I can never resist talking about sealers and gaskets. So anyone who finds that boring this is where to tune out. When I assemble without a gasket I get really picky about the RTV. I also like the Permatex Ultra Grey and use it a lot. I also like Permatex fuel resistant and hi heat silicon RTVs. Great value for the cost. For me, the trick to using them is to apply a thin layer to both sides and then not assemble until it is very tacky and nearly cured. You don't want to force strings of RTV out of the joint - especially not in a HST.
For the ultimate silicon goo, there is always Dow Corning 3145 Grey. It's an industrial product not often sold retail - but it is the "go-to" grey silicon for high$$ hi-tech and for aerospace applications. I get it from Pilot Gear Online.com....$33 for a 3 oz. tube and worth every penny. Handled carefully & resealed with care it will last five years or more. Very sticky, capable of high temp and pressure. it cures to a tacky surface quickly & then takes overnight for final strength. It is also non-toxic, and doesn't affect sensitive surfaces since it cures by a different catalytic process so that it doesn't outgas any acid fumes (that distinctive organic acid smell). 3145 has no odor and can be safely applied and shaped with a wet finger.
Great stuff, but crazy expensive.
Looking at the pumpshaft PDF you posted, that's just the kind of place I'd use 3145 if available, but I haven't had or seen any problems with Permatex Ultra Grey either. Very thin layer, though....and wait for tacky before assembly.
I'm currently doing a set of vintage Norton motorcycle engine/transmission cases that way.
rScotty