Who Makes a Good Portable Compressor

   / Who Makes a Good Portable Compressor #51  
I just looked at a couple of mine today...

The newest is the little Senco... it is 1/2 hp and states 4.5 amps.

My old Emglows have compressors made in Italy... 20+ years and no issues yet.
 
Last edited:
   / Who Makes a Good Portable Compressor
  • Thread Starter
#52  
I took the plunge tonight and bought the Dewalt D55151. It was $218 w/ free shipping from Amazon.com. Should be here late next week. I'll let you know what I think after I use it.
 
   / Who Makes a Good Portable Compressor #53  
The Makita MAC700 Big Bore 2.0 HP Air Compressor got great reviews on Amazon.

I just purchased one, and it has worked well with limited use so far.

- Spindifferent

I bought this stuff as well

Amazon.com: Makita MAC700 Big Bore 2.0 HP Air Compressor: Home Improvement

J.gif
 
   / Who Makes a Good Portable Compressor #54  
What kind of compressor to get is a matter of what you need, and what you can afford. The best option is an all cast iron (not aluminum), oil lube compressor. For less money, you can get units up to about 2 true HP that run on 115 V (20 amp), and put out up to
6 cfm at 100-125 psi. For a little more, you can get a true 3 HP that runs on 230V, single phase, at 15 amps, that puts out 9-10 cfm at 125 psi. Non lube compressors are loud and don't last, but they are cheap. The question is, do you want a disposable unit, or one that will last for years.

Another Searz Veteran? I notice you use the term "true horsepower", so I thought I might enlighten some un-initiated folks here. In the "olden" days .. alot of searz/craftzmen stuff, would advertise electrical tools using locked rotor current to calculate horsepower .. including compressors. Sometimes .. using start current, which can easily be several multiples of running current. Amps times volts (watts) divided by 746.

James Watt invented "horsepower" to market his steam engines to replace mules and horses in mining operations. One horsepower, can lift 550 pounds one foot in one second. Wth the advent of electricity .. someone figured that to be 746 watts. Anyway .. using locked or startup motor current was a marketing ploy .. haven't had a searz catalog in mabe 25 years .. hope they have cleaned up their act :)

I have here, an old craftzman twin cylinder new in '76 as I recall .. cast iron .. 20 gallon tank .. came with 2hp .. put a twin capacitor 3hp on it mabe 20 years ago. It works .. never re-built .. gotta small leak .. but hardly ever use it anymore .. takes 220 ... solar off-grid here now. It was made by Campbell Hausfield. Certainly ... cast iron is the way to go for the bigger units.

A few years ago .. bought a Ridgid "portable" twin tank .. basically for nail guns .. very similar to the one offered at HD as a reconn Campbell Housfield .. which is oiless. It has become noticeable noisier over the last six years .. but mostly used for occassional tire inflation these days .. 3/4" impact wrench needs the big guy, and the 18v dewalt 1/2" impact has far exceeded my expectations and is truly "portable".

Cast Iron .. for the big guys .. Oil-less works fine, but as noted in this thread, tends to get noisier with time and use. To this day ... I Always consider advertised horsepower ratings to be suspect ... compressors ... bench planers .. you name it. Caveate Emptor as they say. A $20 Kilawatt from NewEgg or where-ever, can be most enlighting :)
 
   / Who Makes a Good Portable Compressor #55  
Another Searz Veteran? I notice you use the term "true horsepower", so I thought I might enlighten some un-initiated folks here. In the "olden" days .. alot of searz/craftzmen stuff, would advertise electrical tools using locked rotor current to calculate horsepower .. including compressors.

Yep, they are still playing those games. The most you can hope to get out of a 15A 120V RMS outlet is right around 1.5HP. I recently saw something that advertised it was 120V 6HP! Talk about going nuts on the specs and blatant outright false advertising.

I'm thinking that spec was probably on a shop vac, and probably a cr@psman one at that.
 
   / Who Makes a Good Portable Compressor #56  
Another Searz Veteran? I notice you use the term "true horsepower", so I thought I might enlighten some un-initiated folks here. In the "olden" days .. alot of searz/craftzmen stuff, would advertise electrical tools using locked rotor current to calculate horsepower .. including compressors. Sometimes .. using start current, which can easily be several multiples of running current. Amps times volts (watts) divided by 746.

James Watt invented "horsepower" to market his steam engines to replace mules and horses in mining operations. One horsepower, can lift 550 pounds one foot in one second. Wth the advent of electricity .. someone figured that to be 746 watts. Anyway .. using locked or startup motor current was a marketing ploy .. haven't had a searz catalog in mabe 25 years .. hope they have cleaned up their act :)

I have here, an old craftzman twin cylinder new in '76 as I recall .. cast iron .. 20 gallon tank .. came with 2hp .. put a twin capacitor 3hp on it mabe 20 years ago. It works .. never re-built .. gotta small leak .. but hardly ever use it anymore .. takes 220 ... solar off-grid here now. It was made by Campbell Hausfield. Certainly ... cast iron is the way to go for the bigger units.

