Z-Michigan
Veteran Member
RalphVa said:The old way of working dirt on the farm was with plow, disc and then harrow, often pulling harrow behind the disc.
And when you're done, you should have nice fluffy soil for the first 3-6" deep, and soilcrete below that. I say this from personal experience; if I have to disk an area more than twice - and I usually do the garden several times - my last pass over the area is with a scarifier to loose things back up. A chisel plow or subsoiler would be just as good; but none of these will leave a smooth finish.
I agree with Ralph and others that a fine finish can be had with a RR tie, or a straight log, or a chain harrow if you have one. In our garden we plant by hand so a fine finish isn't needed. If I were doing a large area I would probably try to disk once with disk alone, then a second time with the disk pulling my chain harrow, and stop at those two passes. Maybe my soil is more prone to compaction than some, but multiple passes create a lot of compaction below 3-6" in my soil.