Sorry, I did not mean to imply that all raw elements in a dogs diet are bad. I didn't think I said that. I was only talking about eggs, nothing else. What's more, I was thinking (and did not say, I admit) about store bought eggs. Store bought things are much more dangerous because they are stored longer, may not be as carefully handled, and more likely to get contaminated.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( Depending on what your definition of anecdotal is, Cliff, I find subjective evidence to be very helpful. )</font>
Anecdotal evidance is evidance based on anecdote, that is, an example rather than a study. For instance, you talk to ten people who each say they took a particular drug and never had a problem This is anecdotal evidance. If you study them (or more likely a much larger population) and measure their whole health you may find that the incedance of brain tumors is extrardinairly high in this group. No one would report this. From an anecdotal point of view, the drug is perfectly fine.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( I believe most sites and books DO provide the reason that dogs do not get salmonella.)</font>
I've never seen any evidance that the harsher climate in the dogs stomach kills all salmonella, and since dogs do get diagnosed with salmonella poisoning, I think it's clear that it's not absolutely true. I would not doubt they have a harder time getting it than humans, in fact I believe it is quite rare. Consider also the issue of the B vitamins I noted in the last post.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( that the growing number of people feeding their dogs a raw diet . . .. Heck, even my vet gave his dog a quail leg when we were out hunting, but he does not promote feeding a raw diet. He knows there's nothing wrong with it either. )</font>
Eggs are the issue here. Raw game is unlikely to carry salmonella like poultry barn chickens handled and moved to market are.
By the way, in england I understand that processed dog food is much less popular and they usually feed a raw diet just as they always have.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( you have nver heard of a dog being fed a raw diet dieing from bloat either. )</font>
I never heard that. That's interesting. Is it because they can't eat it as fast as they can eat processed dog food? There are many things about a raw diet that are appealing (well, for the dog that is), I just have a problem with the store bought eggs.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( Let's not get personal here, Cliff. )</font>
I sincerly appologise if anything I wrote sounded like a personal statement. It was not my intention at all. I think debate is always informative and useful. I sugest only that people should know the value and the risks of any food they give to their dog and by the way, just because you use store bought dog food doesn't mean there aren't risks. There are many including an increased likelyhood of having alergiic or chemical reactions to their food.
Respectfully,
Cliff