some mahindra's seem to be nothing but trouble

justinbechard · Sep 14, 2005

some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

my 2810 has had more than its fair share of problems for a new tractor and i dont seem to be the only one. I purchased my tractor new so that i would not have to fix it. Granted i have not fixed it but when i want to get something done around the house it seems to break down. My dealer has been great about repairing it, but there have been several posts lately about mahindra problems on new machines. It appears that some people love em but on the other end some appear to be just plain lemons. I have friends with JD & kabota compacts and they have had no such problems. Is mahindras quality lacking, when i purchased my tractor there was very little complants on the TBN now it seems thats all there is.
Oh by the way it blew some module again and to start i have to cross the starter, second time this month.

DavesTractor · Sep 14, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

We have very, very few problems with Mahindras. They aren't perfect, nor are John Deere, New Holland, Kubota or others. Sorry you are having some problems and I hope your dealer continues to give you good support and gets to the bottom of the electrical issue.

jwcinpk · Sep 14, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

Yeah I second that and couple it with a dealer that won't keep his word makes you terribly mad! I am through this time! Regardless of loss mine is gone when it's fixed!

wallace · Sep 14, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

I understand the problems you are having with your tractor.
However I do think that a dealer will make a difference in a tractor name.
Each and every tractor brand does have its share of problems.
As for your problems I beleave it is the dealer that is putting the bad tast in your mouth.. Not the tractor brand.
What I do know is that parts are shared between manufactures and parts are also sourced from out side suppliers.Which means yes you mahindra does share parts with kubota and kioti and...... Beleave it or not.
Everybody raves about John Deere heck in all reality they don't even make their own machines.

I just hope that anyone that purchases a tractor does also look into their dealer not just into the $$$.

Sorry JMO don't mean to start a war /forums/images/graemlins/wink.gif

shvl73 · Sep 14, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

( It appears that some people love em but on the other end some appear to be just plain lemons. I have friends with JD & kabota compacts and they have had no such problems. )

Read some of the threads under the big three names, you'll see problems (even major ones) aren't isolated to one brand.

MessickFarmEqu · Sep 14, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

(
Read some of the threads under the big three names, you'll see problems (even major ones) aren't isolated to one brand. )

While this is very true. Its nieve to think that some brands don't excell over others in this area. I will openly admit that we have less problems with Kubota tractors than New Hollands. When reading forums about other problems you also need to take into account pure sales volumes. Kubota sells about 12x as many tractors as Mahindra, so I'd expect to see a fair amount more posts about people with issues.

disclaimer - I'm a NH/Kubota dealer and said nothing scathing Mahindra... I'm just trying to promote some discussion.

Tim_in_IA · Sep 14, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

MessickFarmEqu,

While some other dealer brands may excel in this area, I think you will only see Mahindra improve in this regard. The other brands have the distinct advantage of time on their sides. Mahindra will gain this and mature appropriately. Thank you for spurring the discussion /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif!

shvl73 · Sep 15, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

( When reading forums about other problems you also need to take into account pure sales volumes. Kubota sells about 12x as many tractors as Mahindra, so I'd expect to see a fair amount more posts about people with issues. )

I agree. People should read as much as possible on this site to help them make a more informed opinion.

skipmarcy · Sep 15, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

My opinion on the matter is that Mahindra has just as good a product as any of the other manufacturers. I had a serious problem with mine earlier this year (4110 broken bolts) but that problem was corrected and I still say that prior to and since that episode, I have been extremely happy with the service my tractor has given me. My main gripe was the lack of service/communication from Mahindra at the time and then they finally stepped up to the plate and took care of my situation and I am satisfied. Ask 100 different people which brand is better - Ford, GM, Chysler, Kubota, JD, Massey, NH - you'll get 100 varying answers. They all have built shining stars and lemons both. Any man-made mechanical contrivance can and eventually will fail, some just sooner than others. Mahindra has been building tractors for decades, just like the rest of them, they have probably just as many units out there as the other companies, just not all in the USA. I'm sure once they get their dealer network established well and weed-out the riff raff, they will be right up there with the other companies in sales and service.

musa_marketing · Sep 15, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

If you experience a problem that you believe has not been resolved to your satisfaction, please email me at marketing@mahindrausa.com. I cannot promise I can resolve every issue, but I will look into the matter and provide a response.

