What to look for when buying a used dozer?

   / What to look for when buying a used dozer? #11  
stumpfield said:
It's a $75k machine and I'm only selling it for $15k. What do you expect?) Is this just standard business practice to avoid liability thing? How can one tell the hours on the meter is real?

$15K sounds a bit low for a D31. A decent D21 usually goes for that around here.

There is no real way to tell if the hour meter is correct.

It really sounds like you need an experienced dozer person/mechanic to take a look at that machine. A good and complete undercarriage inspection and thorough test drive can usually give some indication of how much a dozer has been used. If you are uncomfortable doing this yourself, all signs here indicate that passing on this one would be a prudent decision.
 
   / What to look for when buying a used dozer? #12  
Hour meters lie.

As for the guy selling a 75k machine for 15k. I got 2 ideas.

He bought it cheap, and is selling it cheap.. and doesn't want to touch it and 'find' ny problems. it's running and he wants to sell it while it is still running. Lots of dealers take trade equipment like that. it comes in.. and they want it to go out without touching it.

Other idea is he knows it has a problem and is a schiester..

Soundguy
 
   / What to look for when buying a used dozer? #13  
I get a feeeeling that your second point is more accurate!

jb
 
   / What to look for when buying a used dozer? #14  
When you start messing with dozers it all costs big bucks , You're buying older kit with final drives , Transmissions and powershifts that make your little tractor look cheap to fix .
I bought my first dozer last winter a CAT D7e ( 1967 ) powershift and fortunateley she is a good one , I bought it with a cracked head and replaced it myself ( cheap dozer ).
Since march it's been clearing 80 acres of bush ( part time ) so far problem free .
Whatever dozer you buy you always you bought a bigger one ,
Don't get addicted and good luck.
 
   / What to look for when buying a used dozer? #15  
I have a little experience with dozers, but not very much info on what your looking at.

The new paint job sets of red flags. The only reason to do that is to hide something. Nobody is gonna think twice about buying a dozer with some scratches and wear on the paint.

He's not telling you anything about the machine. This is red flag number two. Playing stupid is just a way to cover his but. He knows what's wrong with it and can probably look at the machine from a hundred feet and know what it is. Why he's not telling you is a sign of what you can expect down the road when you figure out what the problem is.

Telling you what a machine cost brand new and that he's giving you a deal really sets of those red flags!!! He just sounds sleazy to me. But to be honest, that's not very uncommon with used equipment sales people. Just my opinion.

Before you even look at the machine, you need to know where you can buy parts for it. It will break down. How often and how expensive is the mystery.

If you want to own a dozer, you better have a good set of tools and be willing to bust your but doing your own repairs. Nobody wants to come out to help you. Your on your own!!!

My dozer weighs almost 40,000 pounds and has about 170 hp. It's a big machine and pretty much useless on stumps and large trees. I can get them out, but it's a major task that requires moving tons of dirt. The backhoe is allot better for this.

It's good for grading roads, cutting trails and moving dirt short distances. I moved hundreds and hundreds of yards of dirt today with mine. I did the same yesterday and will do the same tomorrow. I burn about 30 gallons of diesel a day and right now with a new engine, about a quart of oil every other day.

Threre's really four main parts to a dozer. Undercaraige, hydraulics, transmission and engine.

Not much to check on the engine. Look at the oil, the water and check for leaks. I looked at a Cat D7 that was priced right, but when I started it up, there was a steady stream of green water coming out of someplace. I didn't want to mess with it, so I passed on that one.

If the engine goes on you, what will you do?

The next one is the big money item. The transmission. Clutches or hydrostatic. Either one will be a pain to fix if it goes out. You will have to run it to get an idea if it's ok. Start the engine, warm it up, and open the throttle all the way. Always run a dozer in full throttle.

Drive forward and see how it tracks. Does it go straight forward? If it goes to one side or the other, this might be a simple adjustment, or a five thousand dollar repair that's just a few months away. Do the same in reverse. Turn it, spin it and run it through some manuvers. If you find it doesn't respond properly just once, you got issues!!!

Put the blade all the way down. It should lift the front of the dozer off the ground. Put it in forward and try to push it. Both tracks should spin evenly. If one is faster than the other, you got problems.

The big wear item is the undercaraige. If it's a solid machine, it could still have a worn bottom end. Do the tracks have a master link? Is the sprocket one piece, or five? If it's one piece, you have to take off the tracks to change the sprocket. One pice sprockets are a royal pain to replace but the five piece ones are super simple.

The next big item and the one you really need to check are the spindles on the tracks. This is what the sprocket grabs when driving. It's also what wears out the fastest and is very expesive to replace. They have to be pressed on and I've heard it can cost $5,000 to have them turned over.

Feel them by hand. Are they totaly round? I doubt it. Is one side round and the other flat? This is what mine are like. This means they have been turned. One side wore out and now I'm on the other side.

The hydraulics will leak after awhile. This is normal enough and the parts are usually around a hundred bucks, give or take, for a rebuild kit. I do my own, but the first one was a real learning experience. I've done about a dozen cylinders now and most have been pretty straight forward. Some are sealed together with loctite and you will need to torch them to melt the loctite to get them off. You will probably need a special spanner tool to get them apart as well.

