I would agree that Garlon 4 which is the same as Element 4 which is the chemical triclopyr butoxyethyl ester is outstanding. Use a surfactant with it and it far surpasses 2,4-d. Some states might require an applicators license so check on that.
Oofda! $100 per gallon!
Well, 2,4-D is good, but not that good. There are a lot of broadleaf plants it won't kill such as blackberry, clover and holly. Crossbow won't kill grass and is a good all around broadleaf killer.
Cord said:Oofda! $100 per gallon!
Do not know where you got your price from but that is not what I pay. Or even close but I buy in 2.5 gallon containers. I pay a little more than for crossbow but it works way better and is approved for forestry application which crossbow has limitations.
Crossbow will kill, or at least severly damage, cedars, which is a Bad Thing in some forestry applications. Garlon is the choice, or sometimes a mix of Garlon and 2,4-d.
There are several formulations of Garlon: [url]http://www.dowagro.com/PublishedLiterature/dh_0130/0901b80380130084.pdf?filepath=ivm/pdfs/noreg/010-50677.pdf&fromPage=GetDoc[/URL]. As I read their respective labels, Crossbow and Garlon 4 have the same version of triclopyr, although in different concentrations. Crossbow has a lower triclopyr concentration than Garlon 4 (16.5% versus 61.6%), but includes 2,4-d (34.4%) as an active ingredient.
Steve