Redwings are good but so are a bunch of others. Redwing is just better known. Carolina,Doc Martin,Georgia,Thorogood,Chippewa and Danner are just as good as long as you don't cheap out. Merrill and Keene are comfortable but are a little less substantial. I think Timberland Pro(I think the regular Timberland line pulls it down),Wolverine,Rocky,and Cat are a step below but not bad. If you want to go first class, move up to Wesco,Whites,of Nicks. They cost a small fortune but people have worn the same pair for 20+ years. Whatever you get look at how it is made. Better stuff makes better boot. Vibram soles,quality brass or stainless hardware, thick leather and stitched on welt will be used on the better stuff. A decent pair of boots will cost at the very least $125, probably $200+.