Grapple grapple types

/ grapple types #1  

arrow

Super Member
Joined
Dec 15, 2002
Messages
6,313
Location
Wakefield, RI
Tractor
Mahindra 3016
I need to pick up split firewood from the splitter pile and dump the load into a cart and bring it to the wood stack. The bucket on my fel does this pretty miserably bringing in few splits and much dirt. Gotta be a combination that does this much better. Any suggestions?
 
/ grapple types
  • Thread Starter
#2  
Loading the bucket by hand is a PIA.
 

Attachments

  • PICT0049.JPG
    PICT0049.JPG
    78.6 KB · Views: 628
/ grapple types #4  
The easiest solution involves putting the split wood in something that you can move. This can be a small dump trailer (cheap kits for low speed farm use ones are readily available), a modified pallet or custom built box with sides, whatever. No grapple will pick very much up. Time to build something!!:)
 
/ grapple types
  • Thread Starter
#5  
Maybe I should explain this a little better. I have 3 years in advance firewood stacks. When they all are filled there is no place to bring the splits to anymore. I still keep splitting however and make these large piles in anticipation of eventually getting them to a stacking point. I need something that will walk into one of these piles, come out with a load that can then be dumped into a cart rather than to continue flinging them in by hand, Iwas looking for someone who may have had experience with this same situation who could advise what works well for them. Our buckets are just too small to do it like a 3 or 4 yd bucket does. Still, there has to be a better way and another chance to buy another implement.
 
/ grapple types #6  
I've been fooling w/ the firewood *buisness* for some time and have recently made the leap to actually taking it on full time.

For what its worth I load my little 2 cord delivery dump truck many times each day with a small Kubota tractor w/ a 60" wide regular bucket. Frankly, I've tried many different ways, scooping & loading with a tractor bucket is only second to using a conveyor...it works VERY good! I'm using an L3400 machine w/ the standard 60" wide bucket, on average I can fill the 2+ cord wood box on my delivery truck w/ about 11-12 scoops. Because time is money in the firewood buisness, and there ain't much margin, I've spent considerable time, effort and energy finding the most efficients ways to handle firewood. That said, if you're having trouble getting a full load into your bucket try coming into the pile at a slight angle...this helps a lot; everytime I come into the pile I come away with my bucket overflowing w/ split firewood on the first try. On average I can fill my 2+ cord wood box in about 13 minutes, from the time I pull up, start the tractor, load, and drive away again is less than 20 minutes. I know of now other way that is as fast and efficient....you won't be this fast w/ a conveyor, even feeding the hopper w/ the tractor. The piles I'm loading from are between 15-70 cord piles, around 12-14' tall.
Making firewood piles w/ a tractor is a joke, doesn't work very well and you'll end up w/ tore up equipment...making the piles works best w/ a conveyor, but when loading a tractor bucket is the only way to go!
 
/ grapple types #7  
You might try some bolt in "trash forks" from Sundown, or perhaps Payne. Another thought is one of the various buckets with extended tines that ATi has..... good excuse for a QC
 
/ grapple types
  • Thread Starter
#8  
LukeTD, And you wanted to know what a 35 hp tractor would do when you probably have a full fledged skidder. You sir are in a rough business. I worked with a firewood guy for 3 years until he went belly up. His beligerent ways with customers finally did him in. I used to go with him on deliveries just to break up the fights he'd get into with his customers after they accused him of short changing them on wood. He was the type willing to swap hands in a second when they made that kind of accusation. He never did so I know what you may be confronting at times. Ok he had a big Hough loader that basically filled up the truck with one bite. (3 yd bucket) Our piles were also made with a conveyor about the same as yours and there in lies the problem. My home piles are only 2-3 cords. The tractor just kind of pushes the pile if I go high and fills up with the gravel base when I go low. If I had the resistance of a bigger pile, then maybe my small bucket would fill up like yours. My splits average 20" and 4-6" wide. I probably would be better off with a tined bucket just to start the slide in process for my smaller bucket. Heck, I may even be able to load longer length stems onto the trailer as a forwarder when in the woods with such a bucket when runs get too long to skid. What's with your fronts breaking beads in the woods or were you just kidding.
 
/ grapple types #9  
good thread again arrow.

