JD 2520 PTO won't stop turning.

   / JD 2520 PTO won't stop turning. #11  
The PTO clutch on the 2520 is only accessed by splitting the tractor also. I own the service manual and read through the steps myself and decided for my sanity I better not undertake it alone. They are expecting 24 hours of labor. 24hr by $145/hr equals $3480 in labor.

Shop time in Aaska is only $106/hr. 'Course it was a $100/hr at the dealer in Devil's Lake, ND this Spring... I guess if you've got oil - everything goes to a "cost plus" basis!

All in all, it still seems excessively high.

I think I'd "waste" some phone time with the corporate rep anyway..

AKfish
 
   / JD 2520 PTO won't stop turning. #12  
I can see where shop mechanics (not only Deere) who are now having to train for weeks to dive into a $350,000 Deere machine with all the latest bells and whistles and computer electronics are worth the big bucks to the Dealers who have to come out in the black at the end of the month.

Problem then is if the computer trained mechanic is the one that puts in the hours splitting a tractor and fixing the simple problem, but the dealer costs per hour are the same. A real dilemma that bites us all (unless we are the one with the computer problem in the big expensive combine or harvester machine).
 
   / JD 2520 PTO won't stop turning.
  • Thread Starter
#13  
Shop time at the local ford dealer is $185, so to me I wasn't shocked when they said $145.

We are working with the corporate Deere rep to have them cover some or all of the cost, but no decision from them yet.
 
   / JD 2520 PTO won't stop turning. #14  
For $3480. I would do it myself. The service manual is the same book the shop will be working from and I doubt they replace that many PTO clutches on 2520's.
 
   / JD 2520 PTO won't stop turning.
  • Thread Starter
#15  
For $3480. I would do it myself. The service manual is the same book the shop will be working from and I doubt they replace that many PTO clutches on 2520's.
I really wanted to do it myself, that is why I bought the service manual. Between work and my kids I only have about 2-3 hours a week to work on things. Once I read the manual I realized that I just didn't have the time to commit tithe project. I know the money hurts, we were hoping to take the family somewhere tropical this winter, but getting the tractor back in top running shape was the wise choice.

Sent from my iPhone using TractorByNet
 
   / JD 2520 PTO won't stop turning. #16  
I can see where shop mechanics (not only Deere) who are now having to train for weeks to dive into a $350,000 Deere machine with all the latest bells and whistles and computer electronics are worth the big bucks to the Dealers who have to come out in the black at the end of the month.

Problem then is if the computer trained mechanic is the one that puts in the hours splitting a tractor and fixing the simple problem, but the dealer costs per hour are the same. A real dilemma that bites us all (unless we are the one with the computer problem in the big expensive combine or harvester machine).

Well... Yes and no... Normally, the combine guy doesn't jump into fixing the small, compact tractor (unless that's all they've got in the shop) or the lawn mowers or chainsaws, either!

Not all mechanics are created equally - in any given dealership. And they don't all earn the same pay...

As well, the training and the necessary repairs and cost of parts for the "big ticket" machines is an order of magnitude different than is the case for the less complex equipment. Not even in the same ballpark... That said, I would imagine that the cost of inventory for spare parts, etc. for the large HP equipment is also a significantly greater "fixed cost" for the dealership.

I would also venture that the "cost per labor hour" for the dealership is significantly higher for repairs on a 20,000lb tractor or 30,000lb combine than it is for an 1,800lb compact tractor!

Nonetheless, it may well be that this particular dealer charges $145/hr for shop time for anything 75hp and less, etc. And they charge $185/hr for the bigger, more complex machines. Don't know...

What I do know is that this particular dealer in Alberta is about 35% more expensive than Alaska to repair a small, compact tractor!

AKfish
 
   / JD 2520 PTO won't stop turning. #17  
My dealer has 3 price ranges.

1) Regular price with me at home.
2) me watching price.
3) me helping price.

Guess which price is the cheapest.
 
   / JD 2520 PTO won't stop turning. #18  
My dealer has 3 price ranges.

1) Regular price with me at home.
2) me watching price.
3) me helping price.

Guess which price is the cheapest.

Yeah.. Every place I go - that's how they all roll!

But... Did you ever consider that your dealer could be "makin' up for lost $$" on those "easy tractor" repairs?

AKfish
 
   / JD 2520 PTO won't stop turning. #19  
Yeah.. Every place I go - that's how they all roll!

But... Did you ever consider that your dealer could be "makin' up for lost $$" on those "easy tractor" repairs?

AKfish

I always wondered why a car dealer can spend an hour doing a service but a tractor dealer needs to have it for a week to "work it in" for roughly the same service but a LOT more money.
 
   / JD 2520 PTO won't stop turning. #20  
The answer is there are very few tractor repair shops, especially non-dealer shops. I am blessed in having found the local retired Deere service manager who makes house calls.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2020 DRAGON 150BBL ALUMINUM (A58214)
2020 DRAGON 150BBL...
2024 CASE TV620B SKID STEER (A52709)
2024 CASE TV620B...
2023 HELI CPYD25C FORKLIFT (A58214)
2023 HELI CPYD25C...
2025 transit van (A56858)
2025 transit van...
FUEL CELL (A58214)
FUEL CELL (A58214)
New 40ft High Cube 6 Door Container (A59000)
New 40ft High Cube...
 
Top