B2710 (B Series) front axle klunking noise......

   / B2710 (B Series) front axle klunking noise...... #1  

dan279

Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
31
I am a licensed A&P mechanic, so get ready for an earfull. My B2710 has 800 hours on it and has always been operated with manufacturer's suggested limits. The rear R4 tires are filled with beat juice and alot of the tractors use has been devoted to hauling loads with the FEL downhill. The heavier loads were transported down hill backwards (700-800 pound range) while the lighter loads (400-500 pounds) were transported downhill in the forward direction, both on Low -4WD. The slope of the concrete driveway is a 15 degree incline and about 200 yards in length. There was a klunking noise coming from the front axle bevel gear assemblies which was synchronous with the front wheel's rotation and at time slippage was heard and felt as the tractor went down the driveway even without a load. I removed the front tires and pulled each bevel gear housing on the front axle assembly. I then proceeded to disassemble each bevel gear housing and inspected the gears and bearings.

The wheel ring gears were severely worn to the extent where 7-9 teeth had broken off and the shaft gears were severely worn. The ring gears were taken to the metallurgy lab and X-RAYED. Unacceptable fissures were found in the ring gears eminating from the casting process at the time the gears were manufactured. Both ring gears and shaft gears were replaced along with the bearings, shims, O-rings and seals. The total repair time was about 2 hours.
The parts cost was close to 2000 dollars. The ring and shaft gears have to be purchased as a machined set.

My advice is that when you buy a Kubota tractor, you spend a few hours and disassemble the front wheel bevel gear housing and have the ring gears inspected for casting fissures and cracks, either by X-RAY, ultrasonic or eddy current testing. If any fissures are detected, document your findings and return the tractor.
It is only a few hours of work with a good set of snap ring pliers. Metallurgy cost and analysis is about 250-500 dollars and well worth it. It can save your life. I was very close to a downhill run-a-way tractor with a load in the front end loader using 4WD.
 
   / B2710 (B Series) front axle klunking noise...... #2  
Dan you should have just done one post! Reading your prior posts tends to lead a different warm fuzzy feeling!! Do you own a tractor?
 
   / B2710 (B Series) front axle klunking noise......
  • Thread Starter
#3  
I timed out when typing the text. Yes I own a B2710. I have photos of the ring gears.
 
   / B2710 (B Series) front axle klunking noise......
  • Thread Starter
#4  
All the teeth were worn beyond limits and 7-9 had completely broken off. You guys need to look closer at the crap your buying!
 
   / B2710 (B Series) front axle klunking noise......
  • Thread Starter
#5  
I have read some similar complaints here about this problem, but no one really posted an authoritative response to any concerns members expressed.
So here you have one.
 
   / B2710 (B Series) front axle klunking noise...... #6  
Dan in early 09 in a post you stated that you have had this problem several times before! Now again you state that you have it again!

Normally tires don't roll off rims unless they are low on air or overloaded.

I'm just puzzled why you keep running into the same problem?

I guess I'd be getting rid of your Kubota and headed down to your deere dealer as you satated before, they don't have that problem according to you in a post from last April.
 
   / B2710 (B Series) front axle klunking noise......
  • Thread Starter
#7  
That was a different issue. The front tires separated from the rims when scooping up snow..very common occurance with any tractor without tubes...that happens with my B2710 and B7800 when plowing deep snow in a sharp turn. Tubes installed....no longer an issue. What do you do? Just look at your tractor in a barn?
 
   / B2710 (B Series) front axle klunking noise......
  • Thread Starter
#8  
I would be happy to send ya the photos of the ring gears.....My email....dan279@yahoo.com
 
   / B2710 (B Series) front axle klunking noise......
  • Thread Starter
#9  
Kubota's bevel gear design does not buy you that much anyway...just a tighter turning radius. more problems than it's worth.
 
   / B2710 (B Series) front axle klunking noise...... #10  
I would be happy to send ya the photos of the ring gears.....My email....dan279@yahoo.com

Why not just post the photos here? As opposed to popping up every couple months, bashing Kubota, and disappearing for a while?
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2018 John Deere 245G LC Excavator - Hydraulic Thumb, Tooth Bucket, 56K LB Class (A52128)
2018 John Deere...
2008 Ford F-350 4x4 Crew Cab Pickup Truck (A50323)
2008 Ford F-350...
AGT Agrotk 680 Drop Hammer Attachment (A47384)
AGT Agrotk 680...
2019 FORD F550 XL SERVICE TRUCK (A51243)
2019 FORD F550 XL...
2016 Dodge Charger Sedan (A50324)
2016 Dodge Charger...
2000 FORD F450 SUPER DUTY SINGLE CAB FLATBED TRUCK (A51406)
2000 FORD F450...
 
Top