4WD with loader would be just fine in my opinion. You can run a 6' mower with out a problem and 1200 to 1250# shouldn't be any problem. In a NH that would be a boomer 50, but if you have an LS dealer around they make that boomer 50 it would be an LS4047, less money larger loader capacity, same tractor and if I am not mistaken LS just started 0% financing I think.
 
   / Another "What Size" thread by a clueless newbie.... #7  
If you want to be able to easily lift 1200lbs+ on the FEL regularly, you want a loader that can lift at least 2,000lbs to max height....you don't want to be struggling on the limits of the machine's ability on a regular basis. I think that also means you don't want to go down in size to the 30-35hp machines, even if they'll lift the weight, because they tend to weigh less to start with. I'd look for a base machine that weighs 3,500lbs, not including FEL, 40HP minimum, 2K+ lift on the FEL, and an HST transmission (very handy when doing loader work, or mowing/brush hogging).

As far as brand goes, realize that some big names aren't making their own compact tractors now. For example, a NH Boomer 35/40/50 and corresponding Case/IH Farmall B models are actually an LS R3039/4041/4047 respectively....but NH and Case charge much more (like $8K).

A lot of companies are offering 0% financing right now, which helps a lot...some even up to 84 months (I just saw that LS is offering this).

I wouldn't go any smaller than a 6' finish mower, and brush cutter, with that size tractor, and that much land. I have a 7.5' finish mower, and 6' brush cutter, and I want to add a 7' brush cutter because I know my machine will handle it. If they made a normal finish mower much bigger, I'd consider that as well because I'm not coming close to taxing my machines.

The good thing is that you can go to any of the brands you mentioned (including a few more like Yanmar or LS) and get a machine that will fill the bill perfectly....you'd be hard-pressed to find a bad one in the bunch.
 
   / Another "What Size" thread by a clueless newbie.... #8  
It is difficult to follow GManBart.

You may as well focus in on your hay bale requirements. Handling 1,250 pounds and stacking two bales high on a trailer is your minimum requirement.

I recommend 50-hp to 70-hp, four-wheel-drive and concur in a tractor weight of 3,400 to 4,400 pounds.

In Kubota that puts you in the 'M/MX' range with a LA844 loader = 1,874 pounds lift, full height, when new or a LA1154 loader = 2,535 pounds lift, full height, when new.

Lifting heavy loads with an FEL is when people topple their tractors, especially light tractors. More tractor weight provides more stability than less tractor weight.

While you might be able to lift a bale without a counterbalance mounted on the three point hitch...DON'T DO IT. The rear end will be light without a counterbalance and should you drop a front wheel into a hole, or rut, or turn downhill, over you will go. Box Blade is a common counterbalance, as is a dedicated Ballast Box. I use my Cultipacker; heavy yet compact.

A 3-Pt. hitch mounted counterbalance also unloads stress from the front axle.

I have a Kubota B3300SU tractor-loader package: 33-hp/1,900 pounds/4-WD; largest in the 'B' series. I consider my tractor totally inadequate to your stated bale requirement.

A Front End Loader is the most useful tractor option.

About my favorite attachment goes on the FEL: Ratchet Rake @ $400

You can use RR for minor grading on your road and RR is the berries for tearing out brush and piling brush.

THERE IS NOTHING WRONG WITH A USED DIESEL TRACTOR IF WELL MAINTAINED.

Ratchet Rake Video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gvinkbW8Z90
 

Attachments

  • DSC00034.jpg
    DSC00034.jpg
    1.1 MB · Views: 226
  • IMG_0398.jpg
    IMG_0398.jpg
    222.1 KB · Views: 174
  • IMG_0399.jpg
    IMG_0399.jpg
    198.6 KB · Views: 182
  • IMG_0607.JPG
    IMG_0607.JPG
    119.9 KB · Views: 191
Last edited:
   / Another "What Size" thread by a clueless newbie.... #9  
Check out LS or Kioti, Say The DK-40 or 50. Don't see why you would need a 70 HP machine unless you were Haying.
 
   / Another "What Size" thread by a clueless newbie.... #10  
I would think the smallest Kubota you could get by with would by an L4600 and that may still be reasonably priced. Larger, heavier tractors would probably make the job easier for you, but you could probably use something in the 40hp and up range.

I have an L3800 and I believe round bales would be at the very top of my specs either on the 3ph or loader (and maybe over on the loader). I don't think my loader would do much more than just lift and transport a bale (if that). I'm sure I wouldn't be able to raise to any appreciable height for stacking, and that's mainly due to the weight of my machine. I'd end up lifting my rear end probably even with ballast on 3ph and loaded rear tires. I run a 5' bush hog on some very hilly land with zero problem and would probably put a 6' finish mower on if I was going to buy one. I use a solid duty 6' box blade routinely and my tractor handles it with ease. I say all this to point out that something larger and heavier with more horse would do your jobs that much easier or faster.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

(2) ROLLS OF HD CHAIN LINK MESH WIRE (A50460)
(2) ROLLS OF HD...
1997 John Deere 690 Elc Excavator (A50514)
1997 John Deere...
10x16.5 Tire Assembly (A52128)
10x16.5 Tire...
2016 FORD TRANSIT 250 VAN (A51406)
2016 FORD TRANSIT...
2016 KLEEMAN MS192 MOBILE SCREEN (A51242)
2016 KLEEMAN MS192...
71054 (A49346)
71054 (A49346)
 
Top