A few years ago .. bought a Ridgid "portable" twin tank .. basically for nail guns .. very similar to the one offered at HD as a reconn Campbell Housfield .. which is oiless. It has become noticeable noisier over the last six years .. but mostly used for occassional tire inflation these days .. 3/4" impact wrench needs the big guy, and the 18v dewalt 1/2" impact has far exceeded my expectations and is truly "portable".

Cast Iron .. for the big guys .. Oil-less works fine, but as noted in this thread, tends to get noisier with time and use. To this day ... I Always consider advertised horsepower ratings to be suspect ... compressors ... bench planers .. you name it. Caveate Emptor as they say. A $20 Kilawatt from NewEgg or where-ever, can be most enlighting :)

I agree with the extreme over rating. I have an electric motor from the 1930s-1940s. My grandfather pulled it out of a building his company was working on. That thing is about 2x as big as a modern 3 hp motor, and even the shell of it is cast iron, weighs about 60#. Anyways that thing is rated at 1/2 hp, and my brand new general dust collector draws the exact same amperage, but is rated at 1hp. Now I know effiecency has improved, but I cant see it really making 2x the hp for the same amperage. Also, when wired for 220v, I am sure that old motor produces more useable power then that new 1 hp...
 
   / Who Makes a Good Portable Compressor #57  
Being a roofer, I have had quite a few air compressors over the years. First one was a green campell husfeld from1972 That one lasted until 95

Bought an oiless black Coleman hotdog 4.5 gal that lasted until 2003

bought an emglo oil lube dewalt, and used it until 08 when the motor came loose, and needed one the same day, so bought a Ridgid pos-blows breakers even 20A

Fixed the dewalt,and use it as my backup. works well.

Got sick of blowing breakers all the time, so in September, I bought a Rol-Air gas wheelbarrow. Made about 70 miles from my house in WI. put an hour meter on the honda, I have just over 200 hours on it so far.

If you need bigger, I love my Ingersoll Rand 185 with a 3cyl Deere Diesel.
 
   / Who Makes a Good Portable Compressor #58  
Has anyone ever used a large rotary compressor? One time at the flea market a couple of lowlife types were trying to sell the biggest 'portable' compressor I've ever seen. I think everyone who went by assumed these characters had just stolen it from the railroad or something.

This compressor looked like a rotary aircraft engine and sat on legs with the cylinders horizontal. (if it were a rotary airplane engine then the propeller would be on top.) Diameter was about 6?? ft and I think half the cylinders were gasoline engine cylinders, alternating with compressor cylinders. It started with a rope pull then spewed oil as it ran. I think it weighed around 250 lbs.

Anybody ever seen one of these? I can't find a photo online, but would love to see one.
 
   / Who Makes a Good Portable Compressor #59  
Has anyone ever used a large rotary compressor? One time at the flea market a couple of lowlife types were trying to sell the biggest 'portable' compressor I've ever seen. I think everyone who went by assumed these characters had just stolen it from the railroad or something.

This compressor looked like a rotary aircraft engine and sat on legs with the cylinders horizontal. (if it were a rotary airplane engine then the propeller would be on top.) Diameter was about 6?? ft and I think half the cylinders were gasoline engine cylinders, alternating with compressor cylinders. It started with a rope pull then spewed oil as it ran. I think it weighed around 250 lbs.

Anybody ever seen one of these? I can't find a photo online, but would love to see one.

Sounds like the engine off a Douglas DC-3.......
 
   / Who Makes a Good Portable Compressor #60  
I can't afford to buy anything at Graingers.

Thinking of picking up a rolair compressor with wheels and it has to by relatively quiet.

I have a Senco 1010 that I love... so quiet but only good for a brad nailer... contacted Senco for sound ratings and have not received a reply.

My old Emglo has been bullet proof... it is a little heavy to lug around and loud.

Thinking about one of these with wheels...

https://www.rolair.com/products/air-compressors/hand-carry/vt25big

or this one that is a 1/3 lighter

https://www.rolair.com/products/air-compressors/hand-carry/vt20tb

Both say optimized for generator use in that low voltage down to 90 isn't a problem to start.

Also 5000 to 6000 rated life compared to some with 500 hour life or even one at 150 hours
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

JOHN DEERE 85G EXCAVATOR (A51242)
JOHN DEERE 85G...
SpotWeld RockerRite 480V Arm Type Spot Welder (A50322)
SpotWeld...
Ford F-450 Utility Truck (A52128)
Ford F-450 Utility...
UNUSED CFG Industrial XZ20R Mini Excavator (A47384)
UNUSED CFG...
2018 CATERPILLAR D6T LGP CRAWLER DOZER (A51242)
2018 CATERPILLAR...
PORTER CABLE 150 PSI AIR COMPRESSOR (A50854)
PORTER CABLE 150...
 
Top