Too bad I missed the beginning of this thread, but it sounded like the guy was going with a Ford. My 2 cents probably don't count because I'm a Ford man through and through, my dad was, his dad was, and his dad had a horse named Ford. (Not really, but if they'd had trucks back then it would have been a Ford.) Anyway, I have a few beefs about Ford none-the-less. They used plastic hubs in their 4X4. I have replaced several hubs in my younger years muddin' in my Fords. I've replaced the transmission in the last three Ford 4X4's I've owned - however, I lay most of that to operator error (towing with OD on, doing stupid stuff in mud). Then I got married and all that foolishness stopped (as far as she knows).
Today I drive a 2001 Ford F-150 SuperCrew 5.8L V8 (black of course). I use it to haul cattle, dad and Papaw have 2004 F-150's (black of course). There is some really good engineering in the newer ones, most have talked about engines and stuff, but one big improvement is the brakes. The rotors are much larger diameter on the newer ones, feels a whole lot better when bringing those cattle to a hault. All in all, the "modern" F-150 is as reliable as you could ask for, and has plenty of power for moderate towing. My buddy has been through 3 Dodges since I bought my Ford and he's not been happy with any of them. From 1500 to 2500 to 3500 dually.
I've got 90K on this one and I'm counting the days until this thing dies so that I can get a 450!!!

But I fear this old truck will last me for many more years now that I'm married and use it responsibly.
Here's some shots of my truck clean, dirty, and hanging out behind the house on my farm...
... oh by the way, tires, not that it's critical, but those are GoodYear MTR's on there, and they are awesome. A bit loud on the road, but get them off road and they won't disappoint