TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD

Status
Not open for further replies.
   / TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD #1  

cullison

New member
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
2
(I also posted this in NH Buying/Pricing)

Question for all you guys who have bought TC48's (or 55's for that matter):

Am I going to be happy with 2WD or should I invest the extra cash for a 4WD?

Here's the deal: I just bought a house with 3 acres which is all grass and could be mowed with a lawn&garden tractor, albeit slowly. But the house has a concrete driveway that's about 200 feet long and a large concrete pad in front of the garage and the barn. And we often get a lot of snow here in northern Ohio. So I want some HP and size to push a blade around.

I can buy an '05 TC48DA 2WD with R1 tires for $13,600, which includes an $800 discount for paying cash that NH is offering ONLY on the 2WD TD48.

The dealer says I'll probably be happy with the 2WD so long as I don't put a loader on it. He'd prefer I'd buy a 4WD just to be safe and more flexible, and is offering to sell me the 4WD option at his cost (I think he said $3,500, but I didn't actually have him price it out).

What do you guys who have these tractors think of 2WD vs. 4WD?

If I go with the 4WD I lose the $800 cash discount and he may not be able to discount quite as aggressively because it's a much more popular tractor. The 2WD model is at another dealer who wants to give it up badly.

Right now I have a package deal for a 2WD TC48DA with R1 tires, a Land Pride FDR16 72" rear discharge mower and a Land Pride RB15 84" rear blade for $16,920.32 out the door. I'm happy with the price--especially when I was looking at used 30 HP Kubotas with only a mower for $12-13K. And my wife says buy it if you want it, which is always a good thing.

But she told me to make sure it was what I wanted because if in 6 months or a year I'm whining that I should have bought 4WD it's tough luck because I'm not trading up.

So help me out here guys. If I have no plans to buy a loader in the foreseeable future, will I be happy and will I get goood performance from a 2WD instead of a 4WD?
 
   / TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD #2  
<font color="blue"> And my wife says buy it if you want it, which is always a good thing.
</font>

I got the same speech, only in reference to HP. So I got what I wanted.

I think for mowing only you would proably be fine with two wheel drive but I can assure your tasks will grow with a tractor sittin' in the shop. /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif I think you'll be dollars ahead going for 4WD. Even pushing snow (which I'm not familiar with) might be better with the extra traction.
 
   / TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD #3  
Just out of curiosity, why do you want a 48 HP tractor for 3 acres? Is maneuverability around your house going to be any concern?

I've got a 27 HP tractor...which is probably overkill for my three acres (with a 150' drive and parking pad)...and I maintain a few more acres for a neighbor.

That said, for your circumstances (noncommercial, nonagricultural), considering the weight and power of the tractor, 2WD will do you quite well. Even a FEL on a two wheel drive TC48 will most likely be sufficient for a residential user. And, the price you quoted for the 2WD unit, mower and rear blade sounds really good.

Just seems like that's a large machine to cut grass with...
 
   / TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD #4  
Michael,
That is a really big tractor for 3 acres. Given its size you will find that you won't be able to get it into a lot of places and that when mowing you will have to a lot of backing up. It will also be hard on the lawn because it will compact the soil. I would suggest that you look a tractor in the 20-30 hp range, unless you plan in the near future to purchase a lot more land. As far as 2 or 4 wheel drive, compact tractors are far to light to be of much heavy use with out 4 wheel drive. I personally wouldn't even consider a two wheel drive model.
 
   / TC48DA: 2WD vs. 4WD #5  
1. Welcome to TBN!. /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif
2. I agree with JerryG. 48 hp is way too big for 3 acres

<font color="blue"> (I also posted this in NH Buying/Pricing) </font>
Forum Rule 2 Do not cross-post your message to multiple forums.

Since your question deals with Buying, this thread is closed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2004 Fleetwood Wilderness Travel Trailer (A50324)
2004 Fleetwood...
2018 Honda CR-V LX SUV (A50324)
2018 Honda CR-V LX...
attachment plate (A50322)
attachment plate...
1985 Eager Beaver 9D0W Tri-axle Flatbed Equipment Trailer (A50322)
1985 Eager Beaver...
2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
2017 Polaris 500 Ranger Diesel Utility Cart (A50322)
2017 Polaris 500...
 
Top