patrick_g
Elite Member
Renze said:Patrick, The eaten brass propellers tale must be an urban legend.. Electrolysis only works with DC, because the material is drawn with the current, from the positive to the negative pole.... with alternating current, there is no noticeable movement of material from one pole to the other...![]()
![]()
Renze, I guess we will just have to agree to disagree on this one. The electrolytic action is not a reversible process. Think of the electrochemistry involved and how the electrodes involved act as a diode with resulting rectification (meeting your stated DC current requirement.) A mechanical analog would be a ratchet. You can wiggle the wrench in alternating directions but the net result is unidirectional (even though there is some "waste motion."
There are active systems for electrolytic protection with sense/reference electrodes in contact with the water. These systems impress the required balancing current to protect submerged metal. These typically cannot produce enough protection current to offset leakage current in the water due to reversed polarity of the AC power.
There can be other effects as well: I was literally hosing out the interior of my sailboat and decided to move a hotplate away from the top of the gimbaled alcohol range to clean the stove top and about a microsecond later was on the other side of the cabin tingling all over. My brief electrocution was some amazing to me as I had previously opened the main AC breaker and was some curious as to the source of the current that had repeated the famous "Galvanic" frog experiment on me.
Seems my boat was wired backwards! Neutral went to the main breaker and hot went to all outlets all the time. Opening the breaker stopped things from running by breaking the circuit but still there was 120 volts available with respect to "EARTH ground" or "OCEAN ground" as the case may be. I was standing in a mixture of fresh and sea water. Needless to say I stopped cleaning and started reversing two wires to correct the problem!!!
This was shortly after I got the boat and it had not previously had shore power connected for long so no particular damage. I later ended up living on that sailboat for 9 years and it is a good thing that I found the problem early on and corrected it. Not happy about the way I found it but happy THAT I found it.
It is BAD PRACTICE to use just any automotive type battery charger on a boat since some use autoformers to get the lower voltage and this does not give input to output isolation and promotes electrolysis problems by providing a current path from the AC input to the batteries which will have their negative posts connected the the bonding system connecting all wet metal on the boat.
If you are still not at all persuaded, not even a little bit, talk to an experienced marine electronics tech with good expressive abilities.
Pat