Lack of Yanmar Tractors?

Status
Not open for further replies.
   / Lack of Yanmar Tractors? #41  
I read the court document as I posted previously. The court order involves Wallace and anyone affiliated with him, not Joe down the street. It does, however, set precedence, just like I'm sure whatever case(s) Kubota won did for Yanmar. Now I've read eBay's policy . Yanmar obviously waived the court order involving Wallace under their nose and they flinched because of the possibility of a court ruling they were an active party to a similar set-up as Wallace's. The rest of that stuff is Yanmar's OPINION. I've dealt with patents and trademarks enough to know that a whole lot of it won't hold up and isn't even enforcable, it's not even common sense. So we know that they've gone after 2 big targets and won both times. I would imagine that if they haven't already, then they will be waiving the same document at those who are importing the tractors, especially those of any magnitude. Most of whom I'm sure will also just comply rather risk the expense of court. It still doesn't really affect the private individual with 1 tractor he no longer wants, other than he can't sell it on eBay. The ruling doesn't state and Yanmar can't afford to try to keep Joe from selling Bill his tractor. However, it appears a court has rulled making it potentially illegal for Joe to sell 1 a week.
 
   / Lack of Yanmar Tractors? #42  
You know, you can't even find a new Yanmar tractor here. I'm trying very hard to understand what the big deal is here. It would seem to me that our litigious society has crapped in the punchbowl once again. I shoulda bought green.
 
   / Lack of Yanmar Tractors? #43  
"Has the SEC made some kind of ruling?"

The SEC does not have to rule on anything. All they have to do is announce to the media and stock analysts that they are initiating an investigation into how Ebay earns their profits and Ebay stock will take a dive, regardless of the outcome.
 
   / Lack of Yanmar Tractors? #44  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( You know, you can't even find a new Yanmar tractor here. I'm trying very hard to understand what the big deal is here. )</font> I'm just guessing, but as I've stated before, based on the available information I bet Yanmar views the "greys" as a big hurdle to them selling tractors here in any quanity. Kubota obviously also saw a problem with it.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( I shoulda bought green )</font> This is the sentiment which I'm not sure I understand. As I see it, right now the only people who should really be wringing their hands over this are the guys who have been making a significant amount of their income importing and selling these tractors. Did anyone go around and confiscate all the "grey" Kubotas after they slowed the import of their foreign models? No, you still see individuals and even dealers owning and selling them. Just don't see them being imported. These tractors, just like all the other non-mainstream tractors, will continue to be what they currently are: cheap alternatives that are going to be a more of a hassle to own and repair. If you don't want to deal with that and had the $ then you should have bought green, or blue, or orange, etc... Anyway, you'll still be able to own, buy, and sell them outside of eBay. It just doesn't appear that will continue to be easy to import them. IMHO Ebay is hit and miss at best on equipment this size anyway.
 
   / Lack of Yanmar Tractors? #45  
I was close to closing a deal to buying a container full of yanmars. At least the dealer was nice enough to inform me that Yanmar has 4 lawsuits against sellers in Georgia so far.
I think I'll pass on the Yanmar's for now.
 
   / Lack of Yanmar Tractors? #46  
From a business point of view I can't see why Yanmar is acting so agressively on this. Havn't heard anything from the makers of the other Gray market tractors with the exception Kubota. Importation into this country is legal as is sales. Yanmar should not be responsible for the lack of ROPS or other safety equiptment due to the fact that these USED tractors were not made for sale in the US market. We bought them without them much like we would buy a used ford 8N. Yanmar and Kubota, for that matter, make a quality product. If Yanmar truely wanted to preserve it's good will and trademark thay would fully support their product because it will BE their lack of support and the factory agressive behavior that will turn off buyers to their products. It goes without saying that Yanmar and Kubota have some quality people in their respective Co. structures that realize this. Because sales of "gray markets" in this country are legal and looks like it will remain so, all they are doing is creating a bad image for their respective companies. I think the best thing Yanmar could do for their Co. with the gray market situation would be to FULLY SUPPORT their products. They could even go so far as to take over the recondition themselves. No doubt they could do a much better job of it. If they offered a ROPS kit conversion for all of their gray market tractors that are already in this country without them, no one could convict them of any neglence, only good intent, and they would make some good money doing so. Their is a great deal of money for all of the Gray Market OEM's to be made from this aftermarket. ROPS, PTO shields, Throtle conversions, U.S. stickers, Tractor Manuals. Executives in Yanmar or Kubota must feel that people selling the grays are somehow shrinking their market for new iron. I don't think a gray market buyer is a potential new tractor buyer, if he was he would own a new John Deere. I think the truth is many of us out here can't afford to put $10,000 - $20,000 into new or high end used tractor just to put 40 hours on a year brushhoging. Their is a strong market here for used compact tractors up to 40 hp. My hat is off to the people who have seezed this market and supported it. I can't understand Yanmar and Kubota for that matter, not makeing money on this market, it's a little like leaving gold nuggets in the stream because they aren't big enough!!!
Chris
 
   / Lack of Yanmar Tractors? #47  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( I think the best thing Yanmar could do for their Co. with the gray market situation would be to FULLY SUPPORT their products. )</font>

I think the best thing they could do would to stay out of it. If Yanmar accepts responsibility for these tractors, then each time someone injured themselves, they would be point the finger at Yanmar USA and filing a lawsuit.

