Mahindra: Nothing but problems

   / Mahindra: Nothing but problems #61  
Thank you ODT, If I were closer to Richmond, I would be happy to have someone reach out to take care of these problems. As I said in my #4 post, the local dealer and Mahindra have worked something out to take care of it and I'm happy to sing their praises once everything is working and stays working.

I'm happy to hear you have made arrangements to get the tractor fixed. Yes it should have been right to start with but things happen. It's how a company takes care if you when things happens that really matter. This is my first post in your thread and I realized you were mostly blowing off steam and feel the TBN crowd jumped on you unfairly. This isn't the first time I've seem some of the TBN crowd run off a new tractor owner just needing to blow off steam then ask for real suggestions and help by calling them a troll. The way some people react when you say something about their brand you would think you insulted their family. Any way good luck and I think once you get the new bugs worked out it will be a great tractor.
 
   / Mahindra: Nothing but problems #62  
Nope, no troll, no college kid, all problems legit. BTW, what college kid sits around and stirs the pot about a tractor?

So when I purchase something and it doesn't work it's my fault?
Rush would say that's classic liberalism... if something doesn't work to your favor, blame/attack the victim.

You can blame me for the tractor's shortcomings, but that doesn't change anything. You can also desparage my engineering, or that I didn't post all weekend, thank goodness I escaped this disaster. Like I wanted to post that or feel ripped off.

I was at road atlanta with my car this weekend. I built the engine, suspension, and touched every other part of the car. Engineers don't have technical ability huh? Want to talk valve train geometry about wipe pattern on the tip of the valves from the rocker arms, push rod length, and shimming the springs so they don't develop float? How about fly cutting the pistons for proper P to V clearance, milling the heads to get a better quench out of an ~11.5 to 1 compression ratio with a 12.8deg overlap cam to take advantage of a scavanging merge collector on the headers? I built my car, it runs when I turn the key, and it's a 17 yr old car that thraashes with $100k+ GT3's, Nissan GTR, and the list goes on... But I like to work on my car because it's a race car and that's what you do when you go 160 mph into a turn and need the brakes to work, you prep your own brakes like you pack your own parachute.

I don't expect to have to run around fixing a stock tractor. I spent 3 weeks calling and writing mahindra and the dealer. They did respond, but it took 3 weeks to get everyone on the same page and motivated to do something about it.

I'm a civil engineer though, Spent 13 years in heavy constrcution before returning for my license, so what would I know about big tractors and earth movers? I was working on hydraulics and pneumatics in highschool.

Response to the oil filter issue: the dealer said they never had anyone ask for one of those before... so no, the customer I passed on the way in didn't leave with the last one. lol, nice try though. I am a very down to earth person, what I don't appreciate is going to a dealer and them thinking I'm a stupid consumer. Further, I don't appreciate being bashed for expecting a $35k tractor to work. I didn't buy it to sort out manufacturer or dealer issues. and would have been very happy plowing snow rather than figuring out why it kept blowing fuses.

Electrically it's either the gauge cluster or the headlight switch, I guess. The tractor stopped blowing the starter circuit 40A fuse when I unplugged these two items. Draw your own conclusion

For thaose that asked (and thank you), the local dealer and mahindra have ironed something out to take care of the issues. I had to make sure that I wasn't getting into a situation where the tractor gets taken in and half the work is covered under warrenty and the other half costs me 3x what everything else should have. I asked a lot of questions before I agreed to let someone "fix" something. My biggest problem is that I expect something to be correct, perform as advertised, and not accepting shoddily performed work. This is why I do most everything myself, so I only have myself to blame and don't have to spend the time chasing someone down to do it correctly, the way it should have been done the first time.

Post #4! for those counting

I was reading along, catching up on posts since I hadn't looked at this thread for a couple days. The more posts I read the more I had decided to defend you. Then I got to this post. You certainly don't need me to defend you. Everything was very well stated.

On this website there are two phobias.

1. Safety. Do anything that someone might construe as unsafe and the Safety Police come out of the woodwork!!!! They'll do everything but call you a Baby Killer. I've lost track of the number of times I've been dog-piled by the Safety Police. And most times their solution to the situation is more unsafe than what I'm doing.....

2. Trolls. I pity the fool that only posts on this website 2 or 3 times with anything confrontational. Again, they will be dog-piled and they'll do everything but call you brand bias. I've also been called a Troll. Got yelled at and called names, particularly a Troll recently because I said something condescending about John Deere.

Wears me out.