Run the dozer, get it good and warm and look for leaks. Drive it forward a ways and then get off and look at the area between your tracks for leaks. When the engine is warm, and all the preasure is up on the hydraulics, you should be able to see if there's a leak or not.

Finally, compare prices. I like ebay just to get an idea of what they go for. www.equipmenttraderonline.com is a really good source for prices in your area. www.machinerytrader.com is gonna be very high on prices. If you spend the time to check out their links for dealers in your area, you might find what things are selling for, but never consider it as a good source for prices. I also like the local free classifieds. Here its called the American Classifieds. I check it every week for certain items. If you can find a machine that was used on a farm like what you want, you might get a good deal that way.

From what you've said and the sellers attitude, I'd probably walk away from this deal.

Good luck,
Eddie
 
   / What to look for when buying a used dozer? #16  
stumpfield said:
...It's a $75k machine and I'm only selling it for $15k. What do you expect?
I think that means you can expect to spend $60,000 to get it in like-new condition.

This guy owns a rental yard which means he has a full time staff mechanic, who probably is paid less than a real diesel mechanic. If it's not cost effective to have this mechanic prepare the unit for rental service, then I don't think it would be cost effective for you to pay for field repairs out where you are likely to break it, somewhere beyond the end of that awful access road.

Mariposa is all steep rocky canyons, isn't it? I would be worried about unreliable steering and brakes, operating where everything has a thousand-foot dropoff.

In my opinion you need a thorough checkout by the same mechanic who you will call out for field repairs sooner or later. Don't consider buying it if no one would ever come out for onsite repairs.

And when you find this mechanic he might tell you this unit could only be sold to a newbie, it's unsalable to an experienced owner.

Ok, that's the downside. I hope your mechanic tells you it checks out a lot better than this!
 
   / What to look for when buying a used dozer?
  • Thread Starter
#17  
California said:
I think that means you can expect to spend $60,000 to get it in like-new condition.

This guy owns a rental yard which means he has a full time staff mechanic, who probably is paid less than a real diesel mechanic. If it's not cost effective to have this mechanic prepare the unit for rental service, then I don't think it would be cost effective for you to pay for field repairs out where you are likely to break it, somewhere beyond the end of that awful access road.

Mariposa is all steep rocky canyons, isn't it? I would be worried about unreliable steering and brakes, operating where everything has a thousand-foot dropoff.

In my opinion you need a thorough checkout by the same mechanic who you will call out for field repairs sooner or later. Don't consider buying it if no one would ever come out for onsite repairs.

And when you find this mechanic he might tell you this unit could only be sold to a newbie, it's unsalable to an experienced owner.

Ok, that's the downside. I hope your mechanic tells you it checks out a lot better than this!

Thanks for all the great replies. I learned a lot and can certainly use all this knowledge in finding the next one.
California: Your post pretty much sums up. I'll pass on this one. The only thing that's good about this dozer is the new paint job. The seller is a pro and do this for a living. He buys from an auction, give it a paint job and try to sell it for a profit. So, there's no bargain here. He pretty much told me that I will get what I paid for. 1/5th the price of a good working dozer so I will get 1/5 of a good working dozer.
EddieWalker: Thank you very much for your excellent post.
 
   / What to look for when buying a used dozer? #18  
Dozers ARE money pits if you don't know their history. I recently rented a D6N XL and am thrilled and amazed at the amount of work that I got done in such a short amount of time. Maybe you should consider this and get all the big stuff done, then aquire something smaller and less pricey to keep it maintained. The dozer I rented left my place and is located in Mariposa right now outside of Coulterville awaiting the next call for a rental. Take a look at the website dozers4rent.com if you are curious, as well as see my project I completed posted there. Just my .02 cents!
 
   / What to look for when buying a used dozer? #19  
WOW this thread was sleeping for 2 years!!
 
   / What to look for when buying a used dozer? #20  
I read your post and I would caution buying a machine like this from someone who wants to sell it "as is." If you are serious about buying a dozer, I would highly recommend going to a reputable Cat or Deere dealer and checking w/ them. They always have used machines for sale, which go through an entire check and repairs (if needed) by thier mechanics and usually always guarentee any work performed. Also, if you end up needing service, the dealer would have no problem working on the machine.

If you purchase this dozer and you end up having any mechanical problems, it could cost you A LOT of $$$ to repair. You may also experience difficulty finding someone to work on it, and if you do, they will charge you a significant amount of $$ to perform the work.

Again, I would be careful and stick to a good certifed dealer that will back their work and be there for you (you can't go wrong w/ Cat or Deere).
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2014 Peterbilt 384 T/A Wet Kit Day Cab Truck Tractor (A51692)
2014 Peterbilt 384...
2022 JCB 3TS-8T Teleskid Loader with Telescopic Boom, DB84 Dirt Bucket and FAE Forestry Mulcher (A53473)
2022 JCB 3TS-8T...
2009 DRAGON PRODUCTS 130BBL VACUUM TRAILER (A53843)
2009 DRAGON...
2016 FORD F250 XL SUPER DUTY TRUCK (A51406)
2016 FORD F250 XL...
JOHN DEERE 7300 LOT NUMBER 18 (A53084)
JOHN DEERE 7300...
2017 Nissan Frontier Ext. Cab Pickup Truck (A54814)
2017 Nissan...
 
Top