The reason the others aren't pursuing it is because they haven't sold their tractors here in the amount Yanmar has. I have seen a couple Hinomoto's that were supposedly domestic models built for the US market. Hinomoto is out of business so they aren't anything to worry about. WIth Iseki there is only one dealer in the US and that is Rainbow in Hawaii. Shibaura has never sold under their own name in the US.
 
   / Lack of Yanmar Tractors? #48  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( Yanmar should not be responsible for the lack of ROPS or other safety equiptment due to the fact that these USED tractors were not made for sale in the US market. We bought them without them much like we would buy a used ford 8N. )</font> Unfortunately, while reasonable, this argument will not prevent Yanmar from being sued. The Ford N tractors were built long before many of these safety features were even thought of so they aren't judged the same way as far as liability is concerned and I bet they still get at least 1 suit a year filled against them on these tractors. The manufacturers have to spend $ on these cases even if they are unfounded or ridiculous.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( think the best thing Yanmar could do for their Co. with the gray market situation would be to FULLY SUPPORT their products. They could even go so far as to take over the recondition themselves. No doubt they could do a much better job of it. If they offered a ROPS kit conversion for all of their gray market tractors that are already in this country without them, no one could convict them of any neglence, only good intent, and they would make some good money doing so. Their is a great deal of money for all of the Gray Market OEM's to be made from this aftermarket. ROPS, PTO shields, Throtle conversions, U.S. stickers, Tractor Manuals )</font> I don't know what your backround or experience is, but do you have any idea how much it would cost Yanmar to fully support these tractors? IIRC the majority of the "greys" are like a minimum of 10 yrs old and span several design iterations, most likely many of these tractors have limited OEM support back in Japan. They probably rely on the aftermarket companies, make parts as needed (ie big $), or simply don't support them. This is true for many manufactured products. Just setting up an official supply chain would be big $. The other issue here is that if they were to start re-conditioning and/or offering conversions, while you see it as good intentions, others (see US courts) see it as an admission of guilt. Again, this isn't necessarily right, just the way it is. Besides, how many of you guys are going to rush out and buy all these conversion kits when been using your tractors w/out them. I doubt that enough people would fork over enough $ just to offset their cost. Remember, you're probably talking about specific kits for many different models, not just a universal kit.
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( I don't think a gray market buyer is a potential new tractor buyer, if he was he would own a new John Deere. I think the truth is many of us out here can't afford to put $10,000 - $20,000 into new or high end used tractor just to put 40 hours on a year brushhoging )</font> Honestly, I would guess that for every guy who buys a "grey" b/c it's the most he can afford, there is guy who bought one b/c even though he could afford the green one he wanted to save the other $6k+. People with money often didn't get that way by spending top $ all the time. I also doubt that if the "greys" were fully supported that they would continue to be great values. You are in fact buying at a discount b/c they aren't mainstream, fully supported pieces of equipment. Full supoort means factory authorized dealerships, which means you'll see the same price structures. I would expect them to start bringing the same $ as comperable used tractors meant for the US market. (ie used US Kubotas)
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( Their is a strong market here for used compact tractors up to 40 hp. My hat is off to the people who have seezed this market and supported it. I can't understand Yanmar and Kubota for that matter, not makeing money on this market, it's a little like leaving gold nuggets in the stream because they aren't big enough!!! )</font> You just hit the nail on the head. If the $ were there to make it worth their while, they would support it. The tell tale sign is that, so far, as I understand it the aftermarket hasn't made an attempt to take up the slack. If the $ were there, someone would be making aftermarket parts trying to capitalize on it.
 
   / Lack of Yanmar Tractors?
  • Thread Starter
#49  
You see things different than me.. I read these documents and conclude that Yanmar is saying that you can not sell any grey in the us period.....You say that it does not effect Joe down the street????
I don't understand your thinking.....
 
   / Lack of Yanmar Tractors?
  • Thread Starter
#50  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( </font><font color="blueclass=small">( font> You just hit the nail on the head. If the $ were there to make it worth their while, they would support it. The tell tale sign is that, so far, as I understand it the aftermarket hasn't made an attempt to take up the slack. If the $ were there, someone would be making aftermarket parts trying to capitalize on it. )</font>
They are making aftermarket parts for used grey maket yanmars.....Fredricks for one... There is big money here but it prob would be best if Yanmar would just stay out of it...
I wonder why a Japaneese rice farmer who has a good used tractor can export it to the US or else where but we can't buy or sell them... We are talking used... Yanmar made the money that they intended to make when they sold the thing to the Japanees farmer..... When they start selling new tractors here I aint buying unless they give me FMV for my used Yanmar......
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2019 KENWORTH T680 TANDEM AXLE SLEEPER (A52576)
2019 KENWORTH T680...
2018 JLG 4045R 40FT. Electric Scissor Lift (A51691)
2018 JLG 4045R...
ALL TITLED ITEMS HAVE A $35 TITLE FEE!!! (A50775)
ALL TITLED ITEMS...
2011 Toyota RAV4 4x4 SUV (A51694)
2011 Toyota RAV4...
2020 Steiner 450 Slope Mower (A51573)
2020 Steiner 450...
9202 (A50322)
9202 (A50322)
 
Top