Could you draw a diagram of what you have. If I'm reading this right, it's not connected properly for the best results.
I'd have to wait for one of my kids to show before I could be able to post a drawing, best I can do is post a mental picture with a lot of ish, you might need good reception to understand it though but I'll try.
From the Channel Master Balun to the CM 7777 preamp about 6' of coax) Then from preamp to house behind TV, 75'-ish> into preamp power supply) Then about 12" into CM Amplifier ) Then 12"-ish into Signal Combiner<<<<This has another antenna plugged into that) THEN from that Signal Combiner>> 3'-ish into TV.
Not sure if you got that or not, I can just barely understand the hook-up myself and I'm looking right at it, that set up is from my garage and that signal has increased 4-6 digits. The other antenna on the Signal Combiner is from on my house, 50'-ish of coax.
One thing I did learn is that not all Baluns are created equal even though they say the same numbers, I tried several and this last one from Channel Master worked the best, it cost about $8. the other three was $4.ea