What is hunting and when did it become something to impress others or prove manliness? I've been on hunts on estates and fenced ranches and had a fantastic time. I've shot animals, and sometimes I didn't. I've hunted on massive ranches with deer everywhere that only had barbwire fences for cattle and found the animals to be everywhere and out in the open all day long. It was like deciding on what cow you wanted out of the herd. Simple and easy. I've been to Alaska and Canada where the caribou walked right past you and one time I was nervous one of them would step on me as they went past where I was laying.
I don't judge others and appreciate that they are out enjoying what they want to do. If it's legal, then that's all that matters. If a guy is a member of a hunting club and they release hogs onto the property, I'm not going to degrade whoever it was that shot the animal, same with pheasant hunts at clubs or fishing in a stocked pond. What I do and enjoy isn't about what others think of me or what is judged by others as "hunting" or being a man. I do it for fun and the total experience.
If you have never done a fully guided hunt at a fancy lodge, then all I can say is you are missing out on one of the best times of your life. The hunting may be great, or it might be terrible. I've had both, but I always enjoy the experience when it happens and look forward to the next time. Having the horses ready for you in the morning after enjoying a nice breakfast is nice. Having a guide who knows the mountains and where he's seen the animals over the years is nice. Having somebody with years of experience there to talk to about the animals and what they do, along with other hunters is also nice. It's a learning experience that can't be beat, but it's also a very fun way to enjoy a vacation.
I've also done the backpack thing into wilderness areas where nobody else goes. I once went six days without seeing another human. That was a bit strange, but also kind of fun. Got a nice 4x3 mule deer on that one. Two weeks in a canoe, ten days on a mountain soaking wet every day, and many weeks in national forest without ever seeing a buck or bull all over the western US.
Why do some hunters put down others who do something different they do it? Why do bow hunters say rifle hunters are not real hunters and that they don't have the skills they do? then open site, primitive hunters say the same thing about modern bow hunters? Muzzle loaders against rifle hunters? Guy who hunts his back 40 and shoots just for meat and has never killed a trophy class buck in his life put down a guy who travels across the country to hunt a 20,000 acre ranch with a staff and horses at a nice lodge in order to shoot something that he can put on a wall?
Hunting is what you make out of it. If you enjoy what you are doing, why put down others who are doing something they like?
Eddie