Bernard, nice to have someone who has real technical experience in oil join the discussion. I fully agree with your statement you can't rely much on individual testimonies on oil quality. A couple questions though.
If you are successful at changing the oil once every 70K, does that really relate in terms of oil quality to someone who changes oil every 5K? Another question, how do you determine if an oil is "cheap"? Does price always equate to quality? If a "cheap" oil and "expensive" oil meet the same API specs, what further differentiates them?
I ask because I have always bought oil based on price, It has to meet the proper viscosity and API specs, and I change it at sometimes longer than recommended, but not unreasonable intervals. In my 60 years of running numerous internal combustion engines I have never had what I could see as an oil related failure. I see all these "what's the best oil" discussions and always just shake my head, thinking marketing people are having an effect on us that has more to do with hype than reality. Am I all wet?