bmac said:
I don't think buddy likes being fenced in. Until he came here, he had the run of the world. No restrictions, no discipline. Things have changed. While I'm sure he loves the attention and food he's getting, I think he'd like to be "back on the road". When outside, he runs around the fence and barks non-stop. Looks like he may be getting a bark collar for Christmas.
Hey bmac, I'd sure encourage you to have Buddy neutered as soon as possible, even if, as the vet says, it might not alter his marking behavior.
Why? Well, here's the experience that we had with "Slim". When we bought our place, there had been a family living here as caretakers. Their little girl had a young yellow lab/pit bull, male. They couldn't keep him, wherever they were going when they moved on, and we took a stab at adopting him.
While Slim was thoroughly undisciplined, he was not a stray and had spent his whole young life (year to year and a half) on our place as an outside dog. He was a splendid looking dog, all white fur and black skin. He was smart. He was responsive and liked being around us. He began to take to common commands.
There was a problem though. Slim had reached sexual maturity. He was not neutered. We had been figuring, stupidly as it turned out, that if things seemed to be working out with Slim, we'd have him fixed and shots, etc. Well, our neighbor, who was in the habit of keeping many strays, had a female come into heat. Slim was off to the races. After about a day, they shot him with birdshot. He came home a mess, his whole left side covered in birdshot wounds.
We cleaned him up. He could hardly move. We wrapped him in blankets for the night. The next day, he was much better. He had some food and moved around enough to get the stiffness and limp out of his legs.
Then he was off again, or at least he was really determined to head right back there where he'd been shot. We chained him up in the front yard. Unfortunately, no fence. We live on the side of a hill in a clearing in the woods.
Here the story gets somewhat boring and sorta sad. Slim's wounds healed, although from that event forward, we called him Right Side Slim, because his left side was spotted with black skin/scars where he'd been shot.
The worst thing was that Slim did not like to be restrained and would not submit to it. His life had been pretty much as you described Buddy's, free and unrestrained. Our efforts at keeping Slim home nearly broke his spirit. You would have thought we started beating him. He became a very unhappy miserable dog. After a couple more months, we surrendered him to the Humane Society.
I'm glad you have a fenced in yard. I hope things work out with you and Buddy. Please give some consideration to the idea that "back on the road" really means a fierce desire to do what young sexually mature dogs want to do.