TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD

Status
Not open for further replies.
   / TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD #1  

cullison

New member
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
2
(I also posted this in NH Buying/Pricing)

Question for all you guys who have bought TC48's (or 55's for that matter):

Am I going to be happy with 2WD or should I invest the extra cash for a 4WD?

Here's the deal: I just bought a house with 3 acres which is all grass and could be mowed with a lawn&garden tractor, albeit slowly. But the house has a concrete driveway that's about 200 feet long and a large concrete pad in front of the garage and the barn. And we often get a lot of snow here in northern Ohio. So I want some HP and size to push a blade around.

I can buy an '05 TC48DA 2WD with R1 tires for $13,600, which includes an $800 discount for paying cash that NH is offering ONLY on the 2WD TD48.

The dealer says I'll probably be happy with the 2WD so long as I don't put a loader on it. He'd prefer I'd buy a 4WD just to be safe and more flexible, and is offering to sell me the 4WD option at his cost (I think he said $3,500, but I didn't actually have him price it out).

What do you guys who have these tractors think of 2WD vs. 4WD?

If I go with the 4WD I lose the $800 cash discount and he may not be able to discount quite as aggressively because it's a much more popular tractor. The 2WD model is at another dealer who wants to give it up badly.

Right now I have a package deal for a 2WD TC48DA with R1 tires, a Land Pride FDR16 72" rear discharge mower and a Land Pride RB15 84" rear blade for $16,920.32 out the door. I'm happy with the price--especially when I was looking at used 30 HP Kubotas with only a mower for $12-13K. And my wife says buy it if you want it, which is always a good thing.

But she told me to make sure it was what I wanted because if in 6 months or a year I'm whining that I should have bought 4WD it's tough luck because I'm not trading up.

So help me out here guys. If I have no plans to buy a loader in the foreseeable future, will I be happy and will I get goood performance from a 2WD instead of a 4WD?
 
   / TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD #2  
<font color="blue"> And my wife says buy it if you want it, which is always a good thing.
</font>

I got the same speech, only in reference to HP. So I got what I wanted.

I think for mowing only you would proably be fine with two wheel drive but I can assure your tasks will grow with a tractor sittin' in the shop. /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif I think you'll be dollars ahead going for 4WD. Even pushing snow (which I'm not familiar with) might be better with the extra traction.
 
   / TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD #3  
Just out of curiosity, why do you want a 48 HP tractor for 3 acres? Is maneuverability around your house going to be any concern?

I've got a 27 HP tractor...which is probably overkill for my three acres (with a 150' drive and parking pad)...and I maintain a few more acres for a neighbor.

That said, for your circumstances (noncommercial, nonagricultural), considering the weight and power of the tractor, 2WD will do you quite well. Even a FEL on a two wheel drive TC48 will most likely be sufficient for a residential user. And, the price you quoted for the 2WD unit, mower and rear blade sounds really good.

Just seems like that's a large machine to cut grass with...
 
   / TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD #4  
Michael,
That is a really big tractor for 3 acres. Given its size you will find that you won't be able to get it into a lot of places and that when mowing you will have to a lot of backing up. It will also be hard on the lawn because it will compact the soil. I would suggest that you look a tractor in the 20-30 hp range, unless you plan in the near future to purchase a lot more land. As far as 2 or 4 wheel drive, compact tractors are far to light to be of much heavy use with out 4 wheel drive. I personally wouldn't even consider a two wheel drive model.
 
   / TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD #5  
1. Welcome to TBN!. /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif
2. I agree with JerryG. 48 hp is way too big for 3 acres

<font color="blue"> (I also posted this in NH Buying/Pricing) </font>
Forum Rule 2 Do not cross-post your message to multiple forums.

Since your question deals with Buying, this thread is closed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2006 CIMC SZJ9341TJZ03 20FT CHASSIS TRAILER (A52141)
2006 CIMC...
20305 (A51694)
20305 (A51694)
Ford Pickup NR (A50323)
Ford Pickup NR...
2019 Energreen EVO 40 Robotic Tracked Flail Mower (A52748)
2019 Energreen EVO...
23169 (A50324)
23169 (A50324)
John Deere 348 Square Baler (NICE) (A50774)
John Deere 348...
 
Top