synthetic oil filter

   / synthetic oil filter #1  

bunt

New member
Joined
Mar 30, 2008
Messages
24
Location
Sudbury Ontario Canada
Tractor
1700 Ford
changing over to synthetic oil in my atv and utv, yamaha's, one mechanic said just use same oil filter as before other said use synthetic oil filter for synthetic oil. is there a difference and does it matter
Bill
 
   / synthetic oil filter #2  
Just use a good high quality filter, not a Fram or other junk filter, and you'll be fine. With what you have, ATVs & UTV, I'd just use the factory filter.
 
   / synthetic oil filter #3  
They do make synthetic oil filters, and they say they are better, and if they filter out smaller particles, then they are better.

Oil Filters
 
   / synthetic oil filter #4  
Amsoil sells Donaldson and Wix filters to be used with their synthetic oils.
 
   / synthetic oil filter #5  
Amsoil sells Donaldson and Wix filters to be used with their synthetic oils.

I don't buy Amsoil anymore, they just got too expensive for me, but Wix, Baldwin and Donaldson are the only oil and air filters I use.
 
   / synthetic oil filter #6  
Use of synthetic base stock lubricants is not necessarily improved by the use of synthetic media filters. Standard cellulose (paper) media filters will do as good a job for what any full flow filter can be expected to do. Synthetic media filters can be made from 'microglass', microfine glass fibers held together by bonding resins or from melt blown plastics. An example of melt blown media is Fleetguard's Stratapore. A common misconception that is pushed by sales and marketing for filter companies and some engine manufacturers is that you need filter media to remove the dust and wear metals in engine oil in order to protect the engine best. Nice idea but completely without merit. As a field service engineer for a filter company (part of Cummins, Inc.), you get the best filtration of engine lube oil if you use some form of bypass oil filter. What is a bypass oil filter? It is a filter that bypasses the normal oil filter routing (Full Flow) and takes a small volume of the lubricant and filters it then returns that oil to the sump without going through the engine to lubricate it. A true bypass filter uses a small portion of the oil flow from the engine's oil pump. It is not the main oil flow used for lubrication. That small flow, usually about 2 - 3 gallons per minute is slow enough that the filter can perform the sludge removal more efficiently. Bypass oil filters like the old Luberfiner external housing are very capable of reducing the level of organic sludge compounds that are the by-products of combustion (some of the stuff that makes oil turn black). There are a number of filter products by several manufacturers that provide a remote mount filter head to which you can attach a bypass filter. For example, the old Luberfiner housing with the large cartridge element not only was very good at removal of sludge compounds but added a few gallons of oil capacity to the engine. More oil equates to lower 'load factor' on the oil meaning longer oil change life and cleaner oil. But those filter systems are a pain to service. There are bypass filters that use a stacked disk element within a spin on filter can. They provide the same or better filtration of the sludges by absorbing them than did the older technology.

The long term wear-causing aspect of lubricant is the combustion byproducts, not dust or wear metals. Let's take the dust holding capacity and efficiency rating of a filter. It may be classified as being 98.7% efficient at removing 10 micron particles. Your first thought might be that is what I need. Removing those dust particles and wear metal particles will prolong my engine's life. Capacity and efficiency testing is done by all filter manufacturers. The bad news is that those tests are meaningless regarding a filter's real ability to protect an engine from the wear-causing sludge components of combustion blow by gases. So, forget the synthetic media full flow oil filters, a very over sold technology that has little benefit to engine lube oil. They are great for transmissions and hydraulic systems where those dust particles and wear metals do have a much greater effect because there is so much more of those contaminants in those systems, but not engine oil. If your concern is to trap harmful dust from an engine lubricant....you need to find out if you have an air cleaner that is working. By the time the dust from an air cleaner is collected by the oil filter, it has already caused major damage to the piston rings and cylinder walls. A form of locking the barn door after the tractor is stolen. Let me tread on somebody's sacred cow....air filters that offer high air flow and you can clean them using special processes and oils to improve their efficiency. They are sold as aftermarket products to replace your standard air cleaner. How do they get long life? By allowing dust to pass through that would otherwise plug them and lead to very short life. In the case of those air cleaner types you could use filters that trap a lot of dust in the lube oil but same effect, engine is damaged even though the filters are removing more contaminants. I invite your response or send me email directly, see my profile.
 
   / synthetic oil filter #7  
changing over to synthetic oil in my atv and utv, yamaha's, one mechanic said just use same oil filter as before other said use synthetic oil filter for synthetic oil. is there a difference and does it matter
Bill


I have always used Amsoil 0w 40 in my ATV. I use Wix filters from auto parts
 
   / synthetic oil filter #8  
I bought a bunch of Mobil 1 oil filters (with synthetic media) for my wifes car and the tractor before the the recent price increase.. Once I run out of those I will be switching to Wix filters for both

Brian
 
   / synthetic oil filter #9  
fieldserviceengineer

You seem to know pretty much what you are talking about, but don't you think that a filter that will filter smaller particles of say 10 microns over the 25 micron filter would be a better option.

I also agree with you about a bypass filter. My Dixie Chopper with 25 HP Kohler engine came with a 1 micron bypass filter. Kind of expensive though. When they finally broke the engine down, they said it looked like a new engine on the inside, no sludge at all. I agree with the principle of bypass filtering , it is worth having. It also had a Donaldson turbo air filter.
 
