3D Printing Parts

   / 3D Printing Parts #11  
I bought a 3D printer DIY kit back in 2012. The idea was to make a custom prosthetic hand for my amputee father. I downloaded a fully articulating human hand model from thingverse, printed all the pieces of the digits, assembled it, intentionally slammed it in the bathroom door, and it broke. So I spent the next year or so experimenting with every kind of polymer that was available on the market at the time, doing stress tests, measuring elongation, chemical resistance, impact testing, etc.. Some were much stronger than others, but all of them suffered the same flaw. Printed parts, due to the way they're printed layer-by-layer, always have a weak axis. There is no molecular bond between layers; just a "got hot and smooshed together" sort of relationship, resulting in a "grain" like wood, and for anything more trivial than chess pieces you have to devote some careful thought to what axis you'll print a part in, so that the resultant grain is oriented in the direction where it's least like to get broken. But nevertheless it will get broken eventually, if your part is expected to handle real-world abuse from all angles. Something like the human hand (what marvel of engineering! - or bizarre coincidence) endures forces in all axes all day, from within and without. You can dip it in oils, solvents, leave it out in the sun, beat on things with it, absent-mindedly smash it, and it's no worse for wear (usually). It self-repairs, and with no way to replicate that, a prosthesis must be nigh indestructible. No way to do what I wanted with it, so I decided I need a CNC mill to make my parts out of solid materials. 8 years later, still never made a hand (turns out dad wasn't that interested), but now I'm neck deep in a metal machining hobby that I never foresaw myself having. Still have the 3D printer, sitting in a dusty box somewhere. Much prefer to tinker with the mill and the lathe. I'll be building a CNC plasma table this year. It's odd how 3D printing got me into machining; I think the more common avenue is 180 degrees out.

Uh.... no. :laughing: I got my hand caught in a door and it broke pretty easily. 3 pins, a cast for 2 months, and 6 months of therapy, it now works 95%, but a finger will be permanently bent.
 
   / 3D Printing Parts #12  
Have you ever considered using the 3d printer to make molds instead of parts?
 
   / 3D Printing Parts #13  
Have you ever considered using the 3d printer to make molds instead of parts?

I always thought that the 3D printers were to make a prototype to check for fit and suitability, then to use it for casting in some type of metal.
 
   / 3D Printing Parts #14  
I always thought that the 3D printers were to make a prototype to check for fit and suitability, then to use it for casting in some type of metal.

It depends on the materials and the type of 3D printer. For Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM, what this is) with the right plastics, like ABS or Polycarbonate (I use both, with carbon fiber reinforcement) the material properties are good and the part is strong enough for regular use. I make production parts with mine in fact (not for a tractor). I would not hesitate to make things like blinker assemblies, switch boxes, brackets for lightweight parts, knobs for controls, that sort of thing. PLA is the easiest one to print, but it is not as useful since it is pretty brittle and is water soluble IIRC.

I've made rifle parts, fishing lures, rubber band guns, a custom switch panel for my fishing boat, knobs etc. etc. and have about a billion other ideas to try. I design my own parts since I have been a solid modeling user forever (I am a Mechanical Engineer) and am very comfortable with designing parts in CAD.

Another option for CAD modeling is Fusion360 by Autodesk. One can get a license for free for a year for personal use. I am using that now for my personal projects and the user interface is actually very good. I have also used Creo (Pro/ENGINEER) and Solidworks, but those are both very expensive.
 
   / 3D Printing Parts #15  
I always thought that the 3D printers were to make a prototype to check for fit and suitability, then to use it for casting in some type of metal.

It depends on the materials and the type of 3D printer. For Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM, what this is) with the right plastics, like ABS or Polycarbonate (I use both, with carbon fiber reinforcement) the material properties are good and the part is strong enough for regular use. I make production parts with mine in fact (not for a tractor). I would not hesitate to make things like blinker assemblies, switch boxes, brackets for lightweight parts, knobs for controls, that sort of thing. PLA is the easiest one to print, but it is not as useful as ABS or PC since PLA is pretty brittle and is water soluble IIRC.

