Tractor Sizing Need to Upgrade

   / Need to Upgrade #11  
+1 on all the advice above. '3 PT bale spear' means never having to say "why did I buy too big for just that one task". :D

I'd as soon buy 'used' with say 1000 hrs or less and skip warranty hassles if I though most things that'd break would have already by then.

Agree that Kioti, LS and Mahindra will give top value/performance per dollar but I've seen some good deals on low-hour machines. (a Winter thing)
Here's an example well under $25k: (see it while it lasts) TYM T503 Tractor w/ Loader- 4WD - Hodges Farm Equipment Note 2 scv (pairs) & QA FEL
For later viewing of this model: TractorData.com TYM T503 tractor information
TYM Reviews - TractorByNet.com

Yes, do keep the Yanmar, as a favor to yourself. :) :welcome:
 
   / Need to Upgrade
  • Thread Starter
#12  
I'd sell the Yanmar on my own. I don't think I'd have a hard time getting what I want for it with all the attachments I'd let go with it. I'll probably keep the blade since it was really a touch big for the yanmar anyways and then use the money from the yanmar to get a bigger rotary cutter, disk, etc.
 
   / Need to Upgrade
  • Thread Starter
#13  
No disrespect intended. I think you should continue to let your neighbor hay your ground. If he's doing it for only 1/3 you are getting a great deal. Secondly, if you intend to get cattle, how many and where are you going to run them?? You are either going to limit your existing hay ground for pasture or run a very small number of cattle. Either way you are limiting the heavy work load on the tractor. Can't see you needing anything bigger than 40-50hp. And I'm the guy that's always saying "buy big". :)

As for the Yanmar, why would you consider selling it?? You will "give" it away in a trade deal for a new tractor. Actually could probably save some money by leaving it home. And it will come in very handy for those small jobs like your blading picture.

Keep us posted on your decision. We love to watch people spend money. Pictures of course. :)

No disrespect taken and I appreciate the input. Don't really plan on having much cattle. Neighbor has 35 acres I could rent and continue to hay my place... idk. Nothing is set in stone other than I know I need a bigger tractor to manage my property and I'd like for that tractor to be able to move a round bale from where the hay guy leaves it into where I would keep half a dozen cow/calfs or so to feed them during winter.
 
   / Need to Upgrade #14  
I'd sell the Yanmar on my own. I don't think I'd have a hard time getting what I want for it with all the attachments I'd let go with it. I'll probably keep the blade since it was really a touch big for the yanmar anyways and then use the money from the yanmar to get a bigger rotary cutter, disk, etc.

I'd still suggest keeping the Yanmar for the little tasks. I have the size tractor you're talking about getting. It's great for most stuff. But, I'd still like something smaller available for little stuff... and you've already got the attachments sized for it.

To narrow down your decision, it might be important to talk about features and proper "sizing" of implements for the jobs you want done. I say that because you can easily spend under $30k to get a tractor that will move a round bale.

Features:
Transmission choice: Do you want Shuttle Shift, Hydrostatic, Power-Shuttle? This is worth mentioning because if you want HST, which is the best transmission choice for constant loader work, that will limit you to certain tractor categories. Shuttle will widen the range the most, and Power-Shuttle will be somewhere in-between Shuttle & HST.

Options & creature comforts: Do you want a tractor that comes with a quick-detach loader, extendable 3-pt lift arms, telescoping stabilizer arms, deluxe seating, tilt steering, standard remotes, etc? Don't laugh, but once you get used to some of these things, you'll wonder what you ever did without them. My first tractor did not have extendable lift arms, or telescoping stabilizer arms for the lift-arms... boy what a difference it makes! So much easier to hook up & adjust your implements.

Cab consideration: You can get into a 45-60 hp CAB tractor, with most of the above options, that will lift a round bale, for under $30k. I absolutely love having a cab. I think everyone that has a cab loves having a cab! Don't overlook this option because it really changes your comfort and experience if you're spending long hours on your tractor.

Capabilities - Implement sizing: There seems to be a general rule that you need 5-7 HP at the PTO, per foot of implement. So, if you want to run a 6 ft BrushHog, you should have around 30 PTO-HP. If you want to run a small round baler, I think you need around 35-45 PTO-HP.

If your bales weigh 1000-1500lbs, then pretty much any tractor in the large CUT (compact utility tractor) segment will lift them. For most companies, these start at 40hp & up. So, you don't necessarily have to get a tractor like the 5055e, as that is in the "utility" segment and is a larger machine.

Here are machines in the "CUT" range that would work.

Kioti DS4510HS (45 hp, power-shuttle, no cab option)
Kioti DK40,45,50 (40,45,50 hp Shuttle & HST - this model is now discontinued because it was replaced by...)
Kioti NX4510,50,55,6010 (HST or Shuttle)
LS R4047 (outgoing) or LS XR4046
TYM T503 (shuttle or HST)
Mahindra 5010 (actually the same as the TYM T503)
Mahindra 5035
Massey 1648,1652 (HST) 1655 (shuttle), 1660 (power-shuttle) - these models are now replaced by...
Massey 1749,1754,1758,1759.
JD 4320,4520,4720 - now replaced by the 4044,4055,4066.
Kubota MX4700,5100 - replaced by new models, can't remember the numering
Kubota Grand L - 4240,4740,5240,5740 - now replaced by
Kubota Grand L - 4760 & up.

There's more, but those come to mind.

Up from that is the Utility tractors, which will not have HST, but will come with Shuttle or PS. I really don't know the models in this class by heart - I know the ones from LS and that's about it LOL
LS U5020,U5030,XU5065
JD 5055E

Good luck!
 
