Around here, it makes a big difference if you are near/far from the fire station. It also makes a difference if your fire department has a high rating. Insurance companies know if your FD is fully staffed, has quality and ample equipment, and is fully trained. I have also noted lately that Ins co's are starting to charge more the people that live in areas that are more apt to have a claim. Are you in a flood plain, tornado alley, hurricane, fire, or landslide area? Your premiums probably went up more than people that are not.