Sorry you are having trouble with your tractor. Fortunately you aren't depending on it to work for you everyday to make a living. Wouldn't that suck!!!! This situation could have happened with any color tractor, including orange/green. Good luck with your solution. Hopefully you will give TBN another chance. There are great people on here. Unfortunately they are usually drowned out by the complainers. :)

Lastly, I'm not counting. ;)
 
   / Mahindra: Nothing but problems #63  
I was one of the people who jumped on him, althought I didn't (at least I do not remember) calling him a troll.

I still feel he treated Mahindra as unfairly as he feels he has been treated.

Blowing off steam is one thing, what he said was more than blowing off steam in my humble opinion

I am glad he is finding that the dealer and Mahindra wants to take care of him, and hope that they do!

In his response he could have at least stated he may have stepped over the line a BIT in his rant, but I don't see any of that all I see is he accepts none of the responsibility.
:irked:
 
   / Mahindra: Nothing but problems
  • Thread Starter
#64  
Plenty of blame to go around including me. It was unfortunate the tractor died completely, that really sent me over the line after all the other nagging issues had been festering. I was honest in posting Mahindra and the dealer are stepping up to take care of me. I did use TBN and other forums to help me track down similar problems withother models that helped me trouble shoot. I also read thousands of posts before making my decision on the purchase: I expected some issues, but this was too much.
 
   / Mahindra: Nothing but problems #65  
Author states what a badly engineered tractor it is, and that he is an engineer. Really speaks volumes as to why such a smart person would buy such a poorly engineered product.
This was my original post and I stand by it. I don't know if you still feel that it is poorly engineered but I do understand letting off steam. Good luck with your new tractor, I hope its everything you thought it would be when you bought it.
 
   / Mahindra: Nothing but problems #66  
Plenty of blame to go around including me. It was unfortunate the tractor died completely, that really sent me over the line. I was honest in posting Mahindra and the dealer are stepping up to take care of me and not leaving it open ended. I did use TBN and other forums to help me track down these common problems.

Well thank you for this post

Sometimes we all need to step back and look at things a little more calmly
 
   / Mahindra: Nothing but problems
  • Thread Starter
#67  
cartod: Thanks, I hope I can recapture the magic of the first 5 hours. Engineering and QC are inseperable, you need both to have a reliable well engineered product that works. Smart people make mistakes too (not to claim intelligence). I trusted something that had better specs than other comparable machines and the warranty to back it up.
 
Last edited:
   / Mahindra: Nothing but problems #68  
Dmize,
Now your stating you worked it out with the dealer and Mahindra. In your OP, you only stated that Mahindra acknowledged your emails. Nothing in your OP did you state you were communicating with your dealer. Which led us to believe you were not dealing with a dealer who didn't have what you were asking for. So like another poster stated..............you lite the fire.

Now, I am happy to hear you have got it all straight with Mahindra and your dealer. Hopefully, it will all end quickly and your happy with the result. Please let us know what they find is causing the short, as just unplugging a connector is not fixing the problem, just isolating the circuit the short is in.

Next time your dealer doesn't have what you need, ask them to overnight it to your place at their cost.
hugs, Brandi
 
   / Mahindra: Nothing but problems
  • Thread Starter
#69  
Thanks for your words Richard, I don't take it personally. The tractor is on it's way to be repaired and we are moving in the right direction.
 
   / Mahindra: Nothing but problems
  • Thread Starter
#70  
Dmize,
Now your stating you worked it out with the dealer and Mahindra. In your OP, you only stated that Mahindra acknowledged your emails. Nothing in your OP did you state you were communicating with your dealer. Which led us to believe you were not dealing with a dealer who didn't have what you were asking for. So like another poster stated..............you lite the fire.

Now, I am happy to hear you have got it all straight with Mahindra and your dealer. Hopefully, it will all end quickly and your happy with the result. Please let us know what they find is causing the short, as just unplugging a connector is not fixing the problem, just isolating the circuit the short is in.

Next time your dealer doesn't have what you need, ask them to overnight it to your place at their cost.
hugs, Brandi

Thanks, I'll try that line rather than to offer $100 to suppliment their fuse inventory. BTW, after a couple of days looking around, PEP boys had all the funny looking fuses I needed...
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

TRUCKING INFO (A50775)
TRUCKING INFO (A50775)
2019 Ford Explorer AWD SUV (A50324)
2019 Ford Explorer...
2018 Dodge Charger Sedan (A50324)
2018 Dodge Charger...
2019 POLARIS RANGER 4x4 UTV (A51222)
2019 POLARIS...
2005 Big Tex 10PI 16ft. T/A Pipe Top Utility Trailer (A49461)
2005 Big Tex 10PI...
2020 CASE CX37C EXCAVATOR (A51242)
2020 CASE CX37C...
 
Top