I've made rifle parts, fishing lures, rubber band guns, a custom switch panel for my fishing boat, knobs etc. etc. and have about a billion other ideas to try. I design my own parts since I have been a solid modeling user forever (I am a Mechanical Engineer) and am very comfortable with designing parts in CAD.

Another option for CAD modeling is Fusion360 by Autodesk. One can get a license for free for a year for personal use. I am using that now for my personal projects and the user interface is actually very good. I have also used Creo (Pro/ENGINEER) and Solidworks, but those are both very expensive.
 
   / 3D Printing Parts #16  
I always thought that the 3D printers were to make a prototype to check for fit and suitability, then to use it for casting in some type of metal.

It depends on the materials and the type of 3D printer. For Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM, what this is) with the right plastics, like ABS or Polycarbonate (I use both, with carbon fiber reinforcement) the material properties are good and the part is strong enough for regular use. I make production parts with mine in fact (not for a tractor). I would not hesitate to make things like blinker assemblies, switch boxes, brackets for lightweight parts, knobs for controls, that sort of thing. PLA is the easiest one to print, but it is not as useful as ABS or PC since PLA is pretty brittle and is water soluble IIRC.

For traditional metal parts it takes something like a ceramic slurry based investment casting or "lost wax process" (wax model printed in 3D printer) to get a good metal casting, like from aluminum for example. Most (all?) of the printable plastics can't take the heat from most molten metals. I think there may be some printers that make models from green ceramic and then they are fired after printing in a kiln. Those might work for metal castings.

Anyway... I've made rifle parts, fishing lures, rubber band guns, a custom switch panel for my fishing boat, knobs etc. etc. and have about a billion other ideas to try. I design my own parts since I have been a solid modeling user forever (I am a Mechanical Engineer) and am very comfortable with designing parts in CAD.

Another option for CAD modeling is Fusion360 by Autodesk. One can get a license for free for a year for personal use. I am using that now for my personal projects and the user interface is actually very good. I have also used Creo (Pro/ENGINEER) and Solidworks, but those are both very expensive.
 
   / 3D Printing Parts #17  
Have you ever considered using the 3d printer to make molds instead of parts?

I did consider that, it's been quite a while so I don't remember specifically why I decided, but with with some reason I decided that still wasn't good enough. IIRC the plastics which can be cold pour-molded still aren't strong enough and the specific type of plastic I deemed most appropriate needed to be injection molded at liquid/spooge heat into a metal mold, and that was one of the things I intended go try with the CNC.
 
   / 3D Printing Parts #18  
Made this clip on my 3D printer to hold down the PTO lever on my GC1705. Got the program from another member here that made one.
C95E6353-8623-43BE-AF89-F22BC39C473E.jpg
 
   / 3D Printing Parts #20  
Well I don't print parts, have not ventured there yet as I don't need to.... But a while back my old Craftsman band saw shredded a bevel drive gear, and Craftsman/Sears or Atlas Tools no longer makes a replacement gear, and then I found online source that actually printed replacement gears.... IT was so precision it almost didn't fit saw, anyway way it works flawlessly since install.... I think many issues with people disappointment for printed parts may be poorly designed (cheap) printers or not great understanding of materials use ....

Dale
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

1997 Ford LT9000 T/A Day Cab Truck Tractor (A44571)
1997 Ford LT9000...
2012 UTILITY 53X102 REEFER TRAILER (A43004)
2012 UTILITY...
New/Unused Pallet Forks (A44391)
New/Unused Pallet...
2017 MINI Countryman Hatchback (A44572)
2017 MINI...
2019 KENWORTH T680 TANDEM AXLE SLEEPER (A43003)
2019 KENWORTH T680...
2014 KENWORTH T680 SLEEPER (A43004)
2014 KENWORTH T680...
 
Top