I would suggest an effective and cheap way to make your life a bit easier would be to buy a toothbar for your bucket. it will help pick-up many things, including firewood and logs. It will also be a good digger when you need it.

For less then $300 it's a bargain. A bucket grapple, like what I have, will not help pick up firewood.

Luke-up here you can buy a tandem load (23 cords) of maple logs for $800. I have at least 20 of those trucks pass my house each day. Split maple is $70/cord delivered.

I had considered getting into selling firewood since I have the tractor, a 65 cc Husky chainsaw and 20 acres of maple forest (and acess to the surrounding 10000 acres of recently cut govt forest-lots of tops:) ) but I am not sure of the economics of it all. I would have to buy a log splitter (I use a 8lb maul now) for my tractor and a dump truck. Do you think I can make money at $70 a cord?
 
/ grapple types #10  
Northland said:
Luke-up here you can buy a tandem load (23 cords) of maple logs for $800. I have at least 20 of those trucks pass my house each day. Split maple is $70/cord delivered.
Dang... split hardwood mix here in Mid-Coast Maine is between $200-$250/cord, split and delivered. (if you are within 10 miles of supplier) Delivery charges go nuts if you are over 20 miles from supplier.
 
/ grapple types
  • Thread Starter
#11  
Northland thanks for the tip about the teeth. You may be on to something there.
The guy I used to work for had an 8' bed 2500 Dodge Ram with what they call around here an EZ-Dumper body in it. He built up the sides another 3 ' , added additional leaf springs and went around a cord at a time. Back then we got $75 for cut, split and dried oak. (mid to high 1970's) delivered. It is back breaking work and labor intensive. People on Cape Cod are paying anywhere near $350 per cord now. Thats where everyone is going around here and with fuel costs, insurance and maintenance, one now has to charge that kind of money to make meager gains. After your expenses and only if you already have a truck, $70 is chicken feed for the amount of work you'll do. You'd almost have to have a processor to increase your cord per hour duration to make money @70 bucks. In other words, you'd have to have quite the operation going. No, I don't think its worth it not unless you were already equiped with a truck, splitter, conveyor and a skidder that will get you 3-5 cords per hour. If you are having stems delivered as opposed to skidding that may be more cost efficient but I still wouldn't involve myself for that kind of return. Besides, you seem to be having fun in the snow and woods. A business started with an entity that you think is fun now, has the inordinate knack of turning what was fun into work.

Lou
 
Last edited:
/ grapple types #13  
arrow said:
A business started with an entity that you think is fun now, has the inordinate knack of turning what was fun into work.

Lou

amen to that Lou-ain't it the truth:) thanks for the clear voice of reason

see attachment for my set-up
 

Attachments

  • grapple toothbar.jpg
    grapple toothbar.jpg
    91 KB · Views: 308
/ grapple types
  • Thread Starter
#14  
Great set-up Northland. If I get a tooth bar, it looks like you have a little play as to how deep in the bucket it goes. May be all I need.

Ironhorse, Thanks for the tip. Those buckets are more than I can spend and they are quite heavy. My loader only does 800#. They tell me I can increase it with a screw turn but I do not know where this screw is. I did a search on rock buckets after your post and Virnig makes a light one at under 300#. Don't know what the cost is. If I had a pipe bender, I'd make the darn thing
 
/ grapple types #15  
Hi Arrow....I wasn't kidding or trying to be sarcastic in my previous post, sorry if it came accross that way. Sometimes a guy can mess-up typed words versus just standing a talking with someone. I don't have a real skidder and I'm trying very hard to NOT become a "logger".
I have my hands full trying to care of all of the logistical planning, processing and marketing of just the firewood end. For example I'm buying semi log truck of tree-lenght logs and then we process them into cut & split firewood, store that material to let it dry, and then either load bulk stove wood into a dump truck for delivery and more recently we're getting into the bundle-wood mfg process. Another major cmmitment I'm facing right now is building a large drying kiln. These are the little .75 cf (3/4 of cubic ft) shrink wrapped bundles you see at the local quick stop gas station. However our target market is camp grounds and RV parks for our bundle wood.