We have exceptional customer satisfaction with our tractors. No, not every one is perfect, but then what man-made mechanical device is. I can tell you we will try to ensure you are a happy and satisfied customer.

Varmintmist · Sep 15, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

Hey MUSA, take a look at my post on the 112 loader.

If there is a reason why the hyd lines cant be routed like that, let me know.

If it is a good fix that you adopt, I want a hat /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif

I have had only 2 problems with mine in 240 ish hours in under a year. The latest hyd line thing, and I jammed one of the front axel cups up into the knuckle. No problems with the dealer or the fix. I am willing to accept the cup as my fault because I very well may have came down on something bad. I used the fecal matter out of this little guy this summer in ways that probably not all by the book. I didnt buy it just to wax it.

Hyd lines blow and I didnt see it give so I will assume that I got something up against it. However that could be a better design. (shameless hat hint )

I have blown a hyd hose on a new JD so that in nothing against the Mahindra.

Nightrain1 · Sep 16, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

If Varmintmist gets a hat, I want one also. I am not rerouting lines or anything but I was a little suprised that when you buy a 3510, w/fel, and 3 other costly implements, no hats or anything come with it. They did however offer to deliver for free! Seriously, I am kidding about the hat, I have way to many now, but MUSA, your company is missing the boat in this regard. Hats and T's are a very cheap source of advertiseing. Just think, someday you could do like Harley Davidson and get the poor saps to pay you to advertise their product.

Willman · Sep 16, 2005

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

At time of delivery my dealer gave me a hat and a pen /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif

tractor_boy · Mar 20, 2006

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

Someone said in here that Deere doesn't make their own machines. I hope they weren't talking about the 5000 series because they are all made in Deere fully owned facilities. Even the one in India is 100% Deere.

wallace · Mar 20, 2006

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

When you say 5000 series give me some model number that you are refering to.
Are you saying like the 5320,5520,5420 and so, is that what you are calling the 5000 series?

rback33 · Mar 20, 2006

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

The real question I want an answer to is why he posted THAT question under THIS thread that had been dead since Sept.... as his first post.... seeems curious to me.... /forums/images/graemlins/shocked.gif

Travis_R · Mar 20, 2006

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

Where can I buy Mahindra hats, pens, shirts, etc..? I really enjoy my tough tractor and I want to "show" it. I HAVE BEEN LOOKING FOR MAHINDRA APPAREL FOR A LONG TIME WITH NO RESULTS.....IF SOME CAN HELP, PLEASE LET ME KNOW.

I just ordered some hats and a t-shirt from BUSH HOG in Selma, Alabama with no problems.

Thanks,
Travis

tractornewby · Mar 20, 2006

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

Someone posted this site a while back for Mahindra promotional stuff:

Mahindra Promotional Stuff

Regards,

TractorNewby

musa_marketing · Mar 22, 2006

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

( Where can I buy Mahindra hats, pens, shirts, etc..? I really enjoy my tough tractor and I want to "show" it. I HAVE BEEN LOOKING FOR MAHINDRA APPAREL FOR A LONG TIME WITH NO RESULTS.....IF SOME CAN HELP, PLEASE LET ME KNOW.

I just ordered some hats and a t-shirt from BUSH HOG in Selma, Alabama with no problems.

Thanks,
Travis )

Your Mahindra dealer can order these items for you. But with the numerous requests, I'm thinking of allowing customers to order direct. Good idea??

dieselsmoke1 · Mar 22, 2006

Re: some mahindra\'s seem to be nothing but trouble

Sound like a good idea, what can it hurt? Maybe even throw in consumables like filters for those of us that live many miles from the dealer.

I got a nice goody sack when I bought, but maybe because I humhawed till 2:00 pm on Saturday afternoon and the dealer would have given me the keys to the gate to get rid of me.

In my little world, myself and 2 friends, the experiences with the pieces and the dealer have been generally good. No complaints.