   / synthetic oil filter #10  
in some thinks a Wix is as good as a Amsoil EaO someone is smoking $$%^..

There is a huge diff and a simple test is get a good baseline on (1) filter and then switch. Simple and no BS
 
   / synthetic oil filter #11  
in some thinks a Wix is as good as a Amsoil EaO someone is smoking $$%^..

There is a huge diff and a simple test is get a good baseline on (1) filter and then switch. Simple and no BS

Sorry, I didn't catch that.
Apparently I'm smoking $$%^..
 
   / synthetic oil filter #12  
Not only filtering but also having the correct pressure drop to open the bypass valve. This is a very critical and why I buy the filter made by the equipment manufacturer rather than after market attempts at one shoe fits many.

jmf
 
   / synthetic oil filter #13  
As usual well said Gary (fieldserviceengineer). I couldn't agree more on the over selling of some of the synthetic media filters on the market. Bypass filtration is far more effective in the overall life of a piece of equipment. I also agree that the "high flow" filters on the market do more damage than good. They may be fine if your using it in a race engine and need maximum air flow and plan on tearing your engine down after every couple of runs but in the real world they do nothing more than allow in more contamination. I can often tell if a customer is using a gauze type filter simply by looking at their UOA results. They alway's have a increase in silicon when compared to engines using standard filters.
 
   / synthetic oil filter #14  
I was switching everything to the same synthetic oil a couple years back, and when I asked the quad mechanic at the local dealer a couple questions. He said that it was a good idea but the quad uses engine oil to lube the tranny, and some oils are to slick. the slick oils don't allow some of the clutches to work right ( not enough friction?)

I always wonder if he was pulling my leg.
 
   / synthetic oil filter #15  
The slip in motorcycle/ATV clutches used to be true, sometime in the last century:rolleyes:

Not a problem nowadays in properly designed equipment, built since about the 80's.
 
   / synthetic oil filter #16  
That's why synthetic oils with highway additives/packages are not recommended for clutches.

jmf

I was switching everything to the same synthetic oil a couple years back, and when I asked the quad mechanic at the local dealer a couple questions. He said that it was a good idea but the quad uses engine oil to lube the tranny, and some oils are to slick. the slick oils don't allow some of the clutches to work right ( not enough friction?)

I always wonder if he was pulling my leg.
 
   / synthetic oil filter #17  
There are several synthetics labeled........ for use with wet clutches
 
   / synthetic oil filter #18  
There are several synthetics labeled........ for use with wet clutches

The one I like is 0-40w 4-Stroke by Amsoil. No highway additives.

jmf
 
   / synthetic oil filter
  • Thread Starter
#19  
Thank's for all the information, I already use omni air filters in the Rhino and Kodiak and I do know about the additives that harm clutches. What it looks like is Wix filters and probably will change oil and filter again after 20 hrs the first time, then back to old scheduel of at the end of hunting season, November 11
Bill
 
   / synthetic oil filter #20  
fieldserviceengineer

You seem to know pretty much what you are talking about, but don't you think that a filter that will filter smaller particles of say 10 microns over the 25 micron filter would be a better option.

I also agree with you about a bypass filter. My Dixie Chopper with 25 HP Kohler engine came with a 1 micron bypass filter. Kind of expensive though. When they finally broke the engine down, they said it looked like a new engine on the inside, no sludge at all. I agree with the principle of bypass filtering , it is worth having. It also had a Donaldson turbo air filter.
No, actually, I do not see any advantage in engine lube filters that can filter smaller particles. If you have a working air cleaner system, there are no smaller particles to remove. Air cleaner elements have a pore size distribution ranging from 1 micron to an upper range of 15 micron. Engine lube filters made of cellulose generally range in pore size of 40 - 60 micron. Particles of that size circulating in your lube oil have no effect on engine rotating and sliding components. To have a number of particles that size to cause issues means there is no air cleaner working in the system. The result of that will be high cylinder and ring wear. Why would it matter to remove those generated wear particles when the damage has been done. Fix the air cleaner. Don't get a more efficient lube filter. The company I work for has microglass lube filters. They are an added cost with no benefit. Either stay with cellulose or go to filters that combine a full flow with a bypass. The only advantage a synthetic full flow filter has is that it allows higher filtered oil flow during cold startup. Cold can mean oil that is at 100F even. Otherwise, the bypass valve in the engine lube filter circuit opens to provide an alternate flow path for lube flow because the cool oil viscosity is too high to have sufficient flow and resulting oil pressure. Other than that, synthetic full flow media filters are a waste as you pay a lot more and get not much in return.
 

Marketplace Items

500 BBL FRAC TANK (A58214)
500 BBL FRAC TANK...
Honda EM3800SX Portable Gasoline Generator (A59228)
Honda EM3800SX...
Takeuchi TL150 Compact Track Loader Skid Steer (A59228)
Takeuchi TL150...
2006 Acura RL Sedan (A59231)
2006 Acura RL...
2020 DRAGON ESP 150BBL ALUMINUM (A58214)
2020 DRAGON ESP...
2017 Wacker Neuson LTV6 Towable Light Tower (A56857)
2017 Wacker Neuson...
 
Top