Anyway, back to the log skidding part. Currently we have some challenges with a supply & demand issue. We need a certain amount of firewood grade logs delivered to us, however most of the loggers in this region sell lumber grade logs for a certain price, house logs for a higher price, and the firewood grade logs fetch the lowest price. Of course its common sence that no one would go out of thier way to work the same for less money, therefore I'm always on the lowest pecking order, so to speak, when it comes to buying logs. I'm having a hard time buying enough raw material, tree lenghts firewood grade logs. By the way, I have an "open door policy" w/ all of the logging outfits in my region, and always pay cash on the spot for my product, plus do my best to use good people skills when dealing w/ different personalities....in other words I'm not trying to low ball them on price, or act like a jerk so they won't sell to me, the problem is simply supply and demand; frankly I'm buying just as much or more logs than anyone else.
Soooo, to bring this full circle I'm exploring other options to increase my supply. My main option is to get the logs myself, which reguires another major investment in a logging truck, maybe a feller-buncher, skidder, more insurance, large $ bond for bidding on state or federal timber sales, and on and on....the logging business is a business in itself. I've got my hands full doing firewood.

--

As to whether or not a guy can make money in the firewood business is hard to say. I suspect a lot depends on how serious you want to make it, if its your only source of income-or you have another job and do it part time, plus other factors like demand for firewood in your area, and as I mentioned above do you have access to plently of raw material to process into firewood.
In my region the wholesale price for a logging truck, about 9 cords, of tree lenghts Birch with maybe a few Spruce mixed in is about $1,000-$1,200 depending on how far they truck it. Retail price for dry and processed stove wood is about $200 per Cord delivered. As you can see there isn't much margin by the time you buy it, process it, hold it for a year (tie up your $ for a year), and then load it into a delivery truck and go dump it at the customers location.
On the other hand, there is more margin in the bundle wood, however it takes a lot more labor. That said you're getting paid for your labor, or a lot of times you can provide a service to the local community and put some high school kids to work for the summer making bundles, and then you go deliver them to the RV parks and camp grounds during the summer. There are many small buiness' scatered around that are operated by one man who wants something to do in his spare time and makes a little extra money. Plus if you have your own teenage kids putting them to work processing firewood instills good work ethic and its just old fashion hard work...they make some extra money.
 
/ grapple types #16  
Gee whiz guys I got awful long winded and forgot where I started, which was coming to this site looking for info about how to use a small tractor to help me fetch logs. By the way....sure is nice to get different opinions and view point and to see what other guys are doing, thanks!
I'm acting like a spunge and trying to gather up all of the info your guys provide. Which got me to thinking maybe I can use my little Kubota to skid logs, on a limited basis, maybe from some smaller tracts of private land. The attachments for these little tractors are WAY more than they were a few years ago...unlimted options. And one more time I must say this site is an extremly valuable learning tool!
 
/ grapple types
  • Thread Starter
#17  
Luke, I never took offense with anything you said nor would I have been bothered with any sarcasm or not. I just thought with a firewood business, the rest would follow in terms of equipment but that's what was in my background. Everyone had quite the operation except for the last guy I worked for.I used to hate delivering with the guy . He was so ornery, he'd turn peole off in a second. Whenever someone said, "a cord huh, doesn't look like a cord" I'd hold my breath because I knew what was coming. He'd pitch on guys 80 pounds heavier than him. He was a little guy but would wreak havoc with much bigger guys and I'd be in the middle of it trying to break it apart. He did wood all his life and was as strong as an ox but his people skills were zero. He worked for people most of his life and thought he could make money on his own. The key to a wood business along with people skills is pre selling. If you can produce and sell 10 cords a week, thats at least $2000. Multiply that by 36 weeks and you have yourself $72000. Subtract your costs , and that's how much you made but your operation has to be contained. Have logs delivered. The last thing you want to do is get into skidding. Get a good splitter, your tractor, a fast saw and your dump and a customer base and you can make a living. By the way, the guy I worked for died at 54 years of age of a coronary. He was lean as could be but one big ball of stress.

Me, I still can't get splits into my bucket without dirt. I'm having a hard time convincing my wife I need a $1000 rock bucket. I'm amazed yours operates so well. Are you on cement or asphalt by any chance? I have hardly any rollback angle on my fel. I get no bite into the wood at all. I was out there today thinking of you and feeling sorry for myself for having to load up the bucket by hand and also swearing alot.

