MikePA
Super Moderator
Since 10 cents per gallon profit is too much, what's a 'legitimate' profit?Casey1 said:The oil companies would just adjust the price at the pump and make a legitimate profit.
Since 10 cents per gallon profit is too much, what's a 'legitimate' profit?Casey1 said:The oil companies would just adjust the price at the pump and make a legitimate profit.
MikePA said:According to the Energy Information Administration, on average, oil companies make 10 cents per gallon profit. Since they sell a lot of gallons, this is considered astronomical profits. If the oil companies decided to only be half as greedy, cost at the pumps would drop by 5 cents. Even if they decided to make no profit, price at the pumps would drop by 10 cents.
Now that the greedy oil companies have been dealt with, who is the next target. Federal tax at 18 cents per gallon. Is anyone complaing about that? Nope.
Next? State and local taxes which vary from 8 cents (Alaska) to 50 cents (New York) per gallon. Is anyone complaing about that? Nope.
In this scenario, oil companies are making no profit on gasoline, why should they produce it?
No, I didn't. This thread is about oil company (Exxon) profits. Plus someone else posted about what the dealer makes.slowrev said:You seem to have forgotten the distributor and dealer profit.
They make 10 cents a gallon. If it's more complex, please enlighten us.slowrev said:And the oil companies selling crude to themselves and other companies. Not as simple as you imply.
Probably too much.slowrev said:How much profit does Kroger make on a gallon of milk ?
Speaking of profit, supermarket overall profit margin is in the 1%-2% range. They make up for the low margin by selling in volume. The average convenience store is working at about 20%-25% overall profit margin (excluding gas sales). You would be surprised how little retailer profit there is for some items, and how much for others. And the distributors are always trying to squeeze you. My worst distributor was Coke, the best was Budweiser. My 3 biggest profit centers were beer, cigarettes and magazines.slowrev said:How much profit does Kroger make on a gallon of milk ?
Casey1 said:Single digit oil prices. I wouldn't mind it. The oil companies would just adjust the price at the pump and make a legitimate profit. Our cost would be less and they would still do fine. It's a pipe dream though. It ain't going to happen. I hope your stock goes up at the same rate as fuel prices, but I bet that will not happen either.
10 cents a gallon for oil company profit? How did they squeak by before? Gas prices in my area have dropped 25 to thirty cents recently (diesel hasn't) with profit margins so thin the oil companies and the retailer must be selling at cost. I don't think so.
When gas goes to 250 dollars a barrel then I suppose most of you will suspect there is something rotten it Denmark. It will really be smelling bad by then.
MikePA said:Since 10 cents per gallon profit is too much, what's a 'legitimate' profit?
Gee - you didn't answer my question, again. For the sake of argument, let's say that profit was 1 cent per gallon. That'd reduce what you pay at the pump by 9 cents or 3%. Wow.ducati996 said:Gee - since they were profitable and not complaining when oil was between $35 to $42 a barrel we can start there.
MikePA said:According to the Energy Information Administration, on average, oil companies make 10 cents per gallon profit. Since they sell a lot of gallons, this is considered astronomical profits. If the oil companies decided to only be half as greedy, cost at the pumps would drop by 5 cents. Even if they decided to make no profit, price at the pumps would drop by 10 cents.
Now that the greedy oil companies have been dealt with, who is the next target. Federal tax at 18 cents per gallon. Is anyone complaing about that? Nope.
Next? State and local taxes which vary from 8 cents (Alaska) to 50 cents (New York) per gallon. Is anyone complaing about that? Nope.
In this scenario, oil companies are making no profit on gasoline, why should they produce it?
As I said earlier, everyone pays the same amount for gas at the bulk distribution terminal. The difference in prices from the terminal to the pump is usually in the 30-50 cent range. This markup DOES NOT GO TO THE OIL COMPANIES, it goes to the local distributor, hauler and retailer.ducati996 said:Not sure where you got 10 cents a gallon but based on EIA breakdown
of unleaded gas being at $2.98
the breakdown for the crude is 52 % , refining 26%, distrubiton & marketing 6% and taxes 15%
Either way its more than 10 cents a gallon
Gasoline and Diesel Fuel Update
1. It doesn't take that long to get a barrel of oil from the the Middle East to the refinery. So, the oil being sold now was not drilled when it was $40/bbl.slowrev said:Much of the oil being sold now was drilled into when it was selling for $40/bbl or less.
Try doing more research on the EIA site. Oil company profits on a gallon of gas is 10 cents when gasoline costs $3.00.ducati996 said:Not sure where you got 10 cents a gallon but based on EIA breakdown
of unleaded gas being at $2.98
the breakdown for the crude is 52 % , refining 26%, distrubiton & marketing 6% and taxes 15%
Either way its more than 10 cents a gallon -if you could please define if its net or gross profit
Gasoline and Diesel Fuel Update
What do you mean 'there's something wrong and you don't know exactly what it is'? What's wrong is the people who pump the oil out of the ground have doubled the price of a barrel of oil.Casey1 said:It's funny that the oil drilled for 30 or 40 dollars a barrel is the same oil drilled for 70 now. There is something wrong and I don't know exactly what it is but if you believe there is only 10 cents a gallon profit going on then I will sell you some ocean front property in Arizona for oh 10 cents an acre.
I misunderstood your comment. I agree, I imagine there are wells that have been producing that long. However, no refiner, such as Exxon, controls what they pay for a barrel of oil since they (the refiner) do not pump the oil out of the ground.slowrev said:1. It doesn't take that long to get a barrel of oil from the the Middle East to the refinery. So, the oil being sold now was not drilled when it was $40/bbl.//
//
HUH ?
You mean wells drilled before the war are not still producing oil ? All oil does not come from the middle east.
Ben