Farmerford
Platinum Member
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2006
- Messages
- 733
- Location
- Columbus, Georgia
- Tractor
- Kuborta B2400, L2900, L4330; Caterpillar D3B, John Deere 455D
Cavinman:
Understand first that I am stuck in the 1950's when tractors had no plastic, no power brakes, (usually) no power steering, and always had a standard transmission with a clutch, and were expected to last at least 10 years in heavy farm service, and usually lasted 20 years.
I have now a 1995 Kubota, 2001 Kubota, and 2006 Kubota and they have gotten progressively more plastic and electronic. The 1995 Kubota has required a new fuel shut off solenoid and glow plug timer. The 2001 Kubota required a new fuel shut off solenoid, starter solenoid, and ignition switch. When I looked at the 2006 L4330 the next generation L4340's had just come out and I was completely turned off by the electronic engine and HST control system. Not only do I think they are unnecessary and even a hindrance to any reasonable operator, I can't imagine that the electronics will operate 10 years without failure. And 20 years from now parts are likely to be unavailable.
I know nothing about the other brand you are looking at except that they seem to get good reports on this bulletin board. But if they are cheaper, have no or fewer electronics, and you have a dealer close by, I would avoid the Kubota "40" series because they are simply too refined and complicated for long term use. The "old" series L4330 is too electronic for my tastes, but the local dealer is superb and that made the difference.
I am reminded of the early 1990's when Mercedes overengineered their cars with gadgets like "bumper markers" that raised up out of the rear fenders when you went into reverse so you could see where the bumpers were. Not only did that stuff break, it was expensive in the first place, and served no real purpose other than a sales tool.
OK. I will get off the soapbox. Enjoy whatever you get.
Understand first that I am stuck in the 1950's when tractors had no plastic, no power brakes, (usually) no power steering, and always had a standard transmission with a clutch, and were expected to last at least 10 years in heavy farm service, and usually lasted 20 years.
I have now a 1995 Kubota, 2001 Kubota, and 2006 Kubota and they have gotten progressively more plastic and electronic. The 1995 Kubota has required a new fuel shut off solenoid and glow plug timer. The 2001 Kubota required a new fuel shut off solenoid, starter solenoid, and ignition switch. When I looked at the 2006 L4330 the next generation L4340's had just come out and I was completely turned off by the electronic engine and HST control system. Not only do I think they are unnecessary and even a hindrance to any reasonable operator, I can't imagine that the electronics will operate 10 years without failure. And 20 years from now parts are likely to be unavailable.
I know nothing about the other brand you are looking at except that they seem to get good reports on this bulletin board. But if they are cheaper, have no or fewer electronics, and you have a dealer close by, I would avoid the Kubota "40" series because they are simply too refined and complicated for long term use. The "old" series L4330 is too electronic for my tastes, but the local dealer is superb and that made the difference.
I am reminded of the early 1990's when Mercedes overengineered their cars with gadgets like "bumper markers" that raised up out of the rear fenders when you went into reverse so you could see where the bumpers were. Not only did that stuff break, it was expensive in the first place, and served no real purpose other than a sales tool.
OK. I will get off the soapbox. Enjoy whatever you get.