What's sad is how many people actually believe this.
It goes along with the ME attitude. What is theirs is theirs and what is yours is theirs if they can get it.
Why do people think they should be allowed to fish your pond(s) if they ask instead of just trespassing?
Look at all the time and effort Eddie put in to get his nice pond up to where it is now. It wasn't easy or free. Same for me even if on a smaller scale. Who buys the fish to stock my ponds, who mows the dams, repairs the dams, spillways, emergency overflows, etc? Who buys the feed and puts it out?
I have a freezer with food in it. I have a bank account with money in it. I have a couple guest rooms too. Would it be appropriate for just anyone to ask me for rummaging privileges in my freezer, refrigerator, or a little access to my bank account or how about bringing some friends over for a stay in my guest rooms? All these things may be offered to whom I choose but certainly aren't the sort of things random passers by should expect is theirs for the taking (trespassing) or should AUTOMATICALLY be given access because they ask.
What is the difference between theft of my property (say some tools or whatever) and sneaking in and taking my fish? What is the difference between asking me if it is OK to use my tools and shop and catch and release? ...the difference between taking my fish and taking any other property of mine?
I wonder how the people who want to fish my ponds would respond if I mentioned I have some friends I'd like to bring to their house to rummage through their kitchen to see if there is something we may like.
I have less than 10 different people who can fish my place just about anytime they ask. They don't litter, rut the fields when the ground is soft, or cause any problems. One guy called while I was writing this to get permission to launch a small boat and take his 7 year old grandson fishing. He is a retired educator and very respectful of my property so I have never refused him.
I really don't like to refuse folks and would rather they just not ask. This applies to strangers mostly as my friends would never be refused.
Pat