Help Me Decide

[CurtisG]

I am in the process of deciding which tractor I want to buy to replace my old one. I want a FEL along with either a brush cutter or finishing mower. My choices have been narrowed down to two manufacturers. Either a Kubota B2620HSD/B2920HSD or a Mahindra 2516HST/2816HST. The Mahindra's seem to be a sturdier built tractor along with a 5 year warranty, but I know the Kubota has a very good reputation. Any help would be appreciated.
I also looked at a LS model S3010 and was impressed with the build but don't know about the quality of it. Both the Mahindra & LS use a Mitsubishi engine.

Thanks,
Curt
1987 DeutzAllis 5220

 

[SPYDERLK]

urs name is faggish so gtfo ******, and suck my lawn

Dead member ...

 

[radman1]

Dead member ...

I am totally confused. Did you have a mini stroke?

To the OP, I would go with Kubota hands down if the price and specs are similar. I will put my flame suit on first. Lots of people like Mahindra on TBN but in my area, the resale of a kubota is much better than a Mahindra. Kubota also has more dealers, better name recognition, and builds a very good tractor. Only 2 mahindra dealers in my state. Mahindra dealers have a tendency to come and go. Other than on a dealers lot, I have never seen a Mahindra in actual use. Your area may be different.

 

[SPYDERLK]

I am totally confused. Did you have a mini stroke?

No .. That quote comes from the thread. That new member made it to 10 posts and was deleted. What you see is an example captured in my predictive response. I also have a cute private message from it.
larry

 

[TripleR]

I would have to agree with the other poster unless things are much different in your area. We now have no Mahindra dealers in our area, but I am sure someone will try again.

I can't honestly say Kubota is a better tractor, but in the long run I would buy one now due to dealer support, resale value and such.

 

[whistlepig]

I am in the process of deciding which tractor I want to buy to replace my old one. I want a FEL along with either a brush cutter or finishing mower. My choices have been narrowed down to two manufacturers. Either a Kubota B2620HSD/B2920HSD or a Mahindra 2516HST/2816HST. The Mahindra's seem to be a sturdier built tractor along with a 5 year warranty, but I know the Kubota has a very good reputation. Any help would be appreciated.
I also looked at a LS model S3010 and was impressed with the build but don't know about the quality of it. Both the Mahindra & LS use a Mitsubishi engine.

Thanks,
Curt
1987 DeutzAllis 5220

The Kubota CUT's are going to be lighter in weight than any other tractor of comparable size and horsepower. They are designed to do the same work of a much larger and heavier tractor. This is what Kubota does best.

 

[CurtisG]

Thanks for the replies, after reviewing the specs on both I don't see a lot of difference other than the larger displacement engine on the Mahindra and slightly higher lift capacities. Both dealers are reputable but if Kubota comes back with the 0% financing in June, I will probably go with the B2620HST/FEL.
The Mahindra was priced about $1300 lower than the Kubota but if financed the rate was 4.99% so the Kubota would be cheaper in the end. If I pay cash the Mahindra is the better deal. As this is the last tractor I will buy (I'm getting old!) the resale value doesn't apply. I hope to make a decision next week, I'll keep you posted on what I purchase.

Curt

 

[brin]

Thanks for the replies, after reviewing the specs on both I don't see a lot of difference other than the larger displacement engine on the Mahindra and slightly higher lift capacities. Both dealers are reputable but if Kubota comes back with the 0% financing in June, I will probably go with the B2620HST/FEL.
The Mahindra was priced about $1300 lower than the Kubota but if financed the rate was 4.99% so the Kubota would be cheaper in the end. If I pay cash the Mahindra is the better deal. As this is the last tractor I will buy (I'm getting old!) the resale value doesn't apply. I hope to make a decision next week, I'll keep you posted on what I purchase.

Curt

" As this is the last tractor I will buy (I'm getting old!) the resale value doesn't apply."

Ahhh, I'm getting old too.....So you are going to take your tractor with you when you go like me....smart move...:laughing::thumbsup:

 

[BigD23]

Both are excellent tractor makes...I agree with going with one who has a good local dealer...Good luck.

Don

 

[TripleR]

Thanks for the replies, after reviewing the specs on both I don't see a lot of difference other than the larger displacement engine on the Mahindra and slightly higher lift capacities. Both dealers are reputable but if Kubota comes back with the 0% financing in June, I will probably go with the B2620HST/FEL.
The Mahindra was priced about $1300 lower than the Kubota but if financed the rate was 4.99% so the Kubota would be cheaper in the end. If I pay cash the Mahindra is the better deal. As this is the last tractor I will buy (I'm getting old!) the resale value doesn't apply. I hope to make a decision next week, I'll keep you posted on what I purchase.

Curt

I don't know how old you are, but if it works for you then that is the way to go. I too am getting old and thought my last two tractors were my last and now I am planning my next purchase down the road.

 

[jenkinsph]

Curtis,
If thisi is going to be your last tractor purchase make sure it is what you wan't. If you have never had a little hst cab tractor you should at least look into this. Lot more comfort for tired old bones.

 

[TripleR]

Curtis,
If thisi is going to be your last tractor purchase make sure it is what you wan't. If you have never had a little hst cab tractor you should at least look into this. Lot more comfort for tired old bones.

Very good advice. I was going to try to save a few bucks when I bought my last tractor and my wife talked me into another cab. Man I am so glad she did after spending several days bush hogging and pushing trees over.

 

[flusher]

I am in the process of deciding which tractor I want to buy to replace my old one. I want a FEL along with either a brush cutter or finishing mower. My choices have been narrowed down to two manufacturers. Either a Kubota B2620HSD/B2920HSD or a Mahindra 2516HST/2816HST. The Mahindra's seem to be a sturdier built tractor along with a 5 year warranty, but I know the Kubota has a very good reputation. Any help would be appreciated.
I also looked at a LS model S3010 and was impressed with the build but don't know about the quality of it. Both the Mahindra & LS use a Mitsubishi engine.

Thanks,
Curt
1987 DeutzAllis 5220

It's a coin toss--I've owned both brands--a new 2005 Kubota B7510HSD (21 hp engine, 17 hp pto, 4WD, hydrostatic tranny) with the LA302 FEL and a new 2008 Mahindra 5525 (54 hp engine, 45 hp pto, 2WD, gear tranny) with the ML250 FEL. Maintenance is easy on both of these tractors.

I'd check the dealer's service and parts departments and factor this into you choice.

 

[CurtisG]

Well I made my decision today and ordered a Kubota B3300SU loader package along with a Land Pride 5' finishing mower (orange of course) Thanks to all who replied and helped me make my decision! The tractor was still in the crate and should be assembled and ready by Tuesday.

Curt

 

[CurtisG]

Got it!! Kubota B3300SU tractor/loader was delivered Wednesday. After many hours of looking and reading I decided on the Kubota. It fits my needs perfectly.

Curt