$300,000 pet goat settlement

   / $300,000 pet goat settlement #21  
I can see how the initial events could easily happen with a child in 4H. I was raised in 4H, and in my opinion the Fair Board dropped the ball by not allowing the sale to be reversed (as agreed to by the seller and buyer). It is my understanding that the Fair was offered to be made whole (cut from auction).
The Fair Board should have (at worst) banned the family from auctioning livestock in the future.
Agreed. Buyer and seller were both fine in canceling the sale, and seller offered to make up lost auction fees to the fair. So why is fair stuck in the mud on allowing a harmonious resolution?

The actions of the Sheriff's Dept were ridiculousy over the top for the first attempt to seize the animal, then in violation of the constitution in seizing it at the second location.
The poor sheriff's deputies being sent on a 20 hour round trip to retrieve a goat surely thought this was even more stupid than any of us, but it's their job.

Where they screwed up, and cost their taxpayers $300k, was when they didn't drive home after serving the warrant failed. Choosing to exceed the warrant and drive to a second farm where they had no warrant and no jurisdiction, is what likely opened them up to liability.
 
   / $300,000 pet goat settlement #23  
just following orders, eh?
Your boss tells you to go serve a warrant, you go serve the warrant. They're deputies. It's probable they didn't even know all of the details of the case, prior to it blowing up.
 
   / $300,000 pet goat settlement #24  
Your boss tells you to go serve a warrant, you go serve the warrant. They're deputies. It's probable they didn't even know all of the details of the case, prior to it blowing up.
The problem is that they didn't have a warrant for the location they seized it from... I'm sure they didn't want to waste more time driving back and forth again, but that's what they should have done.
 
   / $300,000 pet goat settlement #25  
From what everyone is saying on FB, it appears that the person who called in the complaint on Peanut is a local girl from here in East Texas. I'm working on a house in Longview right now, and that's where she lives.

When she made the complaint, she bragged about it because she felt that Peanut might have rabbis. After everyone found out that she did this, she apologized and closed all her accounts.
Peanut was Jewish?

(Sorry Mr. Walker, I could not resist. 🤭)

Truth be told, any wild or domestic mammal could carry rabies. However, squirrels rarely carry rabies, same as mice, rats, etc.. rarely.

According to the AVMA:
Approved rabies vaccines are available for cats, dogs, ferrets, horses, cattle and sheep. Licensed oral vaccines are also being used for mass immunization of wildlife, particularly raccoons.

There is no rabies vaccine to give a squirrel.

The only way to check a squirrel for rabies would be to kill it and examine the brain tissue. Same thing for cats, dogs, bats, raccoons, etc.

The thing to do would have been to put the squirrel in quarantine and give any humans that had contact with it rabies shots. That's what we had to do with an unvaccinated kitten we had that tangled with a bat. 6 months of quarantine. All that really meant was we had to keep him in the house and not let anyone that wasn't vaccinated for rabies play with him for 6 months. Easily done.

Anyhow, many states have laws against keeping wildlife as pets. Rabies is the main reason. Wildlife trade is another reason.

Sad for the squirrel and people.
 
   / $300,000 pet goat settlement #26  
NY Post reported yesterday that LA's comptroller wrote that LA paid out $141 million in liability settlements during the first four months of the fiscal year and the city's annual budget is only $87 million. Los Angeles seeks $80M loan as city is ‘growing broke’ amid lawsuit judgment payouts
South Bend, Indiana's (population about 100K) annual budget is over $400 million per year. LA's budget is something like $12 billion per year. Don't know where that $87 million figure came from. Maybe that's just their lawsuit budget?
 
   / $300,000 pet goat settlement #27  
I can see how the initial events could easily happen with a child in 4H. I was raised in 4H, and in my opinion the Fair Board dropped the ball by not allowing the sale to be reversed (as agreed to by the seller and buyer). It is my understanding that the Fair was offered to be made whole (cut from auction).
The Fair Board should have (at worst) banned the family from auctioning livestock in the future.

The actions of the Sheriff's Dept were ridiculousy over the top for the first attempt to seize the animal, then in violation of the constitution in seizing it at the second location.
That's what I was thinking as far as the Fair Board goes.

The Sheriff's actions were a waste of taxpayer money (in my opinion), and then to go to a second location without a warrant... over a fair goat.... yikes.
 
   / $300,000 pet goat settlement
  • Thread Starter
#28  
From someone there...

The county never owned the goat, even if they auctioned it. That's the reason they paid $300,000. The county had no legal claim to seize the goat...

The matter is civil between seller and buyer and the contract stated the county auction would receive a fee based on the sales price... zero ownership to the county.

The buyer did not want the goat slaughtered either.

Several lawyers have also reviewed... county grossly overstepped and now paying.
 
Last edited:
   / $300,000 pet goat settlement #29  
Well, I hope Guiness is listening. I suspect we have a record here, for the most money ever paid for a goat.
 
   / $300,000 pet goat settlement #30  
Well, I hope Guiness is listening. I suspect we have a record here, for the most money ever paid for a goat.
Well looky that....

According to the Guinness World Records, the most money ever paid for a goat was $82,600 for an Angora buck sold in Waitangi, New Zealand
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

UNUSED CFG Industrial XZ20R Mini Excavator (A47384)
UNUSED CFG...
2017 RAM PROMASTER 2500 CARGO VAN (A51222)
2017 RAM PROMASTER...
2023 New Holland CR10.90 Combine - 332 Engine Hours - 244 Separator Hours (A52128)
2023 New Holland...
2016 Nissan Frontier Ext. Cab Pickup Truck (A50323)
2016 Nissan...
2017 UTILITY VS2RA 53FT REEFER TRAILER (A51222)
2017 UTILITY VS2RA...
INSPECTION (A51573)
INSPECTION (A51573)
 
Top