""Soundguy, I get Normde's point so this will be my last post on this subject.""
I think it may be mine as well.
""My reply is as follows:
A single wet cell fully charged (1.260/ 1.280 specific gravity) has static 2.13 volts per cell. This 2.13v times 6 cells = 12.78 volts for a fully charged battery. A 12 volt battery at 12.0 volts is less then 50% charged. Batteries continually kept at this low charge rate will die very quickly from sulphation of their plates.""
Never said it was the optimum fix.. just a stopgap measure. Besides.. if a 15v reg is available.. it will be the better choice to start from.
""In addition, there will be a voltage drop from where the VR ties into the alt to battery circuit so that when alt current finally get's to the battery it will no longer be at the VR's 12 volts but at a lesser value.""
If the proper gauge wire is used, with good connections, there should be no more than a negligible voltage drop across a couple feet of copper. Maybee in the 100'ths.. probably in the 1000's range.
""Bottom line, why would one want to design a voltage regulator that would keep a battery at less then 50% charged?""
If I wanted my tractor to start, and I didn't have access to the optimum componets to make a regulator, the 12 reg. would do it.
""Also, if one was to put a fully charged battery in this tractor then, with tractor running, all loads would run off the battery (higher EMF) instead of the alternator until the battery is down to less then 50% of it's potential.""
I stated as much.. that the battery would be in a state of discharge, untill the potential of the battery was less than the charging potential.
"It doesn't cost much more, if any, to go a VR in the std 13.8 to 14.8v range so a VR in this range seems like a better bet to me for this application."
Money wasn't an large factor in my statements.. parts availability was. Radioshack is only a marginal parts house.. if the person performing this repair has access to a better house.. say like newark, etc... then ther probably won't be a problem. On the other hand... rs does sell a 317 variable vr.. but then we are getting back into building a more complicated circuit. An irf-511 powered PWM is going to be even more complicated for an individual without good electronics background. However, if they feel froggy, and want to do electronics via 'cookbook', they have more than enough options right now to go build a circuit blindly from schematics, whether it be a variable vr circuit, any one of the constant current circuits, a series pass regulator, or a pwm.... they can take their pick.
Soundguy