RonMar said:
Mossroad
A manual transfer switch placed between meter and panel is probably the most expensive option of any discussed here... To install it, you have to have the meter pulled to access and replace the conduit and wiring between meter and main panel and locate the switch in a reachable location. A liscensed electrician will most likley have to do the final wiring, or at the very least you will be paying for him to come and sign off on it, so it can pass an inspection before the local utility will re-install the meter. This is the same as if you had a new main panel installed. The prices of a 2 pole switch capable of switching several hundred amps current capacity(has to handle your normal commercial capacity, so 200+ amps)are also WAY up there. If I was going to do a whole house backup generator, then sure why not. But that is a huge investment for a 5KW emergency generator.
In all of my research(over the past several years), the main panel interlock kits, at around $150, are the least expensive UL approved method of adding hard wired manual control backup power that I have come across. The backup-ready main panels with the interlock plate already installed are starting to be quite common on the shelf in the bigbox and electrical supply stores. The kits are also no more difficult to install than installing a new circuit breaker into the panel. You shutoff the main, remove the cover plate and remove the top right 240 breaker. You relocate it and it's wireing to an open slot down lower in the panel. You install a new 240 breaker sized for your generators capability into that top right slot and wire the generator hots to that. the generator neutral and ground go to the main panel busses just like the commercial powerlines do. You then drill the panel cover plate with a template and rivet the interlock plate in place. Once the panel coverplate is re-installed, the main breaker and top right generator breaker can't physically be on at the same time...
Yes, I have seen those interlocks just recently and had forgotten about them. They look like a very cost effective solution, but will not work if you have two boxes wired to a common meter and want to run some circuits from each box. It would work very well if the second panel was wired off the first panel. Definately something to look at to see if it can work because the intelock method is so inexpensive.
Our electric service comes out of the meter, into the main disconnect box, then through the exterior wall and into the house and the main sub-panel. There is no conduit. All that is required is to pull the main disconnect, pull the feed out of the main sub-panel, slip it into the on-off-on switch and run a short new wire from the switch to the main sub-panel. No electrician required. Although, around here, you probably have to get a permit to do it because you are changing things, not replacing existing, and you will definately have to have it inspected by the county guy/gal. I also only have 100 amp service. The cost difference between a 100 amp switch and a 200 amp switch is crazy, that's why I put in the disclaimer in my previous post.
I wonder what the total cost difference is between installing one switch like I suggested VS installing an interlock in one of the panels and rewiring all the circuits to one of Rob's two panels would be VS installing a transfer switch with dedicated circuits to the genny, etc... ?
Rob,
You need to do a cost analysis of the several choices you have. Get out that pencil.
Just curious though.... you mentioned that you have two 200 amp panels. What is your amp service rated at at your house?
How does the power come into your house?
Meter, disconnect, branches to the two sub-panels
or
Meter, disconnect, first sub-panel, second sub-panel fed from the first sub-panel?
Where are the panels located?
Pretty nosey, aren't I?