   / Need to Upgrade #15  
You've had the Yanmar for years so you've got experience with tractors.
It doesn't read like you plan on using the next tractor for full time work, so you PROBABLY won't be running it even 500 hours a year.
If you buy a GOOD used 50 HP tractor (mechanically verified as sound) it should last for 4,000 hours and do everything you want even loading a big round bale on the FEL (my M4700 lifts a ton on the FEL), and will probably pull haying equipment.

I fully agree with keeping the Yanmar, it's handy having two tractors.

If you keep the Yanmar look at places like Barlow's, they list a couple of nice tractors well within your price range Like a MX5100HST, 2010, with 23.3 hours, an LA844 loader, and an A5392 (whatever that is) for $23,500.00.

/edit - and also consider most new tractors will be tier 4.
 
   / Need to Upgrade
  • Thread Starter
#16  
You fellas sure know how to make a guys head spin! Ha!

Ya I haven't decided on what tranny I want yet. I will definitely be doing some food plotting so I will be working some ground so I'm kinda scared to go the HST route. Kind of leaning towards the shuttle shift or power shuttle. Is there a big difference in terms of maintenance or wear and tear between the two?

I don't know if I would really need a quick detach loader. I can't think of many reasons why I would need to take it off.

Cab would be nice but I'd rather spend that money on attachments at this point. Gonna need a bigger rotary cutter. Want a disc, drill, 4 row planter, cultipacker, and on and on!

Definitely want adjustable 3pt arms.
 
   / Need to Upgrade #17  
You fellas sure know how to make a guys head spin! Ha!

Ya I haven't decided on what tranny I want yet. I will definitely be doing some food plotting so I will be working some ground so I'm kinda scared to go the HST route. Kind of leaning towards the shuttle shift or power shuttle. Is there a big difference in terms of maintenance or wear and tear between the two?

I don't know if I would really need a quick detach loader. I can't think of many reasons why I would need to take it off.

Cab would be nice but I'd rather spend that money on attachments at this point. Gonna need a bigger rotary cutter. Want a disc, drill, 4 row planter, cultipacker, and on and on!

Definitely want adjustable 3pt arms.

Yeah, for your described use, I would suggest against HST. Not because it wouldn't hold up, but because it sounds like you'll be doing much more "ground engaging" than precise work.

No difference in reliability really between any of the transmission choices.

Main reason to have a quick detach loader is comfort. If you're brush-hogging a lot of area, the ride will be much more comfortable with the loader removed. You will bounce much less. Main reasons to keep it on during mowing would be A, to keep the bucket close to the ground so that you can discover any large objects before you drive over them with the mower, & B, if you are in a wet or potentially muddy area and might need to dig yourself out.
 
   / Need to Upgrade #18  
Also don't get confused about quick loader and quick bucket detach. I have not had my loader off even though it is quick and easy. But my bucket comes off all the time, sometimes to improve the ride when mowing but mostly in switching between a grapple and the bucket. I now still think of how close a call it was that a Kubota salesman trying to keep the price down about $600 told me I probably would not need quick attach. I almost fell for it because I could not think at the time of a good reason to spend the $600 extra.

I still have nightmares over that one. Pallet forks are coming soon and perhaps a stump digger. But the grapple is a killer app as they say in geek land. That quick attach opens so many doors. Do not get a loader with out skidsteer quick attach system or you will regret it soon unless you absolutely know what you are going to be doing with the tractor. Yes there are those that don't need it. But with that land you describe and the amount of money you appear willing to invest, you are going to be launching into all sorts of things you have not even thought of just yet.
 
   / Need to Upgrade #19  
I had Yanmar 14 01D also was a great tractor I also found it too small so I traded up to a 17 02D with a Koyker 120 loader on the front. This was also a great tractor and almost perfect for my needs at the time. very strong loader and a nice size tractor. Came across a deal I couldn't pass up on a bobcat CT 225 with a loader "it is almost the same thing as a kioti CK 27". I kept the Yanmar For quite a while just because I couldn't bear to let it go but after months of never even starting it once I got the new tractor I sold it so someone else could enjoy it and have no regrets. My tractor is hydrostat and has a very big platform is the easiest tractor I've ever run it is a joy to use. I do food plots as well as gardening and have had absolutely no problems with ground engagement. The hydrostat makes mowing a breezeand my loader which has the Bob tech quick attach release bucket would handle a bale spear and left 1000 pounds no problem
 
   / Need to Upgrade #20  
image-287212080.jpg

Here is a picture of the 1702 next to the CT 225. The people that mentioned the cab are spot on. I had never used a cab beforeand did not realize how useful they can be. Not sure what climate you have but you can get cabs with heat and AC plus they offer bug protection. My property is a little smaller than yours so this tractor fits me perfect and would probably get you by if it's all your budget will allow. But for the size of acreage you're mentioning I think you're on the right track for the 45 to 55 hp range. But do yourself a favor get the factory cab with the heat and AC right off the bat.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

1994 Mack CH613 T/A Wet Kit Day Cab Truck Tractor (A49461)
1994 Mack CH613...
2025 78in Rock Bucket Skid Steer Attachment (A50322)
2025 78in Rock...
2013 INTERNATIONAL 4300 26 FT BOX TRUCK (A51222)
2013 INTERNATIONAL...
2012 Ford F-150 Crew Cab Pickup Truck (A49461)
2012 Ford F-150...
Hilti TE 2000-AVR Electric Jack Hammer (A49461)
Hilti TE 2000-AVR...
1272 (A50490)
1272 (A50490)
 
Top