Separate Brakes...whats the point..???

   / Separate Brakes...whats the point..??? #11  
Its been a few years but I think the backhoes had left foot brake as the throttle was right foot. It is a learning curve though.

That is the way our backhoe is also
 
   / Separate Brakes...whats the point..???
  • Thread Starter
#12  
I know this is going to sound odd but to me the way the hydro/brake/clutch is set up on the 2920 is right foot is brakes and go pedal, left foot the clutch. Logic tells me that a better config would be go pedal and clutch right foot and brakes left foot. Reason I say this is in a hydro config there is no reason to have your foot on the go pedal and clutch at the same time but there are times when go pedal and brake at the same time would come in handy. Now with that said, it would take some getting used to for sure.
 
   / Separate Brakes...whats the point..??? #13  
Manufacturers don't usually "move" standard controls that might affect safety. Anybody remember the Audi 5000 "uncontrolled acceleration" fiasco from several years ago? It was splashed all over the "National Enquirer" type TV shows. That series of accidents resulted from just a very slightly different than usual location of the pedals.
In you car: Right foot; Go and Brake. Left foot; clutch. Instictively you hit the right one in an urgent situation. Move 'em and who knows what you'll hit???
 
   / Separate Brakes...whats the point..??? #14  
Manufacturers don't usually "move" standard controls that might affect safety. Anybody remember the Audi 5000 "uncontrolled acceleration" fiasco from several years ago? It was splashed all over the "National Enquirer" type TV shows. That series of accidents resulted from just a very slightly different than usual location of the pedals.
In you car: Right foot; Go and Brake. Left foot; clutch. Instictively you hit the right one in an urgent situation. Move 'em and who knows what you'll hit???

I see no real safety issue with putting the brake pedals on the left side (where they belong IMO)

A good operator can accommodate such changes.

Do we hear of it being a problem on a CNH tractor?
 
   / Separate Brakes...whats the point..??? #15  
I see no real safety issue with putting the brake pedals on the left side (where they belong IMO)

A good operator can accommodate such changes.

Do we hear of it being a problem on a CNH tractor?

There was a time when some motorcycle manufacturers, primarily foreign had the shift on right side and the brake on the left. In the seventies, due to safety considerations standardized left foot shift and right foot braking took place, so now all motorcycles are this way.

There may very well not be a "problem" if one only operates a certain type of machine, but if you go from one to the other such as between my Kubota and John Deere, there will be problems as not all of us are apparently "good operators" by your definition. I do know of accident caused by the brake and HST locations being different.
 
   / Separate Brakes...whats the point..??? #16  
I sure hope they don't move the brake to the left as I also have a John Deere 2305 with the brake on the left and absolutely hate it. My father in law put his John Deere into about ten feet of water over brake pedal confusion. Fortunately he was able to swim away, but he was really lucky.
Nothing like a swim petal.

I always knew deeres liked to swim..:D
I didn't know JDs had a swimming mode.
 
   / Separate Brakes...whats the point..??? #18  
Remember the older John Deere tractors with the brake pedals on their respective sides and the hand clutch lever on the right?Not too hard to learn!
 
   / Separate Brakes...whats the point..??? #19  
I don't need this feature so I have not tried this but I think it would work if you have the manual cruise control like my L3400.

Push the cruise to the speed you want. Then don't use the go pedal but use the clutch to stop and start. If you need frequent reversing this wouldn't work well.
 
   / Separate Brakes...whats the point..??? #20  
All of the geared tractors I've ever run have a foot feed and split brakes on the right. It is just the way it is done (but there are exceptions). If you want to use the split brakes, you have to use the hand feed for the throttle. I have often wished that I had a similar setup on my BX, but the wheelbase is so short that I doubt the split brakes would be very effective.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2017 E-Z Beever M12R Towable Brush Chipper (A50322)
2017 E-Z Beever...
Alamo SH88 88" 3pt Flail Mower (A50774)
Alamo SH88 88" 3pt...
New Holland TS6.120 4WD 96HP Agricultural Tractor (A50322)
New Holland...
UNUSED FUTURE SKID STEER MOUNTING PLATE (A51244)
UNUSED FUTURE SKID...
2025 CATERPILLAR 265 SKID STEER (A51242)
2025 CATERPILLAR...
2004 Caterpillar 345B Hydraulic Excavator (A50322)
2004 Caterpillar...
 
Top