Lou
 
/ grapple types #18  
Arrow: While I understand what you're after, you need to take a hard look at your numbers. While the gross looks attractive, it is irrelevant. Take a hard look at all of the numbers, err against yourself, and see what you think you can net. Most businesses do well to preserve a 15% margin, what do you expect to do? If you end up with the average margin you'll make $300 a week, less the self-employment taxes, or roughly $200 per week which is $20 for every cord of wood you supply. Maybe you have already worked up and through your model, but plan plan plan. Better to see it now than later! Good luck!
 
/ grapple types
  • Thread Starter
#19  
Bj you might be a little confused here. The numbers I provided were for Luke the Drifter. He is the one in the wood business. He told us he pays a little over $1000 for 9 cords of stems. He'll be lucky to get about 8 cords of saleable wood from that and if he gets $200 per cord, he has netted $600 on that load. Now he has to figure his insurance cost, his fuel and miscellaneous costs, taxes and he comes close to $200 net per 8 cords. For every $72000 he grosses, he has much to subtract. Thats with selling 10 cords per week. He is the one who has to figure out how many 10 corders he has to sell to make a living. In my mind he has to either up his cord price or sell 25-30 cords per week to survive. As I said, firewood is a tough business and if he can make $450-500 per cord of firewoood bundling it as he does, he can make a go of it. It is crucial to have a steady customer base in the wood game. As for myself, the professional woodchuck days are long gone. Right now I'm content to just figure out a better way to load the wood cart with my fel. Your input is appreciated I'm sure
 
/ grapple types #20  
Hey Lou I was surfing around on the world wide web last night-this morning, while my lovely bride was in bed sleeping-where I should have been, and came across a site that had the dangest attachment you've ever seen for hauling material and then dumping. I'm talented at many thing in this world, however I'm not really good w/ computer stuff...which means two things; 1) I can't remeber the site name 2) or provide you w/ a link to click.
However I'll briefly describe it and you'll get the idea, make you can make something up at your own place that'll work for your applaication. They were using some fixed forks and had a container that looked about like a small commercial trash dumpters; the special parts included a niffty latch system on the top door that opened for dumping when it reached a certain angle-that you set, and the fork pockets had some type of clamp system where you wouldn't dump-off the container when dumping the load.
I realize this doesn't help you pickup stove wood w/o getting gravel/dirt/debris mixed in. I prepped my storage area by starting with pit run gravel, compacted, and then finer 3/4" minus w/ plently of binder (dirt) on top -well compacted; plus most of my loading is in the winter so I have a nice layer of ice to pickup from. I would have the same problem you have if I were loading from a non-compacted area that wasn't set-up ahead of time for a certain job. This summer you can rent a plate compactor, have some nice 3/4 minus crushed rock w/ binder delivered, build your load area, and then from now on use this area for storage....skid and process your logs in this area. I have also considered cement, but too costly, other options is pavement...which I have also considered and think would work very well, of you already know its easiect to load the last few scoops from a buck board..so you'll need to make a backstop (buck board) somewhere at the back of your loading area.
Other than that the only thing I can think of is to use a conveyor.
By the way...you're pretty close, just a little low, on our volume of wood sales. I have to mechinize ever step I can to effeciently put out the volume were doing. The value added buddles sound better ever time I think about it....less materail to deal with, which means one less logisitical challenge to face.....which means I have more time to spend w/ my 11 year old boy doing soemthing fun!
 
 

Marketplace Items

2022 New Holland Boomer 45 (A64911)
2022 New Holland...
2022 CATERPILLAR 299D3 SKID STEER (A65056)
2022 CATERPILLAR...
GENERAC MOBILE PRODUCTS  MAGNUM LIGHT/WATER PLANT (INOPERABLE) (A67714)
GENERAC MOBILE...
Survey Kit (A64912)
Survey Kit (A64912)
2013 WACKER NEUSON HF 690 FLAMELESS HEATER TRAILER (INOPERABLE) (A67714)
2013 WACKER NEUSON...
2014 HAMM HD+140I DOUBLE DRUM ROLLER (A65056)
2014 HAMM HD+140I...
 
Top