Venting the front axle on CUTs(with pics)

   / Venting the front axle on CUTs(with pics) #41  
Water above the axle won't do it. We went through that already.

Tell that to one of my previous trucks and see if it will believe you.:D
 
   / Venting the front axle on CUTs(with pics) #42  
If you drill through the dipstick won't your vent essentially be under the oil level and if the pressure gets great enough won't it push oil out? Especially if you were working on level ground and parked it, I think you would find a puddle when you come back to it from out of your vent. I have been bouncing this thought around myself but for the mean time I have been doing the same as some others just cracking the cap loose when I'm done for the day.
 
   / Venting the front axle on CUTs(with pics)
  • Thread Starter
#43  
Arrabil,
Are you sure you have it right? I pushed this thing up hills, down hills, across hills, MFWD on, MFWD off, you name it. Checked the oil before and after. Not a drop!

Rob
 
   / Venting the front axle on CUTs(with pics)
  • Thread Starter
#44  
Tell that to one of my previous trucks and see if it will believe you.:D

Great! Now you want me to talk to your truck. What happen to the physics of it and that you have to be 4.6 feet underwater to realize a force of 2 lbs!

So you're saying that your truck leaked through the vent? How do you know? How do you know it wasn't the seals that were bad or some other place?

Rob
 
   / Venting the front axle on CUTs(with pics)
  • Thread Starter
#45  
If you drill through the dipstick won't your vent essentially be under the oil level and if the pressure gets great enough won't it push oil out? Especially if you were working on level ground and parked it, I think you would find a puddle when you come back to it from out of your vent. I have been bouncing this thought around myself but for the mean time I have been doing the same as some others just cracking the cap loose when I'm done for the day.

Yes, I abandoned that and blocked the hole. I then drilled two small holes right at the end of the thread on the dipstick. I did a post on it right after the pics.

Rob
 
   / Venting the front axle on CUTs(with pics) #46  
I think there is a whole lot of something being made out of nothing regarding venting. Most full size tractors have a vented front axle and all it is, is a small fitting tapped into the dif case on the top. Does not stick up more than an inch. If you are running in water that reaches the top of the front axle you are going to have more problems than water in the front axle. Having pressure on the seals is not a good idea at anytime.
Because an engineer did not put one in the drawings does not mean it is not the best of ideas.
 
   / Venting the front axle on CUTs(with pics)
  • Thread Starter
#47  
I think there is a whole lot of something being made out of nothing regarding venting. Most full size tractors have a vented front axle and all it is, is a small fitting tapped into the dif case on the top. Does not stick up more than an inch. If you are running in water that reaches the top of the front axle you are going to have more problems than water in the front axle. Having pressure on the seals is not a good idea at anytime.
Because an engineer did not put one in the drawings does not mean it is not the best of ideas.

I agree but these tractors posed a special challenge. First, no one wants to drill a hole in the front axle, including me! So it has to be incorporated into the dipstick but we also want to be able to check the oil level. Not as easy as it may look at first sight.

Rob
 
   / Venting the front axle on CUTs(with pics) #48  
So you're saying that your truck leaked through the vent? How do you know? How do you know it wasn't the seals that were bad or some other place?

It was just Empirical Physics applied by an astute observer!:thumbsup:
The seals were still holding but the bearings were howling!:thumbsup:

When I was a kid every time I got my rubber boots on and went wading the darn water just seemed to flow into the top when the level reached the top! Heck, four foot was away taller than I was.:laughing:

The Kubota B7100 I had didn't have a vent on the front axle either. Service manager at the shop told me that was to keep positive pressure when working in the rice paddies.:thumbsup:
 
   / Venting the front axle on CUTs(with pics) #49  
Arrabil, Are you sure you have it right?
Did you look at the pictures in the thread I started? My axle had been vented since April and I go up and down my property at least once a week on it. Never had a problem. But when it was parked in 104 degree heat.... you can see the results for yourself. So what does that tell you? Cause I'm not entirely sure what it tells me. I'm all ears on suggestions cause I want this to work. :)

is a small fitting tapped into the dif case on the top
Yeah, which is exactly what we don't have here.

no one wants to drill a hole in the front axle
Oh that is precisely what I'm going to do if I ever have to drain it to replace any seals or bearings!
 
   / Venting the front axle on CUTs(with pics)
  • Thread Starter
#50  
It was just Empirical Physics applied by an astute observer!:thumbsup:

Oh, the same "empirical physics" that thought the world was flat!
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2008 John Deere 2305 Tractor (A50514)
2008 John Deere...
Case IH 7120 Combine (A50514)
Case IH 7120...
2009 Yamaha YDRE Electric Cart (A50324)
2009 Yamaha YDRE...
P.T 1000 Gallon Supply Tank (A50120)
P.T 1000 Gallon...
2014 Ford Fusion Sedan (A50324)
2014 Ford Fusion...
2021 Caterpillar 304E2 Mini Excavator (A50322)
2021 Caterpillar...
 
Top