CobyRupert,
Good one! Watch out or the fashion police will get ya!
I for one am not worried about cosmetics. My concern is accelerated damage to the driveway. With the cost of paving, you want to get as many years out of the blacktop as possible. A little scratching is no problem, but would gouges lead to ice-cracking and deterioration? Maybe those out there who have older driveways can tell us that they have been scratching the heck out of them for 15 years and they are fine, and if so, we could just put this to rest once and for all.
My drive is only a couple of years old, and on the steep sections, I had to do what I could to get up in the icy conditions. You can see some scratches and a little surface damage. However, I kept it to a minimum, as in avoiding useless spinning of the wheels, etc. I would like to hear the opinion of some who have older driveways if this is an issue or just a 'bogeyman'.
Frank