Do you have the bolt that broke? I'd check the diameter too. My bush hog owners manual called for the same size as yours, 1/2" x 3", grade 2. When I broke a shear bolt I discovered what was installed (when I bought it) was actually only 3/8" diameter so there was some excess play in the hole. I don't know if that had anything to do with break but I don't think it is an ideal situation. Then I also discovered the hole will not accept a 1/2" daimeter bolt so the manual is wrong. I ended up using 7/16 diameter which fits in hole snugly without escess play and have not had one break since. The dealer I bought the Bush Hog from was kinda clueless about this. I found a local hardware store guy that to purchase from.