We did a club house at an apartment complex once with faux Spanish tile roof. It was a screw down metal shingle, with small brick granules attached. It did look good, and it still does 18 years later; But we spent some real time tracking leaks down, as they could appear 30 or 50 ft from the source. As I remember, all leaks were related to cock-eyed screws. It was an expensive product though, and all the apartments go a brick colored, architectural asphalt shingle roof. Personally, I prefer a clean 3 tab solid color over architectural.