How reliable and durable are Craftsman Lawn tractors?

   / How reliable and durable are Craftsman Lawn tractors? #41  
I realize this is an old thread, but I posted in it back in 2012 when I had just purchased my Craftsman YT4000 (made by Husqvarna) and I thought this might be a good place to post an update.

The machine is now 7 years old, but only has 168 hours. I don't have as much lawn here as I used to at my old place. I probably mow about 1/3 acre, but half of that is pretty rough. It is former woodland, not fully tamed. I have removed a lot of rocks and stumps, but still have some that I need to be careful of.

The 24 hp B&S v-twin still purrs like new. No complaints at all so far on the engine, regardless of the low opinion some have of B&S.

I took the deck out from under today to replace the blades. I thought I had heard a bearing starting to rumble. Sure enough, the lower bearing on the left side is loosening. These are the "sealed for life" type. I consider 168 hours to be a pretty short life!:thumbdown: I put the mower back together for now, but I have just ordered a kit of 2 replacement spindle assemblies with grease fittings. (Over many years in the past, have owned 3 of the older heavy duty Cub Cadets. All had greaseable spindles and I never lost a bearing in one.)

The battery that came with this mower had the "Diehard" label on it. I thought it died pretty easy. I think I got 3 years out of it. The second battery was a no-name, but with a higher cca rating. I'm at about 4 years and counting with that one.

This relatively low-end model does not have the electric PTO clutch. Instead, there is a lever above the steering wheel, connected by cable to a belt tightener pulley. This arrangement works fine except if you forget to throttle down before disengaging. If you disengage at full throttle, it will throw the belt off the engine pulley. It is not hard to put back on, but you have to shut down and get off the tractor to do so.

Othewise, I have had no trouble or complaints. The old Craftsman (red Husqvarna) has done a good job for me.

I recently came home with "lawn tractor envy" after trying out a newer, bigger Husqvarna model that my daughter bought used. Sure, I would like a new bigger, better unit. I even started researching and looking at zero-turns. However, I can't justify the expense. With the new greaseable spindles, my YT4000 should go a good while longer. Maybe I can give you an update in another 7 years.:laughing:
 
   / How reliable and durable are Craftsman Lawn tractors? #42  
Thanks for the update!
 
   / How reliable and durable are Craftsman Lawn tractors? #43  
I have a DLT2000 (I believe) Hydrostatic. Been going for 17 years with never a problem! Replaced a deck belt once and the battery once. That is it. 10 gauge deck with electric clutch. I Want a zero turn, but I can稚 kill this craftsman.
 
   / How reliable and durable are Craftsman Lawn tractors? #44  
I got tired of the slow blade speed, large turning radius, 3in max deck height and a few other odds and ends from my various craftsman/husqvarna lawn tractors. O and i got to the point that i had to stock deck belts and deck mandrels.
Last fall i bought a used 48in zero turn bobcat. Cut my mowing time in half even from the gt5000 53in deck i usento have. Il never own another home owner grade mower again.

The 23hp kohler that was in my gt5000 has now been on my sawmill for a few years. You may not kill the engine its just everything else that will fall appart.
 
   / How reliable and durable are Craftsman Lawn tractors? #45  
I bought a Sears 10 hp lawn tractor in76 when I moved to the country (rebadged Murray), mowed with it until 91, mowing about an acre. The B & S engine was still running, the deck got so sloppy it was hard to keep belts on it, gave it away and that guy used a few years, and gave it to neighbor kids who played with it a while before it died.
Bought a Craftsman LT 12.5 in 91 (another rebadged Murray), still use it (needs carb work, ethanol did it in) They are as good as any for mowing.
The most efficient mower is ZTR, bought a commercial Hustler in 04, and cut my mowing time in half.
 
