Comparison Is the MX 5200 worth the extra $4000 Compared to the MX 5100 ?

   / Is the MX 5200 worth the extra $4000 Compared to the MX 5100 ? #1  

rabcon

Member
Joined
Dec 18, 2005
Messages
46
Location
NY
Tractor
312B , 307SB Cat, 450G Deere, Kubota MX5200 825i Gator
Was Thinking of trading my L5030 HST For the MX 5200. THe Dealer has a MX 5100 with 22 hrs. Going Monday to Price the 5100 . The deal for the MX 5200 is $17500 Traded. Not sure what the differance is betten the 5100 to the 5200. I know the 5200 is the tyre 4. Any suggestions?
 
   / Is the MX 5200 worth the extra $4000 Compared to the MX 5100 ? #2  
I'd jump on the 5100 if it was me.
 
   / Is the MX 5200 worth the extra $4000 Compared to the MX 5100 ? #3  
Be there when the doors open on Monday and workout a deal to get the MX5100. :cool2:

Be sure to get those rear remotes in the deal. ;)
 
   / Is the MX 5200 worth the extra $4000 Compared to the MX 5100 ? #4  
For 4K difference I would take a 5100 personally.
 
   / Is the MX 5200 worth the extra $4000 Compared to the MX 5100 ?
  • Thread Starter
#5  
I will be there to check out the 5100 a LITTLE CLOSER. Thanks
 
   / Is the MX 5200 worth the extra $4000 Compared to the MX 5100 ? #6  
Are you saying they want your L5030 plus $17,500?
 
   / Is the MX 5200 worth the extra $4000 Compared to the MX 5100 ? #7  
Unless your current tractor has seen better days, I'm not sure what would be gained by swapping your L5030 for either MX5100 or 5200. From a performance standpoint, they are close enough to your current setup it shouldn't make any great difference in the amount of work you would get done, and feature-wise, you've already got a pretty respectable setup. You can get a gear drive model with the MX, if that means anything for you, but you'd need to go to the M series utilities to get a significantly larger chassis, more hydraulics, etc.
 
   / Is the MX 5200 worth the extra $4000 Compared to the MX 5100 ? #8  
I agree w/ grandad. I'm curious, does the MX have some features that your current machine doesn't have?
 
   / Is the MX 5200 worth the extra $4000 Compared to the MX 5100 ? #9  
Unless your current tractor has seen better days, I'm not sure what would be gained by swapping your L5030 for either MX5100 or 5200. From a performance standpoint, they are close enough to your current setup it shouldn't make any great difference in the amount of work you would get done, and feature-wise, you've already got a pretty respectable setup. You can get a gear drive model with the MX, if that means anything for you, but you'd need to go to the M series utilities to get a significantly larger chassis, more hydraulics, etc.

FWIW, that was my thinking as well. The MX5100 is a very nice tractor (seriously considered it a few months ago), but so is your L5030. Assume you know that the MX is usually described as a cross (X) model, with an L-series front end and an M-series rear end. This according to both dealers where I kicked the tires. Is there a particular reason you want to trade?
 
   / Is the MX 5200 worth the extra $4000 Compared to the MX 5100 ? #10  
I would trade the 5030 to get rid of the HST, but not just to trade. The MX and your L are very close.

If I could get a MX5100 for $17500 I'd buy it right now!!!
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2011 INTERNATIONAL PROSTAR PREMIUM DAY CAB ROAD TR (A51243)
2011 INTERNATIONAL...
AGT Agrotk 680 Drop Hammer Attachment (A47384)
AGT Agrotk 680...
2019 CATERPILLAR 262D3 WHEELED SKID STEER (A51242)
2019 CATERPILLAR...
2019 GENIE GTH-5519 TELESCOPIC FORKLIFT (A51242)
2019 GENIE...
2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
2022 JOHN DEERE 320G WHEELED SKID STEER (A51242)
2022 JOHN DEERE...
 
Top