Kernopelli said:
This is not pointed (directly) at Kama, but I will intertwine a personal story. I purchased a Kazuma 150CC ATV for my son a few years ago. It ate a reverse gear rather quickly and was replaced under warranty. I replaced it and it snapped an axle off at the hub soon after that. Next was another reverse gear and replaced it myself. The third reverse gear that broke destroyed the entire gear cluster and trans case. I ended up removing the entire trans unit and machining a splined shaft coming of the rear CVT clutch and supported it with a pillow block bearing and attached the countershaft sprocket in that manner. It has worked great since. Before removing the trans entirely I considered having new gears cryogenicly hardened but the company I was going to have do it explained they see a lot of gear sets and other components manufactured in China come from customers like me these days. He said they could indeed harden the material but the bottom line was the quality of the original material was the real problem and while you could help it, you can't make it into something it isn't. Other components of this 4 wheeler have held up very well, but they seem to be "over built". I think China will eventually emerge as a great manufacturing nation similar to Japan, but until they can work though some things like materials deficiency's, buyers of their products may get a product that is very attractively priced but may have to trade that for a little aggravation. I'll guess those gears were "well" hardened but are inherently going to be a weak point. I think Rob has a real work horse with a great price and proper design but will occasionally have this sort of repair until the manufacturers have access to better overall materials for some applications. Another great post Rob!!
Good story, Darryl. One day I may get one of those Chinese ATVs. I am
sure they will continue to improve. They are quite inexpensive.
I agree that China's manufacturing rep will keep on improving, much like
Korean manufacturing has already. It was with some trepidation that I
bought several new Korean tractors a few years ago, and I have not been
disappointed. I may have even been willing to buy a Chinese tractor at
one point, since I have always been willing to do my own repairs. At the
time there were no HSTs, so that kept me from doing so.
A bit more care in assembly would be nice, as well as materials improvement.
I just rebuilt one of those Harbor Freight 5" hyd cyls used in their big
log splitter and the materials seemed OK, but one of the seals was outright
missing and the piston nut was loose!