   / How reliable and durable are Craftsman Lawn tractors? #46  
I've got a 99 GT5000 I bought from Sears to mow and plow a garden. I got their little brinly plow and disk and eventually put a rear grader on it for snow duty. I replaced one idler on the deck and a couple belts over that time. The Die Hard battery lasted really well, about 9 years. Last year when I had a belt let go and wrap itself up around the crank pulley breaking and bending a bunch of stuff. Certainly no fault of Sears. I've fixed it and still use it some, but I really prefer to mow with the Bolens/Iseki. Even though it has a 3 point mower, I enjoy it more. It also uses less fuel.
The Sears has served me well, I don't know how well current ones are made. I believe Huskvarna made these.
 
   / How reliable and durable are Craftsman Lawn tractors? #47  
First off, Craftsman don't make a tractor.
Probably a MTD product that is now owned by Toro/Ariens.
There is a whole lot of branding out there but few actual manufacturers.

In fact Sears actually don't manufacture anything, goes for tools, power equipment and white goods.
They just private label existing goods with minor changes.

A big problem with branding is that part #'s usually don't interchange as well as shops generally refuse to service those private label goods.
For service it takes a special type of mechanic (AKA, a real handy type) not usually found in larger shops or dealerships.
Dealerships tend to stick to their brand.

When U get to tools you'll discover that Stanley/DeWalt just about have the whole market covered.
 
   / How reliable and durable are Craftsman Lawn tractors? #48  
I've got a 99 GT5000 I bought from Sears to mow and plow a garden. I got their little brinly plow and disk and eventually put a rear grader on it for snow duty. I replaced one idler on the deck and a couple belts over that time. The Die Hard battery lasted really well, about 9 years. Last year when I had a belt let go and wrap itself up around the crank pulley breaking and bending a bunch of stuff. Certainly no fault of Sears. I've fixed it and still use it some, but I really prefer to mow with the Bolens/Iseki. Even though it has a 3 point mower, I enjoy it more. It also uses less fuel.
The Sears has served me well, I don't know how well current ones are made. I believe Huskvarna made these.

Depending on exact year it could be an AYP built unit, my red GT 5000 was, Husqvarna bought them out along with any remaining Electrolux products, although they were likely out of the system by then. MTD built some lawn tractors for them, but not garden tractors. At least not in the last 25-30 years.
 
   / How reliable and durable are Craftsman Lawn tractors? #49  
I have 500+ hours on my 2009 Craftsman lawn tractor. Replaced belts and spindles and had the transmission mount break at 500 hours. Fixed it and replaced the fluid in the “sealed” tranny and hope to get 500 more hours!

Semi retired the Craftsman a few years ago when I upgraded to a Hustler zero turn. The Craftsman has a bagger so I still use it for leaves and anytime I need to bag.
 
   / How reliable and durable are Craftsman Lawn tractors? #50  
I will be buying a new lawn tractor to replace my 8hp Snapper RER which is 28 years old and just went bad on me. I guess I should not complain :). My price range is $1500-$2000. My lawn is 3/4 acre and basically flat. Up to this point, I have not considered the Craftsman lawn tractors because I always heard homeowners say they had a lot of problems with them in the past. Could you guys talk about the reliability and durability of these products? What suggestions/input can anyone give me on this matter? Has anyone experienced any reliability/durability problems with this brand as a whole? How has anyone found Craftsman manufacturer/retail support in the event of a problem? Who makes Craftsman lawn tractors and are they basically the same as Husqvarna tractors? Does anyone know anything about Columbia lawn tractors? Thanks for your help!

The Craftsman to find,

CTX 9500 Series, starts with model number 107. (the designation for being built by Simplicity)

TractorData.com Craftsman 17.257 tractor information

247. is MTD and 917. is Husqvarna
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2013 TALBERT TRI-AXLE DETACH TRAILER (A53843)
2013 TALBERT...
2023 ALLMAND MAXI-POWER 15XR GENERATOR (A53843)
2023 ALLMAND...
2019 MACK PINNACLE P164T DAY CAB ROAD TRACTOR (A51406)
2019 MACK PINNACLE...
2010 Ford Transit Connect Cargo Van (A53117)
2010 Ford Transit...
2008 Ford F-250 (A53473)
2008 Ford F-250...
2017 HITACHI ZX350LC EXCAVATOR (A54607)
2017 HITACHI...
 
Top