Dirty oil, but clean dipstick.

   / Dirty oil, but clean dipstick. #11  
You are looking at a thin film of oil on the dipstick. Oil in a pan is an entirely different matter.
 
   / Dirty oil, but clean dipstick. #12  
New oil, changes to dark almost immediately. The main cause of darkened oil is not "dirt" but heat.
As oosik states, you cannot compare a thin film of oil to a panful as the density of oil particles is not only blocking light but adding to its color saturation as well..
 
   / Dirty oil, but clean dipstick. #13  
No not always. Did you read post #2? The oil in my tractor is nearing 100 hrs and is just now starting to get noticeably darker…
 
   / Dirty oil, but clean dipstick. #14  
No not always. Did you read post #2? The oil in my tractor is nearing 100 hrs and is just now starting to get noticeably darker…
It does start to change color very quickly. I changed mine out at 50 hrs and it was darker than what was first put in there for sure.
But you're right, I should have stipulated however as the word 'immediately", is relative for me in comparison to other things not so immediate such as changing oil out at 1000 miles instead of 5000 with respect to autos.
1000 miles to me would be "immediate" in the scheme of things and to think I actually did that when I was a pup.
 
Last edited:
   / Dirty oil, but clean dipstick. #15  
how quickly it turns darker depends on the engine series & type of use. of course, lots of cold starts & short runs will darken oil quicker. it takes quite a while for oil to turn completely dark in my Tier II engine.
check the dipstick with engine dead cold. it should be close to oil pan color. the idea of checking dipstick with slightly drained oil is a good one to compare
 
   / Dirty oil, but clean dipstick.
  • Thread Starter
#17  
Be awhile before I get back to the farm to check it
 
   / Dirty oil, but clean dipstick. #18  
Oil does some odd things sometimes. When I check my oil cold the oil on the stick is black. When I check it hot it appears nearly clean. Yes, I check my oil before and after using the tractor. I assume then when I check it after running that the soot is evenly distributed in the oil and when it cools the soot settles out and gets deposited on the dip stick.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

AMG M 35A2C drop side 2 1/2 ton 6 x 6 (A50323)
AMG M 35A2C drop...
2005 Chevrolet Uplander Van (A51694)
2005 Chevrolet...
TAYLOR TDF-60S STRAIGHT MAST FORKLIFT (A51242)
TAYLOR TDF-60S...
2012 Ford F450 Bucket Truck (A50323)
2012 Ford F450...
2015 JLG 6042 Telehandler (RIDE AND DRIVE) (A50774)
2015 JLG 6042...
UNUSED FUTURE SKID STEER QUICK ATTACH LAND LEVELER (A51244)
UNUSED FUTURE SKID...
 
Top