Smaller metal cutting bandsaw thoughts?

   / Smaller metal cutting bandsaw thoughts? #1  

tomplum

Elite Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2017
Messages
2,805
Location
PNW
Tractor
XJ2025H
It seems like a metal cutting bandsaw could be good thing in my future. My bigger projects tend to be working with 3-4" c channel, up to 1/2 thick flat bar, some tube. When I need a better cut, the dry cut chop saw is the go to, but it lacks precision and versatility on angle cuts plus the ability to do miters. Is a model that is rated for 5-6 inches even worth it for upping my game? I'm not running a metal fab shop but having the right tool for a project is always helpful.
 
   / Smaller metal cutting bandsaw thoughts? #2  
I have a Milwaukee Deep Cut Portable bandsaw mounted on a Swag table. Good for 5" deep cuts. I find it very useful.

Swag1.JPG

gg
 
   / Smaller metal cutting bandsaw thoughts? #3  
Bite the bullet and buy a 7x12 horizontal ,vertical band saw . Used $500 new $1000 . Make all the rest of your time in the shop a pleasure.:thumbsup::drink:
 
   / Smaller metal cutting bandsaw thoughts? #4  
It seems like a metal cutting bandsaw could be good thing in my future. My bigger projects tend to be working with 3-4" c channel, up to 1/2 thick flat bar, some tube. When I need a better cut, the dry cut chop saw is the go to, but it lacks precision and versatility on angle cuts plus the ability to do miters. Is a model that is rated for 5-6 inches even worth it for upping my game? I'm not running a metal fab shop but having the right tool for a project is always helpful.

There is always the 6 1/2" or 7 1/4" Diablo metal cutting circular saw blade. I find mine very handy and can make all kinds of angled cuts once the piece is clamped. Just cut 45* "ears" on a piece of 3" channel. Took about 5 seconds per cut.
 
   / Smaller metal cutting bandsaw thoughts? #5  
I do a lot of cuttings on old Craftsman Professional horizontal band saw..... Got it for $20 because idiot I got it from put blade on backwards and he said it did not cut...

Other option would be chop saw. I have a abrasive one, but If I had to do it again I would have gotten "cold cut" Bit at the time I didn't realize the pros and cons of cold cut vs abrasive and let price guide (mistake)...

Worked many hour with a Porter Cable "Porta Band" during my work career, but find in retirement and for property projects it would be nice to have, but I really fine my chop saw and horizontal band saw more useful, only wish for some operation the Craftsman would go vertical but that may be about 1% of my work....... And vantage of say a 60 inch (blade length) horizontal/vertical band saw it you can set up cut and walk away and let it go, and come back in a bit and it is done mean time you has time to sip a bit of coffee or do something else....

Dale
 
Last edited:
   / Smaller metal cutting bandsaw thoughts?
  • Thread Starter
#6  
Bite the bullet and buy a 7x12 horizontal ,vertical band saw . Used $500 new $1000 . Make all the rest of your time in the shop a pleasure.:thumbsup::drink:

I was checking out the craigslit and someone at least within driving distance had a Ramco 8x13. Bigger than what I was going for, but I see your point. 1200 OBO
 
   / Smaller metal cutting bandsaw thoughts?
  • Thread Starter
#7  
I do a lot of cuttings on old Craftsman Professional horizontal band saw..... Got it for $20 because idiot I got it from put blade on backwards and he said it did not cut...

Other option would be chop saw. I have a abrasive one, but If I had to do it again I would have gotten "cold cut" Bit at the time I didn't realize the prows and con of cold cut vs abrasive and let price guide (mistake)...

Worked many hour with a Porter Cable "Porta Band" during my work career, but find in retirement and for property projects it would be nice to have, but I really fine my chop saw and horizontal band saw more useful, only wish for some operation the Craftsman would go vertical but that may be about 1% of my work....... And vantage of say a 60 inch (blade length) horizontal/vertical band saw it you can set up cut and walk away and let it go, and come back in a bit and it is done mean time you has time to sip a bit of coffee or do something else....

Dale

I agree that the dry cut saw is a big notch up from the abrasive wheel. The porta bands that you and others have mentioned just may not be the right tool for me. My problem is I get busy and everything becomes work and maintenance and when I go to craft something, my mind needs a reset. A true artist I am not, though I want to be! I have a small Milwaukee circle saw which is good for thin stuff, a dry cut and a plasma cutter. It seems if I had the time to work with this stuff more, my level of proficiency would improve. The set and and watch the cutter do the work sounds like a good thing to me.
 
   / Smaller metal cutting bandsaw thoughts? #8  
I agree that the dry cut saw is a big notch up from the abrasive wheel. The porta bands that you and others have mentioned just may not be the right tool for me. My problem is I get busy and everything becomes work and maintenance and when I go to craft something, my mind needs a reset. A true artist I am not, though I want to be! I have a small Milwaukee circle saw which is good for thin stuff, a dry cut and a plasma cutter. It seems if I had the time to work with this stuff more, my level of proficiency would improve. The set and and watch the cutter do the work sounds like a good thing to me.

Then you want horizontal band saw....

Dale
 
   / Smaller metal cutting bandsaw thoughts? #9  
Other option would be chop saw. I have a abrasive one, but If I had to do it again I would have gotten "cold cut" Bit at the time I didn't realize the pros and cons of cold cut vs abrasive and let price guide (mistake)...
I did the same thing. I hate my abrasive saw and someday I will replace it with a dry saw or whatever you call them.

I do like my portaband saw. It is pretty much permanently vertically mounted in a SwagOffroad table w/foot switch. Fine for small stuff but a dry cut miter saw with infeed/outfeed roller tables would be nice. A quality horizontal bandsaw would be great but I don't have the real estate.
 
   / Smaller metal cutting bandsaw thoughts? #10  
I have a maybe forty year old WF Wells saw. Also Plasma Cutter, torches and Chinesium Chop Saw. None really get much use. I have friends with better bandsaws and since I get my steel there, it often gets cut.

Am thinking about getting a hand held Cold Saw. Is that even what they are called? Like Milwaukee.

Built a frame with casors for my Wells Horizontal Bandsaw and it mostly lives under some racking out of the way.
 
Last edited:

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

(1) HD 27ft x 24ft Full Garage Kit Metal Building Frame (A51573)
(1) HD 27ft x 24ft...
BESTWAY AG LOT NUMBER 53 (A53084)
BESTWAY AG LOT...
2008 Ford Crown Victoria Sedan (A51694)
2008 Ford Crown...
2019 CATERPILLAR D6N LGP HIGH TRACK CRAWLER DOZER (A51246)
2019 CATERPILLAR...
KUBOTA KX080-4 S2 EXCAVATOR (A51246)
KUBOTA KX080-4 S2...
2000 Thomas Built Saf-T-Liner MVP-ER Transit Passenger Bus (A51692)
2000 Thomas Built...
 
Top