I did some poking around in the area today, though didn't get a chance to excavate (I had to move a big pile of dirt first). The water in the hole was crystal clear (so maybe a spring?), feeling the bottom with a stick there's rocks in the bottom, some areas are gravel and some are much deeper and mud on the bottom. It extends about 4' in one direction and there are some areas around that are 5' deep mud (can push a stick in 5 foot with minor effort). I think it's been developing for a while now that I look at it. Last fall I cut a tree (you can see the stump in the pictures) because the roots had just pulled out and it was lifting out of the ground with the wind, other trees around had started to die and I lost a couple of others. The whole area is slightly sunken vs the other ground and there's a thick mat of tree roots, which is what's holding the surface up, where I fell through I stepped between the roots. I've roped the area off with flagging tape and will wait for it to dry before digging in further. The stone wall near it is my property line, so I probably will be unable to drain it - but maybe I can fill it with rocks and get a stable surface, my hope was to use the area to park a trailer.
The area of the sinkhole. The hole in the center is where my foot went through.
View attachment 319598
Another view showing where the area is. Note there's a compacted Pad for parking right next to it. The drain pipe is for my downspouts though due to a gutter problem (tree hit it), almost nothing drains out of it, it runs out the other end.
View attachment 319599
where my foot went through, looks innocent enough!
View attachment 319600
Inside the hole. The water is pretty clear and the level is about 6" under the level of the ground, the top level is being supported mostly by tree roots.
View attachment 319601